DuplicateValue said:
I agree, classics are highly overrated.
The only horror movie to actually scare me was The Descent, so maybe give that a try.
Awww man, same.
OP: It depends what scares you. Do religiousy demon related films give you chills or do films which could happen scare you? I hate the idea of being stuck in a cave anyway, not to mention in darkness and with weird things trying to kill you.
I've read and watched a lot of horror. It was my favourite genre for some time. To be honest, not many horror movies are good. Once you've lost your innocence (ie, when you know what is going to happen, you can count the moments of suspense and not jump when the loud noise springs out on you and when you know it's just a movie) a lot of the films lose their edge.
Personally, I'd go with the Del Torro movies. They're chilling and poignant if not terrifying all the way through and good to watch with friends because you can chat about it after.
But then I'm distinguishing Horror from Gore. Gore makes you cringe. Horror for me, gives me chills after the movie has finished and makes you think twice about putting your feet on the floor when you're in bed in case there is something there. Gore is a good part of horror if done correctly, but sometimes it fails, like Hostel, or Saw sequels. It's schlock horror and gore for the sake of using gore.
But if you're after Gore... Hah! Pretty much anything on the horror shelf with 'Saw' in the title, or with Rob Zombie as a director will hit the spot. Peter Jackson's early work is good for it too. And check online for banned films. They might be aged now, but the content is pretty horrific still. I think there are boxsets on sale of films that were banned at some point.
Personally I like 'Boo' - a pretty poorly known film set around Halloween and based in an abandoned mental asylum. Not a great film, but a good little watch. And I also really liked 'Th13teen Ghosts'. Try 'Shrooms' too.