Guy Jackson said:
holy_secret said:
Garrus and Tali were not bangable in the first game, yet became so in the second game. Does this mean they were rewritten to be interested in Shep?
Umm, yeah, actually, that's exactly what it means.
I wanted Tali to be romancable in ME1, but she wasn't and there wasn't even any chemistry. Then in ME2 they just ditched all that and crowbar'd a romance in there. I'd rather they'd stayed true to the original character.
That's not rewriting, that's developing the character. Tali and Garrus' interest/disinterest in shepard was not a subject covered in the first game; There is no evidence to show they were interested in Shepard, but neither was their evidence that they were not. They obviously didn't plan the romance options ahead of time, but I think they handled including them in a believable enough way. In Tali's case, she simply has a crush on Shepard, which is perfectly reasonable for Shepard to miss. When this crush developed is pure speculation, but I doubt it was during the events of the first game. She suppressed her feelings because she did not see a way their relationship could work. Knowing she is interested in him changes the way shepard feels about her. In Garrus' case, he did not see shepard in that way until she came on to him. Even then, it's more about casual sex.
Sure they didn't plan it, and I'm sure they would have left clues in ME1 if they had, but I really don't see any major problems with the way they developed the characters.
The only thing that kinda bugs me is how Garrus and Tali had no problem shacking up with Shep while knowing about his current relationship with Liara/Kaidan/Ashley. Maybe cheating isn't a big deal for Quarians/Turians. I'm sure there will be some Jerry Springer moments in Mass Effect 3...