SomeUnregPunk said:
i know this off topic but I want to know why people still love this series? I watched up to but not including the newest season. I just didn't want to watch it anymore, the same thing happened for me with Heroes or Alias. ... they came a point where the story got or became too retarded to watch.
I found Heroes pretty horrible after the first season, but I don't think Battlestar Galactica has declined in quality. There's been a huge amount of progression, a bit of retconning, potential unresolved plot holes and a few lows here and there, but it's still managed to remain one incredible.
Why do I love Battlestar Galactica? I feel it's one of the most human and relatable shows on television, it's easily the
most intense show on television, it's been pushing the boundaries of what you can do and say on TV for a while now (when people say frak, we definitely get the point), it's visually stunning, and I love the moral and political dilemmas that constantly arise throughout the series. The show is never preachy. It always remains ambiguous, and never gives you any answers... It just gives you balanced arguments and lets you make the decisions for themselves. No two people will take out of Battlestar Galactica the same things. No two people will agree on all the issues.
Week after week it's been the only show that fills me both with a sense of dread and a sense of hope. I love the dialogue, I actually care what happens to the characters, and it's the most mature thing I've seen on TV. It makes almost every other show on right now look like crap.
Name a show that has had equal parts drama, action, solid story-telling, and such strong philosophic undertones... I used to love Heroes, but you can't compare it to Battlestar Galactica.
What part of BSG do you find retarded? The first half of season 4 was a little weak, but overall, the series has really set a new standard for quality, I think.