I can't wait to see Norman snap. It seems like he's quickly approaching his wits end.
Westfall really changed with the cataclysm, and not for the better. I recently did this quest on my low level human paladin. It really is there, and it is really this dumb. Normally I try not to think too much about quests like this, but this one literally makes no sense. Why not bring the carcass back for them to butcher and eat? Why not just grab the pumpkins that are sitting not 10 feet away? I won't spoil what happens next, but it's kinda disturbing.
I'm now seriously considering dropping the human storyline on him and going to play with the night elves. At least their quests (for the most part) make sense.