So, the Joker.
Good thing they cut it out, because the idea of a 2 year old Batman already having faced and beaten the Joker is really stupid.
As for the performance itself, it comes off as a slightly accented, younger Ledger. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but I would have thought they'd want to really differentiate him this time. We're really not gonna get an actual Clown Prince of Crime here I feel, with how gross this Joker looks.
Think it depends on how evolved a character Joker is at this point. The big negative for me is the Make up prosthetics are pretty rough. You can clearly tell its all rubber. Look at his forehead. Maybe they would have done some CGI clean up to make his face move a little more. As it is, his face has no expression which I think is key to the character. Health ledgers character was insanely expressive in everything hed did, ironically despite the mouth prosthesis, but Health did a good job of working it into the way he talked.
I can see the idea, Joker gives him a bunch of hints that kinda roll right over him. I can also see why they cut it. Just not necessary to the story. I think if they did this scene theyd need to reference it somehow earlier in the film to foreshadow a previous event, why its a big deal that Batman is coming to see this person. Otherwise the audience doesn't have any context other than "meta". The other characters in the film work without any fan context, this guy just..idk, he's not compelling, at least with the scene were given. Without a previous film hes just goofy looking nobody with an annoying laugh. He just doesn't have any presence.
I was onboard with the idea of Jared letos Joker because this was supposed to be a kind of modern take on DC. At least it would have been something different. This just feels that CW joker, though I only watched a scene or two before I'd had enough of him.
I have a feeling Matt Revees is not going to do Joker. I think its widely accepted as a dead horse and the scene we got in the film was a tease for the fans. If they decide to go forward with a Joker I'd like him to be more sinister, something reminiscent the of the Joker in DKR maybe that combined with the younger version seen in Return of the Joker.
Heath Ledgers joker as he states the film was more an Agent of Chaos, he liked the idea of putting people in situations that drove them over the edge, He rarely even kills anyone that isn't a bad or in his way.
I'd rather they mold something else, Like David Bowie's look mixed with Hannibal Lector.