Goofguy said:
The AC series is pretty much built on its urban set pieces so playing an assassin through the American Revolution and the Spanish colonization of the Americas wouldn't really appeal to me.
The Aztec capital, Tenochtitlan, was twice the size of the largest European cities at the time, had sophisticated irrigation, levee and aqueduct systems, and several dozen important public buildings. It more than meets the criteria for the setting of an AC game.
Puzzlenaut said:
There isn't really any way that the narrative can allow a game set in Feudal Japan. Not only that, however, but its a tired and used setting (mainly in Japanese media, of course) that wouldn't lend itself well to the AC series, which is brilliant at urban areas and fairly poor at anything else.
Edo(Tokyo) during the height of the Tokugawa Shogunate was the largest city in the world at the time. It was the size of London and Paris put together, and was 5-10 times larger than most other major European cities. Osaka and Kyoto were also the size of the largest European cities. Granted Edo was much smaller during the Sengoku period proposed, but Japanese cities were still quite large and feature interesting buildings and fortifications that would be fun to run and jump all over.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_urban_community_sizes
Get_A_Grip_ said:
I think the American Revolution setting would work as it's the only remaining option for Desmond's acestry... That doesn't seem ridiculous.
Late 19th/ Early 20th century Russian ancestors would seem a bit odd...
Unless Desmond's great-grandparents were Ukrainian immigrants who changed their name from Milovchuk to Miles, for example.
Gecko clown said:
The the victorian empire one because then you'd get the chance to go to Britain, India, Australia, Canada, Africa, America and a ton of other places to.
This would be the only reason I'd get behind Victorian England: if they actually showed the extent of the British Empire and made you travel between global population centres by steamship and rail. Victorian London itself is way overdone (and I say this as a dyed-in-the-wool steampunk).
Captain Booyah said:
FRENCH REVOLUTION, YOU BASTARDS. I'm never going to get a game set there, am I? ;__;
Yeah, I want that too but I guess we're not getting it. You'd think Alexandre Dumas/Scarlet Pimpernel-style swashbuckling and undercover work would be a natural fit for the series, but apparently the
giant French video game publisher doesn't agree.
Personally, I'm curious to see a Western developer do a well-researched, historical game set in China or Japan. Alternatively, if a more modern setting is called for, Revolutionary Russia is interesting, or more broadly, anything set during World War I. I've had my fill of WWII in video games and don't really need to see anymore for a good long while.