reading the first page of comments, i'm amazed only about 2 people noticed, well, thats what you get for spending your time on the internet -
Gaary: well, i guess i owe Romin $5...
you guys are morons for not realising - they were having a debate about alternate timelines in an erlier episode - thats what's happened, the portal was to a different time period, creating an alternate time line - petey was not eaten and hence is still there (though may not be dead in the original time-line, just in the fish), and does not know eluamous.
simple -.-
Gaary: well, i guess i owe Romin $5...
you guys are morons for not realising - they were having a debate about alternate timelines in an erlier episode - thats what's happened, the portal was to a different time period, creating an alternate time line - petey was not eaten and hence is still there (though may not be dead in the original time-line, just in the fish), and does not know eluamous.
simple -.-