Monoochrom said:
So, yes, obviously you aren't interested in Feedback if that is how you react to it. Neither of you came to the conclussion to ask WHY I wouldn't describe any of you as insightful or talented writers. Go ahead and point out what errors I might have in my Forum post (because I really have alot of reason to pay attention to that, huh?), I'm not asking for money for it or that anyone consider it professional level writing.
Not to butt in, but... well, yeah, actually, butting in here:
Seems to me you're not interested in providing "feedback" to either of these guys -- at least not in any useful way. What you've provided is an insult (or at best a "complaint"). Yet then you feign surprise when they don't immediately rush to find out the justification behind your feelings?
You didn't present what they can do better, or even any
specific grievance you have with how they do things now. You just said what basically amounts to, "You're not very good," and then make a pretty ballsy
assumption about the inner financial workings of the publication itself.
You know what that sounds like from the outside?
NOT the start of a "conversation," that's for sure. It sounds like someone who already thinks they know it all, and they're gonna tell you how it is... and that isn't much fun. That's, you know, the kind of person that doesn't really pay much attention to feedback...?
If I had some tips on how you could optimize your living room furniture arrangement, I could say, "Hey, here are some tips I have to blah blah blah." Uninvited? Sure. A little rude? Eh, "presuming" might be a better word. But it could start a conversation that leads to a productive conclusion.
Now, if I stomp into your living room uninvited and throw one of your chairs across the room and say, "This place sucks," how likely do you think we are to have a conversation? No matter how good my advice would have been, you're going to deal with my prickishness
first -- because that's what I led with. I did not begin from a place of helpfulness, or with any manners whatsoever.
Just some, y'know, "feedback." Please consider.