I'm going to stop this one right here. Not because you aren't wrong (you are right), nor do I not want to continue this (I do), but this reply will be short, curt and to the point. I mean you, in particular, no ill will for this curtness, since, you are right but I will say two things, the first of which is that I will elaborate on the second point at a later point of my choosing, which is thus (and not entirely aimed at you, hence the apology, 'likes!' and promise of actual picking up of this later because...)
*I need to not be banned for this post so while not formatted as such please let it be read by your internal monolog as a low, angry shout uttered through clenched teeth*
"wow, I never had thought of that how bizarre we might have to put you under guard somewhere secret since the guy in the white house may get word that there may be a playoff for the fifa world piss off cup and he might get jealous enough to send the 5th fleet and an entire meu to get you like he did maduro. Now, before you fend them all off successfully with your cheap off the counter drone fleet, can you please explain to me how to escape this chinese finger trap? the concept of "come together good, pull apart bad" is too large a concept to fit into my equally 3yr old mind and I need help please before you are made emperor of mankind of the imperium of man and are unreachable"
I will no longer be replying to you on any matter even remotely related to military affairs, ever, and please gerg do NOT reply to this post. While I have no members of this forum on mute and will continue to do so, you will still be absolutely ignored.
And come down here too, Thaluikhain, because while this post wasn't entirely aimed at you...
View attachment 14127
I am quite fucking miffed, not a lot, but certainly more than a trifle. And not because of anything in this thread (see above reply to yourself) but rather that one reply you gave me in the shower thoughts thread the other night. It seems weird to bring up now, but is on topic (not the thread itself, sorry, lol) but at least this post itself in that, like the reply to gerg above so sarcastically put it...
I
Know
Obviously, everything can be broken down to be made to fit anything else. I know that the thought is weird on it's face and didn't make sense.
That was the point; it's a shower thought.
And while yes you can absolutely wonder about and question what the fuck exactly I meant or even why I care this much, I will at least answer the latter because it's why I'm so fucking mad at gerg above.
Please, do not talk down to people, certainly not so condescendingly.
Please. Everyone reading this, I'm begging you.
Because yes, while I am absolutely aware that my thought was vague, weird, and more than likely wrong, you did not, at all at the time and probably not since, thought to ponder on it more than what you personally thought and did not think to ask me for why this was so (either the thought in question or its weirdly curt nature)
And this seems weirdly personal to get hung up on in a post that has what, on the surface at least, looks like more of the same. But...look...that post (and other shower thought post like it) was structured the was it on purpose for a specific reason:
Makes you think.
Or, at least it's supposed to. Conversation itself, and, again..., the human condition itself, and it's success can be summed up as the weirdly short nonsensical statement. Because thus is how our species on the whole actually evolves, not because of some strange little things like spleens or disappearing toes or some such, because those are just the fun little things on top of the most base thing in nature, and in fact entirely predicated and being able to acheive:
Survival
Because, fuck evolution, that shit is a bonus you get, a little treat, after the fucking nightmare that is existence as a whole. It's rough. It's bloody. It's a disgusting mess and a necessary evil for all living things to need to destroy other living things. And if you can't survive, you die, end of the road, do not pass your genes and do not collect $200 millions of years down the line when you figure all of the necessary bits out to even get to the rough concept of exchange, let alone actual cold hard cash. And thus...
Consider a ship...
And this is why
I
Am
Constantly
Enraged
All the time, everywhere, at everything, all at once.
Because, yes gerg, teamwork does infact make the dream work. It's how we even got to this fuckog point at all, where we can scream at each over a fucking distance measured in hundreds of thousands of miles apart near instantaneously.
So why, then, fire rockets at each other? Fuck the ship for a moment, humanity's real closest metaphorical neighbor is that fucking finger trap, and like the cartoon episode I watched in my formative years taught me (Dexter's Laboratory), that, while yes, the finger is stupidly, and so obviously easy a solution to figure out even bickering siblings can come together, it still takes then way to fucking long to come tona conclusion so blisteringly obvious. Why? Why is that?
Imagine with me now, a sweater.
Now, this thread is starting to pop off wildly and this post is both long, and while (outwardly, at least, bare with me all the way through here now, for real though.) this post is veering wildly off topic to dangerous degrees, please follow with me a little longer now, I promise it will be worth it. I will, as one last sign of genuine trust and as a furthering of the messages I will be putting on the forum in the coming weeks I invite any interested members of this forum, the wider internet traveling population, come follow me to the shower thoughts real quick. Before we go and as actual evidence of the goodwill on offer;
Gerg, while those cheap drones are actually about as much of a genuine threat as you think they are, top brass, everywhere, already know this. Both in the sense that everyone and their mothers dog wants that sweet cheap suicide drone swarm, they also have had to contend with similar things for far, far, fffaaarrr longer than you are giving them credit for, and entirely due to the most recent war, so instead of replying to me with what you think you know, consider the following (I will be using this and similar phrases quite often for the forseeable future and as a key right now for this post is thus: think about this. Actually think, like break it down literally like a child with constant, stupid, easy sounding questions; what, why, who, how, when, etc. And like a child, accept no answer as the right one and keep pushing with the stupid questions. Combine the above simple questions together to try and form more complex thoughts. I promise to make this pay off (or at least will try to, anyway. Horse, water, and the man is not at all bright himself));
Drones such as Shaed are can be countered in one of two ways, soft and hard. Soft counters are electronic based systems typically today and as such, right now, are constantly evolving, both in the counters themselves and counter-counters designed to get past them. We will thus ignore them for this discussion. Hard counters are systems designed to physically destroy the target, usually be means of lead believed really fast but anything that physically hits to cause damage can be counted thusly.
Consider a drone; it's a small, remotely operated and independently powered aircraft, usually armed or the aircraft itself may even be armed. They are small, cheap, easy to manufacture and store, and worst of all, can be made with off the shelf parts consumers/civilians may have access to (up to and including explosive payload). There are videos all over the web of them maiming and killing hundreds of troops, and even can be seen regularly blowing up full blown, million dollar pieces of equipment. Keep considering the drone, and follow along below;
Consider those counters (hard especially, but even soft though it will continue to not be expanded upon at this time) again.
Easiest way to put lead on flying aircraft, found out quite early on*, is either a gun on the ground, firing up (the gun/what is fired does not matter, everything at one point or another has been tryed). Best guns for purpose are either smaller calibers fired fast enough to saturate an area an aircraft might be found in, or really large guns firing explosive shells with enough shrapnel to replace the lead of the former.
Consider the US Navy; it's a strange lot these days. Not a lot of boats (no multiple layers of gun defences), most of the small boats they do have have to travel long distances over open water and can be seen from space (not being seen, to finally touch on it once and for all, is still the first and sometimes best soft counter/counter-counter), and wosrt of all, the most important big boats are glorified aircraft landing strips (aircraft while good at taking out other aircraft are always, themselves, aircraft and subject to the same basic law of up and always coming back down, sometimes are bits and pieces of wreckage).
While you think about all that, I will leave you with two bits of reading material, warmest wishes, and the hope you never engage me on military matters ever again.
How the USS Cole got bombed, while at anchor, in Port, controlled by friendly hands (pay close attention to lessons the Navy learned from this)
And finally, to show how long this has been a known problem with solutions worked out*, the chapter from Red Storm Rising, "Vampire!", consider the word vampire and its use here, and please, again most of all,
Never reply to me again on matters of military or related subjects, because I will certainly not be replying to yours.
EDIT: as a further adder on from the other post... a couple of little bits shuffled left or right from original post after rediscovery of its survival and further quiet shaking of head at stupid ass self.
Ugh...
EDIT 2: always something to forget...
*WWI, the second bullet point reference to this point is to consider...just...ask yourself why I would reference a, by the time the book (written at height of Cold War) also has a passing mention of WWI, in relation to said book (featuring modern day for the time jet aircraft), for a chapter with a name of a spooky creature that will at no point in the chapter titled with its name, make an appearance in? I will at no point answer this for you or otherwise hand hold further. Big boy pants time for you