I would say that GOOD KNIGHTS QUEST is overall at best very average, I had no real interest in watching the series the whole way through when it first started whereas I was on the edge of my seat waiting for DOOMSDAY ARCADE every time. It wasn't until I decided to enter this years competition that I went back and watched the whole of GKQ and I have to say that overall ... at best it's very average. I don't even think it's particularly well made they just have some good equipment which hardly qualifies. Don't get me wrong it's not a bad show, it's perfectly watchable, but is that really good enough?
Just adding on I also found this site through Zero Punctuation, in fact it's still the only series I regularly watch. I come on the site every week to watch that and randomly watch a couple of other things whilst I'm here. That's not to say I'm not a fan of the other series on here I just usually come on to this site with the intention of watch ZP and it's pretty obvious I'm not alone there.
Here's a few more of my thoughts on the handful I haven't yet reviewed in the order they appear. This is just the videos from page one and half of two, hopefully I'll get round to writing some more soon:
TRAILER MASTER - not really sure why this got a "first cut" ribbon, that's not to say it's bad I'm just not sure why it's somehow better than the others of it's ilk. As review/talky shows go BEFORE IT WAS FILM, THEY OLD and WHAT THE DILLIO are certainly no worse than this (if not perhaps slightly better), so the only reason I can see for TRAILER MASTER being in the "first cut" is that unlike those this one's actually about video games. Although OPINIONATED REVIEWS made it into "first cut" and that's about TV so I don't know, maybe they picked them out of a hat.
PRESS TO CONTINUE - this is alright, at the very least it's quite unique and I did kind of enjoy playing along, but I can't see myself going out of my way to tune in every week. It seems like the idea might get a little old with no real competition involved.
OPINIONATED REVIEWS - another Yahtzee clone (no shortage of those on the internet) but this is certainly the best written that I've seen. The animation set up is a little choppy in places so I would guess it was a learn by doing situation. It's very good, but do we need it?
SECRETS OF THE VIRTUAL PAST - the lowest production value of the "first cut" selection which begs the question as to why some of the other dodgy looking videos didn't make the "first cut". This film feels a little like the token low production value entrant put in for affirmative action purposes only. None the less it's a pretty good mockumentary, a genre I'm something of a fan of, the presenter character is well defined and it's pretty well written with some good jokes and some not so good ones. Assuming the series would break away from the documentary segments and focus a little more on the disfunctional character of the presenter I think this could be really interesting.
TALES FROM THE TABLE - despite being a D&Der myself this didn't click for me. That's not me saying that I felt I was being made fun of, I'm a fan of UNFORGOTTEN REALMS and the like, I just wasn't clear on the motivations of the characters and thus where the show is going. Are we dealing with a hardcore DM trying to lead a band of dysfunctional idiots who seem to be almost trying to screw his game up, or is it about the lives of these dysfunctional idiots and D&D is merely the one thing they have in common. Either way is fine it just felt spread a little thin, also the characters seem pretty into the game but none of them really seem to understand how to play and I'm not sure how that works. Basically it's very well made, has good characters and performances, I'm just a little unsure of the context of what's going on and thus found it hard to get into.
BREAKING BLIZZARD - competently made (despite the sound edit losing it in places) but ultimately not very engaging. The dialogue and the actors do a good job and it's nice to see some more three dimensional characters and plot taking place here. It's good but the way it's shot is very boring to look at and really kind of let's it down.
RADIOGAME THEATRE - this strikes me as a really good idea because it's something you could have on whilst doing other things, so essentially it's a podcast. Not having to watch the video could make this very popular as people could just put it on let it run whilst they work or whatever and the relative cheap nature of simply recording voiceover means the episodes could be considerably longer than most other things on here (if they wanted to be of course). The piece itself is pretty funny and well written so I think this could work. I can see this being an additional winner offered a contract as well just to create podcast style material for the escapist rather than a new video.
SHOW ABOUT GAMES SHOW - is pretty good, well shot and edited but for a sketch show there was no big laugh for me, by which I mean the joke that I go away and tell all my friends they have to see, but all the gags are well thought out and very funny (trials HD guy is great), certainly would be a good addition to the videos on this site.
PLAY TILL YOU DIE - it's all right, not sure the point of it and don't think it would make much of a series but it kept me watching all the way to the end. Not much else I can say really, kind of bland.
SUNDER - a good effort but with the exception of a few not particularly good jokes it's played straight and that doesn't really work. If you want to make a serious show you've got to have better acting and whilst the shot composition is okay the editing is pretty bad. The effects work well enough, there's certainly the early signs of some skill, I just think that with it's constraints this would have worked better as more of a comedy.
DEMON'S SOULS COMMENTARY - why is this TEN MINUTE video still up here? For fucks sake take it down.
VOYEUR - I don't get it, why is this meant to sound like a good idea? Sorry mate, you seem like a cool guy, but I'm not really buying into this concept.
THE DISK - vaguely competent in it's design, characters are pretty bland though but that could be an acting issue. It's somewhat loose connection to gaming could be what let's it down in the eyes of the judges but the idea is pretty solid even though the script has it's flaws. The problem is I'm not really sure what it's trying to be, it seems serious but it goes comedy in places and the ending is just kind of weird.
PROTYPE - it's quite amusing to watch the struggle to get to the end of the level and the commentary is quite funny in its frustration but I don't think there's a series in this. But thanks for the vid, was entertaining.
INTERNET WARZ - pretty dodgy animation but kind of works anyway. I did get to the end not really sure what it was all about, I'm assuming this was intended purely to introduce the character types who will fill the series and it's kind of funny in places but gets a little repetitive and felt like it went on for ages, which isn't good. Writings okay though so could come good in the end.
BETA - mentioned this before as the best structured of the game designer/writer sitcom selection, and it is that. The acting is pretty good and the characters are well written, it's not massively funny but it is entertaining so I'd certainly be interested in watching more.