What is so great about Anime?

Broken Dreamer

New member
Jul 7, 2010
12
0
0
Anime is a broad medium, to say that Azumanga Diaoh is to Charlie brown as Naruto is to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. There are some exampled of animation, and eastern animation being used for artistic or valuable narrative. Most anime is crap just as most noth american animation is crap and most television is crap. It's not the medium that's to blame, it's the quality of the product.

I'd suggest you check out Ghost in the Shell. The art is fantastic, and the narrative deals with an explorations of what it is that defines humanity. Naruto has saturday morning art and discusses who is the most baddest assed ninja EVAR. Probably not a topic you would care about unless you had an attachment to the characters.

If you want some examples of what I consider good western animation, I'd probably pick one of the better episodes of Futurama, Either Luck of the Fryish, or Leela's Home world.

I hope my rant was of some value to you.
 

CJ1145

Elite Member
Jan 6, 2009
4,051
0
41
Texas America Murphy said:
OH GOD YOU'RE RIGHT! I AM ASHAMED! I AM SO VERY ASHAMED!
Sarcasm gets a fool nowhere. Right now you are about hip-deep in quicksand. If you're going to go on a rant and generalize, don't be surprised if you're called out on it, which I'm sure you have been dozens of times over through the course of this thread.
 

Jfswift

Hmm.. what's this button do?
Nov 2, 2009
2,396
0
41
I only really enjoy a handful of Animes. What I feel their strength is over live action movies is that they can get away with showing fantasic worlds with much less difficulty (because it's animated). The few decent ones that I'd recommend are Moribito, Mushi-Shi, and Wolf's Rain. Oh yea Initial D which explores the mountain racing culture of Japan. These are a bit more serious and have a story to tell so check them out if you want a second opinion.
 

Peteron

New member
Oct 9, 2009
1,378
0
0
Its not really anime that is special. I just enjoy a few specifics, as I do movies and games.
 

lolnoobzor

New member
Apr 12, 2010
16
0
0
Given your afore-mentioned ignorance of anime, I would like to introduce you to the classifications and tropes that constitute it's various genres. In complete weeaboo style, I'll use the japanese terms, but I hope, Mr. Texas Sir, you'll recognize the fellow snob in me, that I may help guide you away from mediocrity.

The most common genre, and the most popular one, is named 'shonen', or literally 'young boy', since it's aimed at the young male demographic. You seem to have already experienced some of it's horrors. There are several tropes that help define the genre:

A young ( often male ) protagonist, also often a whiny immature pr#!&, which makes sense since he's meant to be 'relatable' to 13 yr-old kids. Also makes 'friends' during his 'adventure', whose main purpose is to spend half the episode explaining in detail what you just saw, in case you are blind. See below, slow plot.

Slooooooooooooooooooooooow plot, interspersed with filler. I believe it's a consequence of how most shonen are adapted from their comic form, where over-extending the plot means more books people have to buy. A joke a friend of mine came up with: How many saiyan does it take to change a lightbulb? One, but it takes him 6 episodes.

Fanservice seems to be omnipresent, but sometimes it's toned down to tolerable levels. Sometimes. Other times, you get steaming piles of it, like in High School of the Dead, where there is more time given over to fanservice than plot in most episodes. Also see above: slow plot.

Crack. Well, that's at least how I decided to call it. It's the adrenaline rush the viewer feels when their relatable protagonist finally starts beating back the much more powerful ( initially ) antagonist. This is the main reason people watch it, and it also leads to what is called DBZ-syndrome, which means that as the protagonists gain power, more and more ridiculous antagonists have to be conjured. Quickly leads to NPS (Nonsensical Plot Syndrome), though I can't deny that crack is what made me discover anime when I was young. Now that came out weird, though it explains so much...

To resume, unless you want a quick fix that leaves you dazed and impairs cognitive functions, stay away from shonen. Examples of the genre: Naruto, One Piece, DBZ, Bleach, FullMetal Alchemist... *braces for fan-pact* Most of those shonen's excuse for a plot is the search of an absurdly elusive McGuffin, whose finding I cynically predict to coincide with the IRL decrease of sales, when a new generation of crack makes it's way to the market. Though I'll admit that, if you excise all the childish comic relief, FMA is actually pretty good entertainment, thanks to an ok plot and a fascinating universe.

Two other famous genres targeted at the younger crowd, and that I've yet to see produce anything actually creative, are shoujo (i.e. 'young girl', sappy love stories), and a genre that doesn't officially have a name, but that I call harem anime, because it's about a relatable (read: nerdy) protagonist and the dozen girls infatuated with him. No need to elaborate on either of them; I'm tired of making spoiler boxes :p

Then there is seinen, or 'adult male' manga/anime. Which can hardly be qualified a 'genre', as it's very definition is just that it stays clear of the nonsensical tropes of the rest of the industry, though when it is 'officially' classified as seinen, you can expect 3 things:
-Explicit violence, if the plot includes it.
-More or less explicit sexuality, if the plot includes it.
-A somewhat higher probability of NPS, as all japanese writers realised ever since Evangelion that if the ending made no sense, people would have a tendency to mystify it *brace for more fan-pact*

Now for the recommendations:

People have already set you up with Cowboy Bebop, and the same studio's Samurai Champloo. Another good 'genre-bender' is Michiko to Hatchin. It's got less action, the plot being about Michiko, a fugitive criminal, 'adopting' (kidnapping) a young girl named Hatchin to take her to her real father, but the universe is just as engrossing ( Favela-style cities set to a funky afro-cuban soundtrack ). My only gripe is that it takes them the entire first episode to get the ball rolling, but after that it's all good.

Of the other recommendations, Ghost in the Shell is nice, though it has lapses of NPS when it tries too hard to be intellectual. And god does it try hard.

Most of the rest, I'm not really familiar with - I'm more of an expert on manga. I have read Claymore though, and sorry fans, but the large amount of crack in it is the only interesting parts, hence I file it as a shonen. It does, however, avoid the other annoying tropes of shonen, or at least it did up until where I stopped reading it. So maybe it's decent.

As for Elfen Lied, it's another one I've only read, not watched, so it might be different in it's animated form, but I hated it.
IMO, it starts out pretending it's going to be a nietzschean tale of an evolutionary power-struggle. But it turns out to be about little girls ripping peoples' limbs off with psychic powers, and providing fanservice when they're not murdering. Oh, and if the murder isn't enough, the plot is there just to serve some dumbed-down social commentary.

How I miss thee, subtlety... Which brings me to:

Paranoia Agent made me ecstatic when I saw it a couple years ago, thanks to it's deep social subtext, and because it's one of those rare 'surrealist' anime that aren't just a shivering miasma of nonsense but actually make sense. I won't go into more detail, just watch it.

Right now I'm watching Texhnolyze, which I've found to be a very nice take on the classic sci-fi problem of cybernetics and technocracy, though I've yet to watch the last 6 episodes.
It's mostly about a low-tech city called Lux, built around a 'lafia' mine (lafia being what makes cybernetics possible), and the interactions with the technocrats, aptly named the 'Class'. I actually was afraid it might veer into NPS because it starts out 'in media res' (also because of poor subtitles, but that's another problem altogether), and only bothers giving you the background about halfway through, but it turns out fine - or at least it looks like it might, I just hope it won't turn into an Evangelion-like at the end.
 

thublihnk

New member
Jul 24, 2009
395
0
0
I am so sick of this attitude that everyone has to like anime or else they just haven't watched enough of it. Look, it's a style, it's a specific thing for specific people. I'm an appreciator of animation and I'm a huge appreciator of film, but Anime has a culture behind it that I just can't get behind, and said culture heavily influences the content of the art. And I just don't dig the style.

I just don't dig. You dig?
 
Dec 25, 2010
110
0
0
lolnoobzor said:
Given your afore-mentioned ignorance of anime, I would like to introduce you to the classifications and tropes that constitute it's various genres. In complete weeaboo style, I'll use the japanese terms, but I hope, Mr. Texas Sir, you'll recognize the fellow snob in me, that I may help guide you away from mediocrity.

The most common genre, and the most popular one, is named 'shonen', or literally 'young boy', since it's aimed at the young male demographic. You seem to have already experienced some of it's horrors. There are several tropes that help define the genre:

A young ( often male ) protagonist, also often a whiny immature pr#!&, which makes sense since he's meant to be 'relatable' to 13 yr-old kids. Also makes 'friends' during his 'adventure', whose main purpose is to spend half the episode explaining in detail what you just saw, in case you are blind. See below, slow plot.

Slooooooooooooooooooooooow plot, interspersed with filler. I believe it's a consequence of how most shonen are adapted from their comic form, where over-extending the plot means more books people have to buy. A joke a friend of mine came up with: How many saiyan does it take to change a lightbulb? One, but it takes him 6 episodes.

Fanservice seems to be omnipresent, but sometimes it's toned down to tolerable levels. Sometimes. Other times, you get steaming piles of it, like in High School of the Dead, where there is more time given over to fanservice than plot in most episodes. Also see above: slow plot.

Crack. Well, that's at least how I decided to call it. It's the adrenaline rush the viewer feels when their relatable protagonist finally starts beating back the much more powerful ( initially ) antagonist. This is the main reason people watch it, and it also leads to what is called DBZ-syndrome, which means that as the protagonists gain power, more and more ridiculous antagonists have to be conjured. Quickly leads to NPS (Nonsensical Plot Syndrome), though I can't deny that crack is what made me discover anime when I was young. Now that came out weird, though it explains so much...

To resume, unless you want a quick fix that leaves you dazed and impairs cognitive functions, stay away from shonen. Examples of the genre: Naruto, One Piece, DBZ, Bleach, FullMetal Alchemist... *braces for fan-pact* Most of those shonen's excuse for a plot is the search of an absurdly elusive McGuffin, whose finding I cynically predict to coincide with the IRL decrease of sales, when a new generation of crack makes it's way to the market. Though I'll admit that, if you excise all the childish comic relief, FMA is actually pretty good entertainment, thanks to an ok plot and a fascinating universe.

Two other famous genres targeted at the younger crowd, and that I've yet to see produce anything actually creative, are shoujo (i.e. 'young girl', sappy love stories), and a genre that doesn't officially have a name, but that I call harem anime, because it's about a relatable (read: nerdy) protagonist and the dozen girls infatuated with him. No need to elaborate on either of them; I'm tired of making spoiler boxes :p

Then there is seinen, or 'adult male' manga/anime. Which can hardly be qualified a 'genre', as it's very definition is just that it stays clear of the nonsensical tropes of the rest of the industry, though when it is 'officially' classified as seinen, you can expect 3 things:
-Explicit violence, if the plot includes it.
-More or less explicit sexuality, if the plot includes it.
-A somewhat higher probability of NPS, as all japanese writers realised ever since Evangelion that if the ending made no sense, people would have a tendency to mystify it *brace for more fan-pact*

Now for the recommendations:

People have already set you up with Cowboy Bebop, and the same studio's Samurai Champloo. Another good 'genre-bender' is Michiko to Hatchin. It's got less action, the plot being about Michiko, a fugitive criminal, 'adopting' (kidnapping) a young girl named Hatchin to take her to her real father, but the universe is just as engrossing ( Favela-style cities set to a funky afro-cuban soundtrack ). My only gripe is that it takes them the entire first episode to get the ball rolling, but after that it's all good.

Of the other recommendations, Ghost in the Shell is nice, though it has lapses of NPS when it tries too hard to be intellectual. And god does it try hard.

Most of the rest, I'm not really familiar with - I'm more of an expert on manga. I have read Claymore though, and sorry fans, but the large amount of crack in it is the only interesting parts, hence I file it as a shonen. It does, however, avoid the other annoying tropes of shonen, or at least it did up until where I stopped reading it. So maybe it's decent.

As for Elfen Lied, it's another one I've only read, not watched, so it might be different in it's animated form, but I hated it.
IMO, it starts out pretending it's going to be a nietzschean tale of an evolutionary power-struggle. But it turns out to be about little girls ripping peoples' limbs off with psychic powers, and providing fanservice when they're not murdering. Oh, and if the murder isn't enough, the plot is there just to serve some dumbed-down social commentary.

How I miss thee, subtlety... Which brings me to:

Paranoia Agent made me ecstatic when I saw it a couple years ago, thanks to it's deep social subtext, and because it's one of those rare 'surrealist' anime that aren't just a shivering miasma of nonsense but actually make sense. I won't go into more detail, just watch it.

Right now I'm watching Texhnolyze, which I've found to be a very nice take on the classic sci-fi problem of cybernetics and technocracy, though I've yet to watch the last 6 episodes.
It's mostly about a low-tech city called Lux, built around a 'lafia' mine (lafia being what makes cybernetics possible), and the interactions with the technocrats, aptly named the 'Class'. I actually was afraid it might veer into NPS because it starts out 'in media res' (also because of poor subtitles, but that's another problem altogether), and only bothers giving you the background about halfway through, but it turns out fine - or at least it looks like it might, I just hope it won't turn into an Evangelion-like at the end.
This. This right here. This is a poster who everyone should emulate. No seriously, this is a great and informative post for someone who's never seen any Anime before. You seem to know your genre conventions really well.
 
Dec 25, 2010
110
0
0
thublihnk said:
I am so sick of this attitude that everyone has to like anime or else they just haven't watched enough of it. Look, it's a style, it's a specific thing for specific people. I'm an appreciator of animation and I'm a huge appreciator of film, but Anime has a culture behind it that I just can't get behind, and said culture heavily influences the content of the art. And I just don't dig the style.

I just don't dig. You dig?
People often underestimate the importance that a piece of arts surrounding culture has on that piece of art. It's really hard to truly appreciate something when you can't stand everyone else who likes it as much as you do. Using games as an example (we are on the Escapist), how many people love Halo but don't play the multi player for the community? This is a valid criticism and one I see levied alot by anime's detractors in this thread.
 

CJ1145

Elite Member
Jan 6, 2009
4,051
0
41
Texas America Murphy said:
So where do Self-Righteous forum posts sit on that transportation scale then?
Self-righteous? So it's self-righteous to chastise a person when their occupation/interests should all but guarantee they shouldn't be so ignorant? At least you seem a little willing to learn, which is more than the one posting below you.

thublihnk said:
On the expressway up the poster's own assh*le?
This guy appears to just hate anime because he assumes that a subset of its fans are capable of making it totally unapproachable as a genre.
 
Dec 25, 2010
110
0
0
CJ1145 said:
Texas America Murphy said:
So where do Self-Righteous forum posts sit on that transportation scale then?
Self-righteous? So it's self-righteous to chastise a person when their occupation/interests should all but guarantee they shouldn't be so ignorant? At least you seem a little willing to learn, which is more than the one posting below you.

thublihnk said:
On the expressway up the poster's own assh*le?
This guy appears to just hate anime because he assumes that a subset of its fans are capable of making it totally unapproachable as a genre.
You think being film student is a guarantee against ignorance and knee-jerk opinions? I want to be snarky, but that thought is so innocent. So pure. So totally outside of real-world comprehension. It would be like taking away Santa.
 

Pokedude1013

New member
Oct 27, 2009
52
0
0
Texas America Murphy said:
Dear Nerds, explain to me what the heck the deal with Anime is.

A little bit of background before we collectively explore this artistic train wreck you call ?Japanimation.?

I?m a film student at the University of Texas. I have never seen an Anime before yesterday. I like to think that I give everything I watch a fair shake. Hell, I even watched an Irani film once. Now, my girlfriend Leanne is a member of our school's anime club, which meets every Friday night. Normally I don?t go with her because my JROTC usually meets on Fridays, but last night I was free because it was Christmas Eve (and its Winter Break), and my girlfriend invited me to have an ?Anime Christmas? with her and her friends who live in the area.

So I walk into the living room and there are these girls dressed up in these weird costumes and stuff. One of them runs up to me and shouts something like ?Cowiie Desi.? So I?m put off, but still determined to see what the big fuss is about. DVDs go in the player and I?m treated to what my girlfriend tells me is the most popular Animes.

First off we watched Naruto. I?ve seen German Art House cinema that made more sense than this. I guess it was about Ninjas, but they were all wearing orange jumpsuits? At no point did any of the plot make sense or any of the characters develop.

After that we watched two episodes of Code Geuess. It was like walking into a Mexican soap opera midway through the plot. Everyone was pulling gambits and double gambits and Russian reversals. I didn?t know who was betraying whom, and I don?t think those cardboard cutouts did either. Also, why is Britain invading Japan? We already did that!

Finally, we watched an episode of this thing Guren Lagan. It felt like I was six years old and watching Power Rangers again. You?d think this would be a compliment. A sort of return to youth. But even at 6 I was doubtful of the artistic validity of Power Rangers. Also, the fact that every character on that show was sexually attracted to a 12 year old girl is incredibly disturbing. Is this okay in Japan?

Some basic research reveals that these shows are some of the most popular Anime both here and in Japan. Why is it so popular? What is so great about these shows? I?m so confused. Nothing anyone does makes any sense, the characters are all cliches, and nothing ever actually happens.

I couldn?t help but notice that virtually half the people on this board of some sort of Anime character as their avatar, so obviously people here love it and its popular. But for all my education I cannot possibly comprehend why people call this ?art.? I was hoping that maybe y?all could enlighten me. There must be something I am missing

Edited for spelling.
You're a nerd too lol
 

thublihnk

New member
Jul 24, 2009
395
0
0
CJ1145 said:
Texas America Murphy said:
So where do Self-Righteous forum posts sit on that transportation scale then?
Self-righteous? So it's self-righteous to chastise a person when their occupation/interests should all but guarantee they shouldn't be so ignorant? At least you seem a little willing to learn, which is more than the one posting below you.

thublihnk said:
On the expressway up the poster's own assh*le?
This guy appears to just hate anime because he assumes that a subset of its fans are capable of making it totally unapproachable as a genre.
Did I say I hated anime? No, I didn't, good job man! I said I don't dig it, and I also alluded to the fact that I don't dig pompous cocks.

I actually used to like anime as a kid, with the DBZ's and the Gundams and whatnot, but I grew out of that and found the more 'adult' (read: not hentai) Anime to be criminally shallow and fan-servicey when compared to other genres of animation, entertainment, etc. And this crusader-like fury that a fan of the form gets when I say I'm just not that into it doesn't really help the case. Kinda makes it sound like it's something for the less-intelligent, if you know what I'm saying, pal.
 

SpotHydra

New member
Jun 3, 2010
5
0
0
Texas America Murphy said:
First off we watched Naruto. I?ve seen German Art House cinema that made more sense than this. I guess it was about Ninjas, but they were all wearing orange jumpsuits? At no point did any of the plot make sense or any of the characters develop.
I gotta say they picked the worst shows on anime Naruto is just like the way you say it is my favorite one right now is FMA the other ones are pretty bad. They are just repeating the same story over and over again like almost everything else.
 

Flunk

New member
Feb 17, 2008
915
0
0
I'm not surprised at all, Naruto is a serial which requires that you watch every episode for it to make any sense. There are something like 500 episodes so I don't recommend trying to watch it all. Also, if you watched it dubbed in English they apparently removed some of the plot points so it probably doesn't make sense at all.

The target audience for Naruto is teenage boys so if you don't fit into that group it's good to avoid.
 

Not G. Ivingname

New member
Nov 18, 2009
6,368
0
0
Texas America Murphy said:
The big deal with anime is that it is socially accepted animation. Animation here in the west has almost always held the stigma of immaturity and "it's for kids" since around the 60's, no matter how hard animators tried to fix that.

Anime on the other hand has been socially accepted in Japan. I don't know why, but it is actually considered art.

Now, most anime is terrible because most entertainment is just garbage, and just because something is popular doesn't make it good. Naruto is the Transformers of anime.

I used to be confused by anime, but I slowly been finding anime I like. Don't just go for what is popular, but do for the weird and wonderful.

I started with Soul Eater, although where you start I suggest be entirely up to you.
 

banksie

New member
Nov 27, 2007
4
0
0
thublihnk said:
I am so sick of this attitude that everyone has to like anime or else they just haven't watched enough of it. Look, it's a style, it's a specific thing for specific people. I'm an appreciator of animation and I'm a huge appreciator of film, but Anime has a culture behind it that I just can't get behind, and said culture heavily influences the content of the art. And I just don't dig the style.

I just don't dig. You dig?
Except that anime isn't a style per se, yes there are many common tropes and techniques that get reused but that isn't anime in totality. Studio Ghibli films have a wildly different animation style and look to what is typically called anime yet that is what they are. Even within Studio Ghibli the art style and conventions used vary greatly with 'My Neighbors the Yamadas' (it being directed by Takahata) having a very different artistic style to anything Miyazaki produces.

It is kinda akin to slamming all French cinema because you dislike the French New Wave films of the late sixties.

There is anime out there that caters to pretty much anyone's tastes. It may take a while to find it but it is there. I mean they made a series about competitive bread making for goodness sake, bakers of the world rejoice! :)

That said I don't believe in forcing people to watch something. If you really don't want to watch anime than that is both your choice and to some extent loss.