What is the dumbest case of fandom infighting you have ever seen?

Dragonlayer

Aka Corporal Yakob
Dec 5, 2013
971
0
0
Meriatressia said:
One of the worst was a really stupid thing were some idiots said brute Splicers in BioShock 2 are gay.
This is a giant splicer, who took a lot of psysical plasmids. It's macho. It's quite clearly a macho male who tried to be more macho with plasmids.
But somehow, this masculine being, is gay. They somehow think the traits of a masculine man, are gay. All of them. They really think that all the brute splicers are gay. Which is statistically immpossible.
No, it's a a macho man who made himself bigger. That's it. It's quite blatantly a heavy, thuggish, splicer.

The worst was someone who drew a female brute splicer, with a tiny handbag and girly things. Who somehow did'nt grasp that if a person was lesbian, they probabely display normal female things or masculine things.
And someone who becomes a brute splicer is deliberately trying to make themselves bigger. They don't care about stereotypical female things. There's plasmids to make a female prettier, they'd take them if they wanted to be girly.

The increasingly desperate and pathetic arguments they come up with are cretinously moronic.

It's even more moronic when splicers live in Rapture, a place that does'nt care about the usual predujices of the 40s and 50s. A lesbian or homosexual would have no problem being open about it. There would be no hiding it.

This is disturbing, because, some people clearly think that masculine things are gay now.
A man can't be macho, without being a closet gay. A character is manly and masculine. And some moron thinks they are gay. They can't just be a straight man.
That is fucked up.
This romanticisation of lesbians and gays has gone way too far.

The most fucked up thing in fandoms is shipping and slashwork. And changing the sexuality of characters for no reason.
Especially when a character is very straight or very lesbian or gay, etc.

Boone in Fallout New Vegas, of all people, get's turned gay! Boone was married to a woman, he is a very straight, serious, man, who adored his wife. But no, some idiots turn him gay.

Adam Jenson could'nt be more straight if he tried. He was with Megan for years. He is a awesome, manly, man.
But no, there's a load of morons who make him gay and with that richardhead Francis Pritchard.

Both are very straight men.
You know that Jordan Thomas, one of the developers who worked on the first Bioshock actually said the Brute Splicer is a closeted homosexual? Now if people are just equating "masculine" with "flaming gay" then that's stupidity on their part, but I distinctly remember the Brute having loads of dialogue that implied he was repressed; stuff like "Argh, get the hell away from me you nonce!" when being attacked or "Don't need no women when I've got a best friend like you" when hypnotized.

Furthermore, where the hell did you get the idea that Rapture doesn't have the prejudices of the time? Nobody underwent any kind of progressive education program when they moved to Rapture, it was just "Do you have enough money to live here and do you like fish and chips?". There weren't any open homosexuals, no blacks/Asians/general non-whites in positions of power (with maybe two or three exceptions that were based entirely on their personal relationship to Andrew Ryan), certainly no religious or political freedom....ironically enough, in certain regards Columbia was a more forward thinking city then Rapture.

I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
 

Xdeser2

New member
Aug 11, 2012
465
0
0
Fallout 3 vs Fallout 1. 2, and New Vegas

It's ridiculous. Bethesda made a fantastic adaptation of the series. But of course, its new so its scary and bad and dumb Etc.

The Elder Scrolls games

I mean fucking seriously. I've done my share of ranting on Morrowind, but I dont think its a bad game by any means (and I'm defiantly in the minority, seeing as most people adore it). There's a crazy amount of spite from people about Oblivion and Skyrim and how their "Dumbed Down" for "Casuals". Those arguments usually come down to "Ugh..Oblivion and Skyrim dont have Levitation, Giant Mushrooms or Pauldrons and have fast travel/quest markers so its dumb"
 

EternallyBored

Terminally Apathetic
Jun 17, 2013
1,434
0
0
Dragonlayer said:
I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
Eh, it's the same reason fans draw wacky crossovers and other things, except instead of thinking that a picture of master chief fighting Samus would look cool, they think seeing a picture of ezio getting his mac on with Nathan Drake is sexy, or hot, or whatever.

Breaking out the canon complaint "but they aren't gay!" just smacks of hypocrisy, I never see these canon complaints crop up when people are handing out lightsabers to the Harry Potter universe, or drawing Goku fighting Superman. Almost nobody is actually saying "it's totally canon that Ezio is gay!", they are saying, "man a picture of Ezio kissing another guy would be really hot", which is pretty much the same logic as, "man a picture of Ezio holding a lightsaber and kicking ass in the Star Wars universe would be totally badass".

Now, if they do actually try to argue that a character with a canon sexuality is actually gay/straight/bisexual, and say that anyone who disagrees with their headcanon is wrong, then yeah that's crossing over from having fun with fan work, to actually trying to change canon to suit your tastes, in which case, feel free to call them out for being stupid.
 

Dragonlayer

Aka Corporal Yakob
Dec 5, 2013
971
0
0
EternallyBored said:
Dragonlayer said:
I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
Eh, it's the same reason fans draw wacky crossovers and other things, except instead of thinking that a picture of master chief fighting Samus would look cool, they think seeing a picture of ezio getting his mac on with Nathan Drake is sexy, or hot, or whatever.

Breaking out the canon complaint "but they aren't gay!" just smacks of hypocrisy, I never see these canon complaints crop up when people are handing out lightsabers to the Harry Potter universe, or drawing Goku fighting Superman. Almost nobody is actually saying "it's totally canon that Ezio is gay!", they are saying, "man a picture of Ezio kissing another guy would be really hot", which is pretty much the same logic as, "man a picture of Ezio holding a lightsaber and kicking ass in the Star Wars universe would be totally badass".

Now, if they do actually try to argue that a character with a canon sexuality is actually gay/straight/bisexual, and say that anyone who disagrees with their headcanon is wrong, then yeah that's crossing over from having fun with fan work, to actually trying to change canon to suit your tastes, in which case, feel free to call them out for being stupid.
Oh don't get me wrong, I fully understand the reasons behind it and certainly don't crusade to put the "degenerates" in their place, it's just something that annoys me on a personal level.
 

EternallyBored

Terminally Apathetic
Jun 17, 2013
1,434
0
0
Dragonlayer said:
EternallyBored said:
Dragonlayer said:
I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
Eh, it's the same reason fans draw wacky crossovers and other things, except instead of thinking that a picture of master chief fighting Samus would look cool, they think seeing a picture of ezio getting his mac on with Nathan Drake is sexy, or hot, or whatever.

Breaking out the canon complaint "but they aren't gay!" just smacks of hypocrisy, I never see these canon complaints crop up when people are handing out lightsabers to the Harry Potter universe, or drawing Goku fighting Superman. Almost nobody is actually saying "it's totally canon that Ezio is gay!", they are saying, "man a picture of Ezio kissing another guy would be really hot", which is pretty much the same logic as, "man a picture of Ezio holding a lightsaber and kicking ass in the Star Wars universe would be totally badass".

Now, if they do actually try to argue that a character with a canon sexuality is actually gay/straight/bisexual, and say that anyone who disagrees with their headcanon is wrong, then yeah that's crossing over from having fun with fan work, to actually trying to change canon to suit your tastes, in which case, feel free to call them out for being stupid.
Oh don't get me wrong, I fully understand the reasons behind it and certainly don't crusade to put the "degenerates" in their place, it's just something that annoys me on a personal level.
Ah well, everybody's got their personal peeves, no big deal. The whole anti-shipping, anti-gay/yaoi/slash whatever thing tends to be a big controversy in a lot of fandoms.

A lot of people get worked up over it to a ridiculous degree, with one side swearing up and down that their pairings can never be questioned, and trying to pass off their interpretations of pretty much every character being gay/bi/straight as totally canon, no ifs, ands, or buts, and anyone that dares question that is a monster for doing so.

On the other side you've got the group obsessed with "canon purity", except that purity only seems to apply when a character is portrayed as gay. You can put them in alternate dimensions, crossovers, give them all kinds of superpowers, or straight up write or portray them as out of character, but the second you make that character gay, there always seems to be a contingent swooping in to complain about how "this character can't be gay! It's not canon!", of course they only really care about canon when it comes to sexuality, so they tend to disappear when it comes time to care about any other facet of that character.

So yeah, shipping and anti-shipping arguements in general are a case of dumb fandom infighting that I've seen for the last 20 years, and I know its been going on even before that.
 

Dragonlayer

Aka Corporal Yakob
Dec 5, 2013
971
0
0
EternallyBored said:
Dragonlayer said:
EternallyBored said:
Dragonlayer said:
I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
Eh, it's the same reason fans draw wacky crossovers and other things, except instead of thinking that a picture of master chief fighting Samus would look cool, they think seeing a picture of ezio getting his mac on with Nathan Drake is sexy, or hot, or whatever.

Breaking out the canon complaint "but they aren't gay!" just smacks of hypocrisy, I never see these canon complaints crop up when people are handing out lightsabers to the Harry Potter universe, or drawing Goku fighting Superman. Almost nobody is actually saying "it's totally canon that Ezio is gay!", they are saying, "man a picture of Ezio kissing another guy would be really hot", which is pretty much the same logic as, "man a picture of Ezio holding a lightsaber and kicking ass in the Star Wars universe would be totally badass".

Now, if they do actually try to argue that a character with a canon sexuality is actually gay/straight/bisexual, and say that anyone who disagrees with their headcanon is wrong, then yeah that's crossing over from having fun with fan work, to actually trying to change canon to suit your tastes, in which case, feel free to call them out for being stupid.
Oh don't get me wrong, I fully understand the reasons behind it and certainly don't crusade to put the "degenerates" in their place, it's just something that annoys me on a personal level.
Ah well, everybody's got their personal peeves, no big deal. The whole anti-shipping, anti-gay/yaoi/slash whatever thing tends to be a big controversy in a lot of fandoms.

A lot of people get worked up over it to a ridiculous degree, with one side swearing up and down that their pairings can never be questioned, and trying to pass off their interpretations of pretty much every character being gay/bi/straight as totally canon, no ifs, ands, or buts, and anyone that dares question that is a monster for doing so.

On the other side you've got the group obsessed with "canon purity", except that purity only seems to apply when a character is portrayed as gay. You can put them in alternate dimensions, crossovers, give them all kinds of superpowers, or straight up write or portray them as out of character, but the second you make that character gay, there always seems to be a contingent swooping in to complain about how "this character can't be gay! It's not canon!", of course they only really care about canon when it comes to sexuality, so they tend to disappear when it comes time to care about any other facet of that character.

So yeah, shipping and anti-shipping arguements in general are a case of dumb fandom infighting that I've seen for the last 20 years, and I know its been going on even before that.
Yeah, from what I've seen it can rouse quite the fanatical fury on both sides, which I think is the absolute height of pointlessness: the way I see it, people are perfectly entitled to make whatever they want in fan-works and just plain attacking them for it (not criticizing or commenting, just attacking) is a load of bollocks. But, like you pointed out, if they try to force it into official cannon or onto others, then bugger that. I personally dislike the "gayafication" of stuff, but no-one is forcing me to look at it so I'm not going to go out of my way to say "WURST FING EVA!".
 

Dragonlayer

Aka Corporal Yakob
Dec 5, 2013
971
0
0
Meriatressia said:
Dragonlayer said:
Meriatressia said:
One of the worst was a really stupid thing were some idiots said brute Splicers in BioShock 2 are gay.
This is a giant splicer, who took a lot of psysical plasmids. It's macho. It's quite clearly a macho male who tried to be more macho with plasmids.
But somehow, this masculine being, is gay. They somehow think the traits of a masculine man, are gay. All of them. They really think that all the brute splicers are gay. Which is statistically immpossible.
No, it's a a macho man who made himself bigger. That's it. It's quite blatantly a heavy, thuggish, splicer.

The worst was someone who drew a female brute splicer, with a tiny handbag and girly things. Who somehow did'nt grasp that if a person was lesbian, they probabely display normal female things or masculine things.
And someone who becomes a brute splicer is deliberately trying to make themselves bigger. They don't care about stereotypical female things. There's plasmids to make a female prettier, they'd take them if they wanted to be girly.

The increasingly desperate and pathetic arguments they come up with are cretinously moronic.

It's even more moronic when splicers live in Rapture, a place that does'nt care about the usual predujices of the 40s and 50s. A lesbian or homosexual would have no problem being open about it. There would be no hiding it.

This is disturbing, because, some people clearly think that masculine things are gay now.
A man can't be macho, without being a closet gay. A character is manly and masculine. And some moron thinks they are gay. They can't just be a straight man.
That is fucked up.
This romanticisation of lesbians and gays has gone way too far.

The most fucked up thing in fandoms is shipping and slashwork. And changing the sexuality of characters for no reason.
Especially when a character is very straight or very lesbian or gay, etc.

Boone in Fallout New Vegas, of all people, get's turned gay! Boone was married to a woman, he is a very straight, serious, man, who adored his wife. But no, some idiots turn him gay.

Adam Jenson could'nt be more straight if he tried. He was with Megan for years. He is a awesome, manly, man.
But no, there's a load of morons who make him gay and with that richardhead Francis Pritchard.

Both are very straight men.
You know that Jordan Thomas, one of the developers who worked on the first Bioshock actually said the Brute Splicer is a closeted homosexual? Now if people are just equating "masculine" with "flaming gay" then that's stupidity on their part, but I distinctly remember the Brute having loads of dialogue that implied he was repressed; stuff like "Argh, get the hell away from me you nonce!" when being attacked or "Don't need no women when I've got a best friend like you" when hypnotized.

Furthermore, where the hell did you get the idea that Rapture doesn't have the prejudices of the time? Nobody underwent any kind of progressive education program when they moved to Rapture, it was just "Do you have enough money to live here and do you like fish and chips?". There weren't any open homosexuals, no blacks/Asians/general non-whites in positions of power (with maybe two or three exceptions that were based entirely on their personal relationship to Andrew Ryan), certainly no religious or political freedom....ironically enough, in certain regards Columbia was a more forward thinking city then Rapture.

I'm with you on the shipping point though: I don't care what relationships you foster in your fan-work, it's just irritating to go onto DeviantArt and see *yet* another gay Assassin's Creed piece on the frontpage. These characters are not gay!
Rapture is free of predjudices, just like it's free of social and religious control.
There is a very clear homosexual in Sander Cohen. A man who slept with 4 men at once, and was not hiding anything. He spent the entire time having sex with men who had their own agendas.
And he was the boss of a area.
Most of the leads are female, Sander Cohen was a very high boss.

Bioshock 2 had some stupid things in it that were'nt in Bioshock 1.
There is zero sexism or racism in B1. But B2 had sexism and racism for no reason at all.
It does'nt go with it, and it sticks out like a sore thumb.

Rapture most definately was free from predjudices and various social controls.
But worthy, stupid, bits of bad writing added things that did'nt exist.

The brute splicers make no sense whatsoever, in any way at all. Especially when you look at the high end boss Sander Cohen. A man who was hiding nothing at all.

I don't care what the idiots who wrote some of Bioshock 2 say. It would'nt be the first time writers have changed their tune to suit fans.
These are the same people who thought killing off the lead was clever.
"Rapture is free of prejudices, just like it's free of social and religious control" - what!? Rapture was a reflection of the 50s society that its residents came from! Ok, maybe people were a bit more open minded because they were willing to engage in some kind of insane underwater Libertarian experiment but just count the amount of non-whites. Hell, count the amount of non-WASP whites. There was.....the single black woman who was the propaganda singer and.....there was an Irish dude who Ryan had personally contracted for architecture.....and there was Suchong and Tenenbaum, both accepted because of their scientific skills. Not only that, but while the ideal for Rapture was that it would lack any government intervention or "control", it very quickly fell apart when Adam was discovered and it screwed up Ryan's idea of a free market ruled city, forcing him to crack down on Fontaine (not to mention he had banned religion; those fishermen Splicers were bible smugglers).

Sander Cohen was the "boss" in the sense that he was friends with Andrew Ryan and that everyone was fucking terrified of him: there wasn't any information saying that he pranced around pre-civil war Rapture having sex with any man he liked, openly and without any repercussions. Just about all the audio logs in the area he was the "boss" of (because he was a Ryan loyalist and a functioning insane Splicer) all allude to his degeneracy, with one of the imprisoned artists crying about what a "sick fuck" he was. Sander Cohen was a warlord, not an accepted gay figure.

Which leads me nicely onto the Brute Splicer, who if I recall correctly speaks with a strong British accent: given the things he says, it's all but certain he's a repressed homosexual, precisely because 50s British society frowned upon that sort of thing. Plus, the creative director of the game the enemy appears said it was so....

"I don't care what the idiots who wrote some of Bioshock 2 say. It would'nt be the first time writers have changed their tune to suit fans." - Firstly, I'm fairly certain the dude said this while he was working on the game; granted I'm not the be-all, end-all master of all Shock related information but I don't remember a great hullabaloo from the fans speculating over an expendable enemy type being gay or not. Secondly, aren't you doing what you professed to hate about shippers? "I DON'T CARE WHAT THE ACTUAL PEOPLE WHO MADE THIS GAME SAY: THIS GUY IS STRAIGHT BECAUSE I SAY SO!"

Look, I get disagreeing with game developers; you'd be hard pressed to get me to say anything positive about Killzone 3's half-baked abortion plot but I acknowledge that it's canon because it was made by the developers.
 

monkey_man

New member
Jul 5, 2009
1,164
0
0
Evil Smurf said:
How to pronounce "gif". It's clearly jif, like Girafe or Jelly. The inventor says so.
It stands for Graphics Interchange Format. It's gif. Not Jraphics interchange format. I dont care what his peanut butter loving butt thinks.
 

Ratty

New member
Jan 21, 2014
848
0
0
Eamar said:
It's never got to anything approaching gaming flamewar levels, but I've seen heated arguments about what colour Legolas' hair should be (Tolkien never explicitly states it). Basically there's a passage that can sometimes be interpreted as showing he has dark hair, but there are equally strong indications that he's blond. Short of finding a hidden manuscript or something, there is literally no way anyone could prove it one way or the other so the whole thing is completely pointless.
Maybe his blond hair and obvious dark eyebrows in the movies were a compromise? (jk)

Negrido said:
RatherDull said:
Light Side Sith

You've never seen an argument until you've seen THAT argument.
Evil Paladins.
The passion involved on both sides of these arguments borders on the scary
Paladins shouldn't be evil. Being freakishly devoted to lawful good is their most defining characteristic. If you want to be a Lord Soth clone[footnote]Still much better than a Drizzst clone.[/footnote] so badly just be a Blackguard.
 

TheSteeleStrap

New member
May 7, 2008
721
0
0
The Bible

A silly one I've seen recently is Dark Souls. You have people who just want to play and learn from their mistakes, and then there are the people who are all "ZOMG YOU SUCK SO BAD HOW DID YOU NOT KNOW THIS ON YOUR FIRST PLAYTHROUGH?!?!1"
 

Jordy Hartog

New member
Oct 5, 2012
44
0
0
I'm half surprised to not have seen (or just managed to gloss over it) Supernatural yet.

I'm not a part of the fandom myself (I enjoyed much of the show, but don't really concern myself with it once I'm not actively watching it), but I have seen some truly deranged stuff coming from its fans. Dumbest I've seen was probably someone who ships the actors playing the brothers (the actual people, not the characters) saying that the fact that both are married and have a kid are all just a clever ruse from the show's PR team, even going so far as to be disgusted by said PR team that they had the gall to include a baby in their charade.

Yup, they were disgusted by people who may have done something for some reason because they made up that scenario in their own mind.
 

Bocaj2000

New member
Sep 10, 2008
1,082
0
0
the hidden eagle said:
The Naruto fandom rivalries,DA:O Vs DA2,ME1 VS ME2/ME3,DMc fans Vs DMC fans,Genwhinners vs people who like all Pokemon games,hell I can name a entire list that's twenty pages long of dumbass fandom infighting considering I've seen and been apart of many.
I kinda want to see this list...
 

sumanoskae

New member
Dec 7, 2007
1,526
0
0
I'm... actually struggling to find one. I haven't seen very many dumb ARGUMENTS, honestly, just people saying dumb shit in general, angry or not.

Let's see... Back in days of yore, when I used to read some Fan Fiction, I regularly cam across entire stories dedicated to criticizing a single character. Not deconstructing them, not subverting their role in the story, just people writing about them doing shitty things or having bad shit happen to them.

I didn't understand it then and I don't understand it now; if you think their character serves no purpose, just omit them from the story.
 

sumanoskae

New member
Dec 7, 2007
1,526
0
0
Jordy Hartog said:
I'm half surprised to not have seen (or just managed to gloss over it) Supernatural yet.

I'm not a part of the fandom myself (I enjoyed much of the show, but don't really concern myself with it once I'm not actively watching it), but I have seen some truly deranged stuff coming from its fans. Dumbest I've seen was probably someone who ships the actors playing the brothers (the actual people, not the characters) saying that the fact that both are married and have a kid are all just a clever ruse from the show's PR team, even going so far as to be disgusted by said PR team that they had the gall to include a baby in their charade.

Yup, they were disgusted by people who may have done something for some reason because they made up that scenario in their own mind.
Jesus... that is genuinely insane, like grounds for getting fucking committed.