Which game has the WORST story

Paddin

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2009
731
0
21
The Diabolical Biz said:
The Great Gatsby, for the NES. I played that game believing that the plot was true to the book. I went on to read the book, and was SEVERELY DISAPPOINTED. I couldn't even finish, such was the depth of my despair!
They made a Great Gatsby video game? How is that possible?! Is it a first person shooter from the view of Mr Wilson? I cannot wrap my mind around that.
TheLiham said:
MasochisticMuse said:
Tetris.

I mean, it's like they weren't even trying.
Yeah, What's the reverse-L blocks angle?!
90 degrees. Ho oh oh.
 

Soviet Steve

New member
May 23, 2009
1,511
0
0
dathwampeer said:
Istvan said:
The upcoming "Homefront", with Modern Warfare 2 in hot pursuit, due to the most blatantly idiotic plot lines since the emo dance scene in Spider-man 3.
Actually. When you read into the timeline. It's not idiotic, at all.

wiki said:
Timeline

* 2011: North Korea faces another UN sanction over its latest nuclear test.
* 2012: Kim Jong-il passes away, he is succeeded by his son Kim Jong-un.
* 2013: Kim Jong-un is awarded the Nobel Peace Prize and featured on the cover of Time magazine for his accomplishment of Korean reunification.
* 2014: American military withdraws from the Korean Peninsula. General Motors declares bankruptcy for the second time.
* 2015: The effects of peak oil are felt as gas prices reach up to 20 dollars a gallon. Russia cuts off all oil trade with Europe. survivalist literature becomes best selling in America. China's influences diminish.
* 2016: America withdraws its military from Japan and other countries overseas, focusing on its instability back home. Texas splits from the United States, border bloodshed takes place as refugees from other states attempt to enter Texas.
* 2017: Martial law is declared in the United States as its infrastructure crumbles due to financial difficulties.
* 2018: Japan surrenders to the Greater Korean Republic, and is capitalized into a vassal state.
* 2019: The UN is dissolved.
* 2020: Poo poo willys bums arses.
* 2021: Korean forces succeed in annexing many countries in East Asia. A new pandemic known as the Knoxville Cough begins to spread in the United States.
* 2022: Mexico closes its borders to Americans.
* 2023: The Knoxville Cough ravages the American public. The Korean People's Army reaches 20 million total personnel.
* 2024: The Greater Korean Republic starts launching their own satellites, claiming to bring a message of peace to the world.
* 2025: An EMP Burst is emitted by a Korean sattelite, it completely destabilizes the United States infrastructure. This is followed by the Korean seizure of Hawaii and landings in San Francisco.
* 2026: The United States is split into two as Korean occupiers irradiate the entire Mississippi River and occupies the Western side.
* 2027: The United States Armed Forces are completely scattered.
Like it or not that's a good story.

America isn't as invulnerable as some of you like to think.
No, it isn't, it is idiotic beyond belief.

North Korea has an estimated population of around 24 million according to wikipedia, and I recall the US population passing 300 million not too long ago. Adding to that is the constant famines that have plagued North Korea since the 1990s, producing a generation of crippled NKs at least. Adding to that is the requirement to garrison South Korea (which enjoys a 2:1 numerical superiority to the North in manpower), Japan and "Many countries in East Asia" (China, with a population of 1,5 billion, and presumably South-East asia with a population of 0,6 million, and also taking into account the Japanese population of about 127 million, that means that North Korea is outnumbered 112 to 1.

In comparison Afghanistan has a total population of 28 million and its insurgency has managed to hold its ground for almost a decade against the US occupation and collaboration government.

In addition, Korean re-unification isn't sure to happend over two decades even if the North reforms into a democratic state with a market economy, let alone over 2 years with communism still present.

Furthermore, the instability plotline in the US is quite absurd, as the union has endured much worse crisis in the past (Such as the Great Depression and the civil war), and despite harsh rhethoric in American politics I don't see the disintegration happending within 30 years.

If this story was set in an alternate universe or centuries in the future, fair enough, things would have changed - but the plotline listed there is the developers insulting the intelligence of anyone with a basic grasp of world affairs.

Mind you I'm only covering a small portion of why the plotline is idiotic but this is what draws the most ire, and before you go off labelling me as an American conservative, I'd like to draw attention to the fact that I am a Danish socialist.
 

captaincabbage

New member
Apr 8, 2010
3,149
0
0
gmaverick019 said:
borderlands.

fuck that fucking ending and fuck the games build up to it
Hell yeah. That was some bullshit right there. The Armory of General Knoxx was awesome tho. ;P

OT: Fucking Dead Rising 2. That shit was so badly acted and written I swear it gave me internal hemorrhaging.

Don't even get me started on Resident Evil 5. Tho it was bad in a hilarious way.
 

captaincabbage

New member
Apr 8, 2010
3,149
0
0
Istvan said:
dathwampeer said:
Istvan said:
The upcoming "Homefront", with Modern Warfare 2 in hot pursuit, due to the most blatantly idiotic plot lines since the emo dance scene in Spider-man 3.
Actually. When you read into the timeline. It's not idiotic, at all.

wiki said:
Timeline

* 2011: North Korea faces another UN sanction over its latest nuclear test.
* 2012: Kim Jong-il passes away, he is succeeded by his son Kim Jong-un.
* 2013: Kim Jong-un is awarded the Nobel Peace Prize and featured on the cover of Time magazine for his accomplishment of Korean reunification.
* 2014: American military withdraws from the Korean Peninsula. General Motors declares bankruptcy for the second time.
* 2015: The effects of peak oil are felt as gas prices reach up to 20 dollars a gallon. Russia cuts off all oil trade with Europe. survivalist literature becomes best selling in America. China's influences diminish.
* 2016: America withdraws its military from Japan and other countries overseas, focusing on its instability back home. Texas splits from the United States, border bloodshed takes place as refugees from other states attempt to enter Texas.
* 2017: Martial law is declared in the United States as its infrastructure crumbles due to financial difficulties.
* 2018: Japan surrenders to the Greater Korean Republic, and is capitalized into a vassal state.
* 2019: The UN is dissolved.
* 2020: Poo poo willys bums arses.
* 2021: Korean forces succeed in annexing many countries in East Asia. A new pandemic known as the Knoxville Cough begins to spread in the United States.
* 2022: Mexico closes its borders to Americans.
* 2023: The Knoxville Cough ravages the American public. The Korean People's Army reaches 20 million total personnel.
* 2024: The Greater Korean Republic starts launching their own satellites, claiming to bring a message of peace to the world.
* 2025: An EMP Burst is emitted by a Korean sattelite, it completely destabilizes the United States infrastructure. This is followed by the Korean seizure of Hawaii and landings in San Francisco.
* 2026: The United States is split into two as Korean occupiers irradiate the entire Mississippi River and occupies the Western side.
* 2027: The United States Armed Forces are completely scattered.
Like it or not that's a good story.

America isn't as invulnerable as some of you like to think.
No, it isn't, it is idiotic beyond belief.

North Korea has an estimated population of around 24 million according to wikipedia, and I recall the US population passing 300 million not too long ago. Adding to that is the constant famines that have plagued North Korea since the 1990s, producing a generation of crippled NKs at least. Adding to that is the requirement to garrison South Korea (which enjoys a 2:1 numerical superiority to the North in manpower), Japan and "Many countries in East Asia" (China, with a population of 1,5 billion, and presumably South-East asia with a population of 0,6 million, and also taking into account the Japanese population of about 127 million, that means that North Korea is outnumbered 112 to 1.

In comparison Afghanistan has a total population of 28 million and its insurgency has managed to hold its ground for almost a decade against the US occupation and collaboration government.

In addition, Korean re-unification isn't sure to happend over two decades even if the North reforms into a democratic state with a market economy, let alone over 2 years with communism still present.

Furthermore, the instability plotline in the US is quite absurd, as the union has endured much worse crisis in the past (Such as the Great Depression and the civil war), and despite harsh rhethoric in American politics I don't see the disintegration happending within 30 years.

If this story was set in an alternate universe or centuries in the future, fair enough, things would have changed - but the plotline listed there is the developers insulting the intelligence of anyone with a basic grasp of world affairs.

Mind you I'm only covering a small portion of why the plotline is idiotic but this is what draws the most ire, and before you go off labelling me as an American conservative, I'd like to draw attention to the fact that I am a Danish socialist.
But. . . It is an alternate universe.
 

Sniper Team 4

New member
Apr 28, 2010
5,433
0
0
Bayonetta, H.A.W.X 2, and the Left 4 Dead series.

Bayonetta got so absurd and unlinked in its story that I lost interest. I'm suddenly fighting in space, with no real reason why? Okay...
H.A.W.X 2 was simply bad. Both of those games I never finished beating, which for me is a big deal.

Left 4 Dead was a let down, seeing as how well Valve can tell stories in its other franchises. They fixed it a little in L4D2, but it's still missing something that makes me actually care.
 

timeadept

New member
Nov 23, 2009
413
0
0
gmaverick019 said:
timeadept said:
gmaverick019 said:
For the pokemon thing i can see where your coming from, but at the same time it has a nice simplicity to it that's why it works out so well for kids/anyone of any age.

mercenaries 2 i will agree with though, fuck that shit.

for my own submission?

borderlands.

fuck that fucking ending and fuck the games build up to it
I actually quite liked borderlands. I don't feel that the game was about the story and so i feel that the minimalist approach to story telling that they took worked well. There were subtle things going on through out the game, you always knew you were going to find the vault, yeah i expected an ancient treasure trove of advanced (yet ancient) weapons (i never understand the idea that these guys were capable of such advanced feats of technology and yet they are all gone today and the knowledge lost and forgotten) but there were hints that there was something else in there. Sure i was disappointed by the lack of loot for bringing down that behemoth, but i felt that the story was told well up to that point and so i was willing to forgive the lack of guns and enjoy how that little mystery unfolded.

I don't really have a good candidate for my worst story ever, comparing what I've played through so far of golden sun dark dawn i have to say that i am very disappointed, it is nothing compared to the first game (golden sun + TLA = 1 story = a 2 part game(don't take this too literally please)).

There are other games that i ignore the (already bad) story completely cause i'm in it for the gameplay, ie. just cause 2 and magicka. Though magicka is a special cause cause it's trying to be silly but the story actually got in the way of the game for me. I just wanted to blow shit up, i didn't care why, so any pause in the action for a cutsceen or story telling was usually unwelcome.
there was nothing wrong with the game actually, i loved the borderlands game, but the story started off decent enough, but with how the game ended?

no. no thank you. it ruined the rest of it completely.

now that isn't the WORST i have ever had, by far, but when you have a game build up all that to the vault and the end and that annoying *****, and you have it go down like that? that was easily one of the worst endings for one of the better build ups i have had in any video game.
Oh that's right, i remember now, the game ended for me when the credits started rolling :p. Tannis was just epilogue and yeah, not very rewarding for epilogue but like i said, i shot the big thing in the face till it died, saw that Hyperion was behind the blue girl thing transmissions in some way and the game was over. I'm still not sure if she works for Hyperion or was just using their equipment or what. But i felt like i had been a part of something REALLY big, bigger than i could have imagined. The game ended there for me and i stopped caring about a story that they obviously weren't going to continue. But i wish they had.
 

Soviet Steve

New member
May 23, 2009
1,511
0
0
dathwampeer said:
The only thing I'll give you is that it happens too quickly.

Jong-un doesn't forcibly absorb south Korea. He tries to make it seem like he has no interest in carrying on his fathers legacy and offers an olive branch. And when America pulls out of Japan. You'd better believe Korea could take them over. Military wise Japan isn't all that impressive at the minute.

The American instability line is actually quite good. Disintegration could happen very quickly with so many factors.
Regardless of Jong-un's actions the scenario is absolutely ridiculous. Any progress with Korean unification would take decades, and I can guarantee you that the South wouldn't elect a Heavenly Great Father, Briliant Comrade and Dear Great Leader, much less try to invade China, Japan, South-east Asia and America because he tells them to.

If this was set as a guerilla war in South Korea under Northern Occupation after the US had pulled out of the place following the financial crisis, it would be taking big liberties with how the world works, but it would be excusable. As it stands it's as likely a story as Rhode Island, with it's 1 million citizens, breaking off the US and managing to invade and annex Britain and France (roughly same ratio)

As for the financial plot point, financial crisis has been done before, and much worse, without disintegration happening. Disease has also occurred without countries falling apart (Remember the Spanish Flu)

I'll give you that Japan's military isn't impressive at the moment, but neither was the military of Afghanistan, and the US is not having a good time there.
 

whitewolf35

New member
Nov 6, 2010
18
0
0
Many of the mario games lack storytelling but for me Black Ops has to take this prize.
Sure it was interesting at first but by the end I somewhat wanted to cry because it dramatically shifts tones, style and anything I could have thought of for absolute grime
 

SIXVI06-M

New member
Jan 7, 2011
245
0
0
MasochisticMuse said:
Tetris.

I mean, it's like they weren't even trying.
Weren't trying? weren't trying?! WEREN'T TRYING?!?!?!

WATCH THIS AND LEARN: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWTFG3J1CP8
 

RaffB

New member
Jul 22, 2008
277
0
0
Final Fantasy 13

I'm one of a few that love the gameplay and battle system, but the story just drains....

No game should require you to have an encyclopedia or journal of notes to remember what the hell is happening and what all the imaginary places/things/maguffins are called...

p.s. FF13 is a brilliant game in my view, as long as its not compared to ANY other FF game.
 

imaloony

New member
Nov 19, 2009
1,025
0
0
Mercenaries 2 certainly is up there...
I personally hated the plot of the 2008 Prince of Persia game. While at first it just seemed mediocre, the ending was such an earth-shattering kick to the nuts that you honestly wanted to reach into the game and beat The Prince so bad that Nolan North would feel it.
Anyone who has played that Prince of Persia game knows what I'm talking about. Just... wow.
 

cgmetallica1981

New member
Mar 15, 2010
295
0
0
Jesus Christ, whats with you guys and bashing the Borderlands ending? Oh boo-hoo, you didn't get OP guns when you killed the final boss. What did you expect? At the beginning they even said clearly that the Vault was just a legend.
 

EasySt17

New member
Dec 18, 2009
57
0
0
DragonBorn96 said:
Prototype, its hard to like a story revolving around a killer who can eat anyone then elbow drop into the crowds. I will summarise its plot = Kill.Kill.Kill.Feel sorry for self.Kill.Kill.kill.kill
I never felt compelled to feel sorry for him...but then again I was only in it for the murderlust anyway...
 

Dfskelleton

New member
Apr 6, 2010
2,851
0
0
F.E.A.R. 2 was probably written by a bunch of perverted idiots who were trying to squeeze in as much full frontal nudity as possible in a series that had absolutely no need for it.
Also, Metroid: Other M was horrific.