Who is the most powerful Superhero? - Can't seem to trump Silver Age Superman

dwightsteel

New member
Feb 7, 2007
962
0
0
Island said:
rossatdi said:
Island said:
there is no limit to the hulks power the madder he get the stronger he gets, and in world war hulk he kicked everyone's ass.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvel_vs._DC#Primary_Matches

No ... he hasn't!

And that was facing off against the weaker modern-era supes rather than the over-powered Silver Age Superman.
there is no limit to the hulks power. go to marvel character profiles if you dont believe me.
There is no limit to his power depending on how mad he gets. His power is conditional, which in my mind counts against him. If Superman were in the mood to kill, Supes could drop Hulk on Mars and let him die.
 

dwightsteel

New member
Feb 7, 2007
962
0
0
KSarty said:
I gotta go with Goku. Your argument that he was only looking for a stronger opponent to become stronger himself only works half the time. Freiza, Garlic Jr., the Androids, Cell, and Buu were all opponents whom Goku fought in order to save the Earth/universe. He enjoys the fighting, but that does not make it his only reason for fighting. He is a superhero.
If we were talking modern day Supes, I'd agree with you, but Goku has never pushed a planet out of orbit, like our silver age friend has. Besides, it takes about 10 and half episodes for Goku to produce a spirit bomb. SA Superman would have the fight knocked out of the way in 10 seconds
 

Geamo

New member
Aug 27, 2008
801
0
0
rossatdi said:
Geamo said:
Jimmy Olsen has, at one time, defeated a Kryptonite-suffering Superman.

For more conventional Supers, perhaps Thor using the full extent of his powers?
Apparently he only uses 30% of it most of the time. And even then, it's pretty devestating.

Also (kind of a loophole here), Lex Luthor from Superman:Red Son, when he's an American scientist/hero, that manages to defeat Superman through one sentence.
Take your point but the debate is most powerful hero but 'who could beat superman'. Red Son is awesome on toast but not cannon, the defeat was very subjective.
Fair enough. Thought struck me though. Although he hasn't necissarily been a combatative sort of hero, the Silver Surfer is quite powerful. He has numerous impressive powers; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Surfer#Powers_and_abilities
 

ItsAChiaotzu

New member
Apr 20, 2009
1,496
0
0
Um Goku, quite obviously, can destroy planets easily, move instantly (that's faster than light guys) so I don't think he has much trouble.
 

GloatingSwine

New member
Nov 10, 2007
4,544
0
0
If you're talking about Silver Age "pull new powers out of my ass to solve whatever problem I have right now" Superman, then no, there are no conventional superheroes who can defeat him, you need a god tier reality warper, so Bugs Bunny, Haruhi Suzumiya, or Sailor Cosmos.
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
Geamo said:
rossatdi said:
Geamo said:
Jimmy Olsen has, at one time, defeated a Kryptonite-suffering Superman.

For more conventional Supers, perhaps Thor using the full extent of his powers?
Apparently he only uses 30% of it most of the time. And even then, it's pretty devestating.

Also (kind of a loophole here), Lex Luthor from Superman:Red Son, when he's an American scientist/hero, that manages to defeat Superman through one sentence.
Take your point but the debate is most powerful hero but 'who could beat superman'. Red Son is awesome on toast but not cannon, the defeat was very subjective.
Fair enough. Thought struck me though. Although he hasn't necissarily been a combatative sort of hero, the Silver Surfer is quite powerful. He has numerous impressive powers; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Surfer#Powers_and_abilities
That's a good one actually. Green Lantern is often given as a potential challenger to the crown and Silver Surfer beat him in the crossover battle. I suspect that Superman's sheer power and resilience would probably inch it though.
 

dwightsteel

New member
Feb 7, 2007
962
0
0
Island said:
dwightsteel said:
Island said:
rossatdi said:
Island said:
there is no limit to the hulks power the madder he get the stronger he gets, and in world war hulk he kicked everyone's ass.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvel_vs._DC#Primary_Matches

No ... he hasn't!

And that was facing off against the weaker modern-era supes rather than the over-powered Silver Age Superman.
there is no limit to the hulks power. go to marvel character profiles if you dont believe me.
There is no limit to his power depending on how mad he gets. His power is conditional, which in my mind counts against him. If Superman were in the mood to kill, Supes could drop Hulk on Mars and let him die.
the hulk can survive in the vacuum of outer space. anyway you cant kill anger incarnate and superman's a boyscout and would never do that. also i dont even know if i would consider superman a hero or just a weapon for the government.
A weapon of the government? Have you even read DC continuity outside of Frank Miller's DKR? He's never been a government pawn, most especially when Lex Luthor was the President.

And the Hulk is not anger incarnate. He has to keep getting more and more angry. His power is conditional. As was pointed out, given the chance, Superman could more then likely calm him down. Besides, it's not like Superman hasn't beat the Hulk before.

EDIT: and as if the Hulk is more of a Superhero then Superman. He fucking leveled Manhatten in World War Hulk. He was all about vengence. You claim Superman isn't a hero but the Hulk is? That's a very weak argument.
 

GloatingSwine

New member
Nov 10, 2007
4,544
0
0
Island said:
the hulk can survive in the vacuum of outer space. anyway you cant kill anger incarnate and superman's a boyscout and would never do that. also i dont even know if i would consider superman a hero or just a weapon for the government.
See, you don't know about Silver Age Supes. Against the Hulk he'd use his Super-Psychotherapy to work out Hulk's anger issues, restoring him to being Banner forever. That's just the sort of shit he did, week in week out.
 

hermes

New member
Mar 2, 2009
3,865
0
0
Godbutbetter said:
Superman is probably the best, but It's just so cheap. I could make a hero named Ultraman who could fly at twice the speed of light and move planets with his little toe, but would that really be that cool?
In that case, I will vote for Arale... Superman stands no chance.
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
hermes200 said:
Godbutbetter said:
Superman is probably the best, but It's just so cheap. I could make a hero named Ultraman who could fly at twice the speed of light and move planets with his little toe, but would that really be that cool?
In that case, I will vote for Arale... Superman stands no chance.
Sorry man: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultraman_(comics)

That's the point isn't it though. I was trying to say supes is good because of it (the opposite is true) but simply to ascertain the most powerful superhero in standard continuity.
 

CaptainCrunch

Imp-imation Department
Jul 21, 2008
711
0
0
Couple of things for the Superman fans:

1) Superman entrusted Batman with a shard of kryptonite, stating if anything happened to make Superman go crazy, Batman is the only one who could actually complete the task. This is due to Batman's lack of Eagle Scout morality, and cunning ability to shield himself from Superman's telepathic-like ability. (He thinks at super speed too, which works out sort of like pre-cognition + mind reading.)

2) Captain Marvel is basically the same thing as Superman, but his powers are based on magic. Superman is weak against magic, hence Captain Marvel could easily kill him (if his moral obligation would allow it.) See Kingdom Come for details (not canon, but it's based on canon.)

3) Hal Jordan, while under the influence of Parallax, killed a bunch of Green Lanterns and Sinestro Corps, and collected their rings. He could have killed Superman, with one energy or another. After all, the Green Lanterns are essentially space cops, and the energy they use is supposed to be pervasive to all but yellow (until later, when conquering great fear removes the weakness to yellow.)

Anyway, reality-changing powers aside, Superman is definitely the hero with the most brute-force power.
 

Sparrow

New member
Feb 22, 2009
6,848
0
0
The Lone Wanderer. Duh.

ShredHead said:
Um Goku, quite obviously, can destroy planets easily, move instantly (that's faster than light guys) so I don't think he has much trouble.
Actually, this guy has a point. Didn't Goku accidentally destory a planet once?
 

Joshimodo

New member
Sep 13, 2008
1,956
0
0
BrynThomas said:
Dr Manhattan, but only if he saw himself win in the future. Does he work with your rules?
This.


As far as I know, he's the most powerful superhero about. Chances are someone has thought of something more ridiculously overpowered though.

Anti-Monitor is probably one of the most powerful supervillains though.

Nasty_Taco said:
Peter Petrelli: Heroes, but only in the first season.
Agreed. Though, if some superhero/villain had a power similar to the Haitian, he'd be in big trouble.
 

ElTigreSantiago

New member
Apr 23, 2009
875
0
0
dwightsteel said:
KSarty said:
I gotta go with Goku. Your argument that he was only looking for a stronger opponent to become stronger himself only works half the time. Freiza, Garlic Jr., the Androids, Cell, and Buu were all opponents whom Goku fought in order to save the Earth/universe. He enjoys the fighting, but that does not make it his only reason for fighting. He is a superhero.
If we were talking modern day Supes, I'd agree with you, but Goku has never pushed a planet out of orbit, like our silver age friend has. Besides, it takes about 10 and half episodes for Goku to produce a spirit bomb. SA Superman would have the fight knocked out of the way in 10 seconds
Move planets? Goku can DESTROY planets, effortlessly at that. Goku fought guys that can destroy planets with ease in the very first episode. Also, Goku can teleport across the universe in a split second. Superman might have a tiny bit of trouble with that. Superman's enemies don't even compare to the guys Goku beat.

And that's just Goku by himself. If he fused with Vegeta, it would be a pretty one-sided fight.
 

rossatdi

New member
Aug 27, 2008
2,542
0
0
CaptainCrunch said:
Couple of things for the Superman fans:

2) Captain Marvel is basically the same thing as Superman, but his powers are based on magic. Superman is weak against magic, hence Captain Marvel could easily kill him (if his moral obligation would allow it.) See Kingdom Come for details (not canon, but it's based on canon.)

3) Hal Jordan, while under the influence of Parallax, killed a bunch of Green Lanterns and Sinestro Corps, and collected their rings. He could have killed Superman, with one energy or another. After all, the Green Lanterns are essentially space cops, and the energy they use is supposed to be pervasive to all but yellow (until later, when conquering great fear removes the weakness to yellow.)

Anyway, reality-changing powers aside, Superman is definitely the hero with the most brute-force power.
2) Captain Marvel has been beaten by Superman is some versions. Justice League cartoon jumps to mind.

3) Hal under Parallax wasn't a superhero.
 

Joshimodo

New member
Sep 13, 2008
1,956
0
0
ElTigreSantiago said:
Move planets? Goku can DESTROY planets, effortlessly at that. Goku fought guys that can destroy planets with ease in the very first episode. Also, Goku can teleport across the universe in a split second. Superman might have a tiny bit of trouble with that. Superman's enemies don't even compare to the guys Goku beat.

And that's just Goku by himself. If he fused with Vegeta, it would be a pretty one-sided fight.

Effortlessly? Goku has to charge his powers for half a season to destroy planets. Not to mention he can be killed (and has been), and that he has to get beaten by every enemy to come back stronger. Granted, the Vegeto fusion probably would provide a much better match for Silver Age Superman, but even then, Superman is invincible.

Goku would probably win though, since he'd just grab Superman and instantly trans-locate him to the largest amount of Kryptonite possible.