He kills a man who is scared shitless, has an unborn child, and a wife. Then promptly says, in the most insincere manner: "I'm sorry it had to be this way." *Twists knife further*
He basically is the one saying 'but thou must', in the begining. "Oh, you don't want to come? Well fuck you. Rite of conscription *****, I own you now."
He dies in some heroic battle, where he tackles one ogre to the ground, killing it. Hey, guess what. I KILLED ONE ON THE WAY TO THE FRICKING SIGNAL. It isn't awesome, it isn't badass, its average.
And he goes on and on about how Greywardens are so *totally* needed, and its awesome because you can sense darkspawn....but you can't, you never do. The only mechanical setup for it is a bloody extra skillpoint. You don't even get the special 'dark spawn' sense. You're even sneak attacked in the bloody camp, by Darkspawn, and nobody gets a warning.
The worst part, Alistar looks up to this jackass like he's some sort of divine being brought down to live with us mortals. Bring up the fact that he just fucking KILLED A MAN who was simply scared shitless, wanted to go home to his wife and unborn child, and was clearly holding his weapon defensively. He didn't stop a crazed man who could have done anything, he is a fucking MURDERER.
Bring up this fact, and Alistar has all the temperment of a three year old child. Stamping his foot and going 'NUH UH! HE'S AWESOME! AN' SUPER! AN' POWERFUL! AN' CAN KICK YOUR ASSS!'