Your most overrated game(s) of last decade

Recommended Videos

Thyunda

New member
May 4, 2009
2,955
0
0
Oddly enough, Borderlands, despite the fact I thoroughly enjoy playing it. When it was advertised, it gave off such an aura of variety that it caught my attention. Irritatingly enough, now that I play the game fairly regularly, all the variety is in the guns. And they're niggly things, like leaf-litter. Occasionally you find a bright, pretty flower, but the rest of it is all shop-food. Dead leaves you trample over.
And the variety is only in the weapons. You get like...three types of each enemy. Bandits? You have gunners, psychos and bruisers. With small variations on each. They all look identical, too. No fun.
And on the note of the weapons, I've got a Scoped Stomper or something, 18 shots in a clip, fires in three-shot bursts. Two bursts to the head will kill practically anything, and even Baron Flynt died in a matter of seconds when he floored me.

Black Ops claims the award for overrated as well. Admittedly, I've not played the story at all yet, but the online play is almost identical to previous games, except for the addition of the flamethrower, which is a lot of fun.

Interestingly, I viewed Fallout: New Vegas as rather underrated. Why? Well, all the forums talking about it complained about its flaws. Nobody ever mentioned any good points. They said it was Fallout 3 with a smaller map and more bugs.
This is easily my favourite game of the year. As for the decade...I don't know. I just prefer the Western feel the latest game has. It has a completely different tone to the third game, so although the gameplay is near-identical, it still feels like a very different game.
 

Anti Nudist Cupcake

New member
Mar 23, 2010
1,054
0
0
My NUMBER ONE overrated game of 2010 has GOT to be Dragon age:eek:rigins.

The story is NOT amazing enough to justify the terrible-absolutely-everything-else in the game.
Hell, the story wasn't even amazing at all, it's just "meh".

Graphics were poor, it was a chore to fight people, uninspiring combat, and when I think "fantasy" I don't think of a boring dull rusty-dusty color scheme.

At least world of warcraft was fun for a week or so, at least world of warcraft STARTED fun ,I hear that the quests were significantly improved in cataclysm though so I might give it a try.

Now that I think about it...

Wow isn't terrible but overrated, but so is:

Half life 1, 2 and all the episodes.
Kotor
Call of duty 4 5 6 and 7
crysis
crysis warhead
aliens vs predator 1

But borderlands was down right awful.

Is anybody seeing a connection between reviewer scores and the opinion of the public? In that there ISN'T ANY? ALL BIG-ASS REVIEWERS ARE BEING PAID TO PRAISE CRAPPY GAMES!
The bastards, they sold their souls...
 

Caiti Voltaire

New member
Feb 10, 2010
383
0
0
Kajt said:
IamSofaKingRaw said:
Mass Effect
Omnific One said:
Dragon Age
These two. You hear almost nothing but praise for these games, but I found them to have horribly boring gameplay and settings. >.>
Don't watch ZP, huh? :p

Honestly though, Dragon Age is popular because its a return to yesteryear, an RPG with story and plenty of stats to min/max; but I think we're fooling ourselves if we try to think that there aren't a lot of people who didnt get it to watch a female warden get it on PG-13 style with Leliana in the same way that there were plenty of people who got ME for the pg-13 scene with that alien chick. Lesbian romance seems like it'll be a popular feature of many Bioware games to come. And it kind of irritates me, because its taking that whole thing and turning it smut romance. If I wanted that, Id buy Harlequin novels, or whatever.
 

Wereduck

New member
Jun 17, 2010
383
0
0
+1 for Bioshock
Also: Beyond Good and Evil

I don't think GTA IV qualifies because although it did get a lot of praise there are also lots of enthusiastic detractors. I'd agree that it was one of the most over-hyped games, but it gets way too much hatred to be called one of the most overrated.

MrShowerHead said:
...
Okay, sometimes it feels like I'm the only one who didn't have problems with Roman or anyone calling you all the time. I think he called me a total of 3 times in the entire game. And the others didn't call me at all.
You are a fortunate man indeed. In my first run Roman was killed in a drive-by and I was upset only because I'd wanted to kill him myself.
 
May 5, 2010
4,831
0
0
Batman: AA. I just couldn't get into that game. Even WITH all that stealthy Batman stuff, it still wasn't all that fun. And the writing was absolutely terrible. I mean really, really, really, REALLY terrible.
 

BlastedTheWorm

New member
Jan 26, 2010
480
0
0
The entire Call of Duty Series.

Half-Life 2: Great game, not the second coming of Christ.

BioShock: It just struck me as pretentious.

I can't think of anything else at the moment. I know there's more, but none spring to mind.
 

theSovietConnection

Survivor, VDNKh Station
Jan 14, 2009
2,418
0
0
Fedp0p said:
If you judge a game based on the fact that little annoying five year olds play it, are you really judging the game? or its community? Don't get me wrong, I hate them as much as you do. But claiming that the gameplay was "average" is simply untrue. It is your opinion, which I can't really say is "wrong", but there had never been anything like it up until that point. It was well executed in my opinion.
I have to agree with this, a game's community shouldn't really be how you judge a game overall.

Anyways, on topic, I hate to sound like someone just going "herp derp, popular game", but I really find Half-Life 2 rather overrated. I think a lot of that has to do with how hyped it was before I finally played it, otherwise it would have been an okay shooter. Can't think of any others right now, will edit them in if I do.

EDIT: I don't think Halo is one of the most overrated, as far as this forum goes, anyways. 5 games does not a milked series make.
 

C95J

I plan to live forever.
Apr 10, 2010
3,491
0
0
manythings said:
In a universe with the Halo franchise (the exact same game released about 5 times now) you can never say HL:2 was over-hyped.
I think you may have quoted the wrong person because I never said that HL:2 was over-hyped...
 

jamradar

New member
Sep 13, 2010
609
0
0
Yet another thread where people will just spout out games that are popular, after all if so many people love a game it has to be bad,.
 

Caiti Voltaire

New member
Feb 10, 2010
383
0
0
I think Half-Life 2 got me with the gimmicks. I don't know how many times I had to do those bloody stacking puzzles, but it is not my idea of rivetting story development or intense action sequences.

[edit]: And they seemed forced. In HL1, you had gimmicks, but they were environmental puzzles while you tried to get out. And they didn't repeat themselves. Once you fried the alien in the rocket test chamber, you didnt have to go and do it five more times. It took a neat trick and made it mundane and repetitive.
 

Gindil

New member
Nov 28, 2009
1,621
0
0
Fedp0p said:
If you judge a game based on the fact that little annoying five year olds play it, are you really judging the game? or its community? Don't get me wrong, I hate them as much as you do. But claiming that the gameplay was "average" is simply untrue. It is your opinion, which I can't really say is "wrong", but there had never been anything like it up until that point. It was well executed in my opinion.
Everything is subjective, that's true. But there are some things you learn from both the gameplay and the community that can make a bad impression on you.

Halo for example, didn't do anything new, it just did it first on the console.

Final Fantasy was good in its tenth iteration but... It has been slowly going downhill since the changing of the guard IMO.

If I could say there was a game that was overrated, I would personally nominate Jade Empire. You really only had two roads to follow and every female actor looked like Lucy Liu...

Seriously did that game need a good sequel and a lot of duck butter...
 

El Danny

New member
Dec 7, 2008
149
0
0
Modern Warfare/Black Ops and Uncharted.

Two game series I completely fail to see the appeal of.
 

nuba km

New member
Jun 7, 2010
5,052
0
0
in order:
1st call of duty(all from 4 onwards except WAW) (by far)
2nd halo reach
3rd mass effect
4th super meat boy
5th limbo
 

SyphonX

Coffee Bandit
Mar 22, 2009
956
0
0
Any of the Call of Duty entries. I mean really.

Anything original brought to the table? It's basically a $60 ticket to a 4 hour experience. A lot of us don't even care about the multiplayer, which is extremely lackluster at best. Tiny maps, lots of nerd-rage and frustrations, zero strategy. Basically 1990's level of game tech and somehow it's a bestseller all the time.

It sells well in active military nations. Coincidence? Probably not.

Also, "It's popular because it's fun." Not true, it's popular because people buy what their friends buy. You're lucky if you have a group of friends to play with, but at that point, any game is fun. Everyone I know that plays Call of Duty, does nothing but complain about multiplayer and that they basically just spend a few hours screaming and swearing.

Frankly, it's creepy, given the world circumstances.

So that's my winded rant on most overrated (franchise) of the decade, marked as of yesterday.
 

Sir Prize

New member
Dec 29, 2009
428
0
0
Halo- It's decent enough but just got a little stale after a while, I can see it's appeal but I'm not much of an online type. I probably would have liked it if not for the lack of anything really interesting or eyecatching, it like water or diet coke. It's fun but nothing to get excited about.

Mass Effect- Don't get me wrong, the games are good but there was just so much focus on the depth of morals choices, which weren't all that deep. Being a niceguy or jerk doesn't really change anything in a drastic way and you can get by with either. You don't block off anything important when taking one route.

Final Fantasty- This is just a personal opinion. I've listened to a friend saying how good the lastest one was, but I couldn't really get into it. It all seemed a little too familar to me and...I didn't really like any of the character's.