Your top 5 games' flaws

[teudys]

Skyrim- you can't make your on spell like in oblivion which make playing a game boring in my opinion

Dragon Dogma- personally felt you need a horse game world could have been bigger

Dark soul- PvP not that great has it moment but one flaw in otherwise great game

avernum escape from the pit- to easy to cheat to victory

mass effect 3- felt to much like a third person shooter and not enough like a RPG

 

[hoboman29]

Timesplitters 2 - my god the graphics have not aged well and the aiming can get awkward when the crosshair resets position when the analogue stick is neutral

Guilty Gear XX Accent Core - the infamous difficulty and learning curves for this game I play on normal and still get my ass kicked a lot.

Devil May Cry 3 (normal edition) - one HELL of a difficulty jump between hard and dante must die and platforming is clunky.

Fallout New Vegas - lags real badly when you have all the dlc installed and I like the dlc.

Blazblue - Fairly small roster and I like to play a lot of characters

Ultimate Marvel vs Capcom 3 - level 3 x factor wesker (he was my main in vanilla but ever since ultimate I don't like using him cause of that)

 

[WoW Killer]

For Guild Wars 2 my main complaint is the total lack of coherence and strategy in group play. I did this fight earlier:

Spoiler

I managed about two frames a second, and spent half the fight swinging into thin air because I couldn't see where the mob was. As well as being unpleasant, it was also kind of easy. The game works really well with small numbers of people about, but with that many it's nonsense.

Ummm... Skyrim, and TES in general; awful balance. You get character options that can be either useless or game-breaking, with no middle ground, depending on whether you exploit or not. Take Destruction magic. Absolute crap compared to melee or bow, unless you exploit the dual-cast stun-locking in which case you can take on anything without a scratch. Oh, and you'll be constantly starved of magic points, that is unless you enchant yourself for free casts eliminating the need for resources entirely.

That's all I can think of right now.

 

[thePyro_13]

AOEO: pro required to use nonshit items, makes getting anywhere high level a *****.

SupCom: the way the economy works allows players with succifiant numbers of engineers to bypass the normal builds time and costs, pretty much fucking up any long game(as someone will always just give up on manageing their eco and just exploit out a fucktonne of gunships).

new CS: joining a server runnning cs_italy seems to break the whole game, if it doesn't crash or kick you, then you end up playing with massive lag,

Killing floor: doesn't respect the OS setting to flip mouse buttons, resulting in many rage from someone trying to use a left handed razor mouse.

not really a gamebut: Left handed razor mice: WTF, they wired the buttons back to front. thereby breaking pretty much every game ever. I just wanted a mouse that fit in my hand easily, now i have to rely on game developers who don't bother to support a really simple setting that has existed since windows 95. Although valve, relic and blizzard seem to get it right.

CoH: the multiplayer wasn't very well thought through. any non-tiny map turns into a stalemate with massive amounts of arty spam.

Dead Space: doesn't respect mouse setting to flip buttons yay.

 

[Evil Smurf]

1. tf2: no one is willing to make a decent MvM team with you!
2. Pokeomon (in general): I want a the game to have more then onereason too catch all the pokemon
3. Skyward Sword: I just fount it boring halve way through
4. Sid Meier's Alpha Centuri: why was it so hard to find a game to buy?
5. Mario Games: why do I care about Peach's constant kidnapping?

 

[ward0630]

Fallout New vegas: bugs. So many bugs.
Battlefield 3: the campaign sucks
Cod Modern Warfare 3 (PC): HAX!!!!!!!
The Political Machine 2012: No debates or conventions
Half life 2: That one bit with the train on the bridge and you're driving and you have to decide whether to speed up or back up, and I always tried to go forward, speeding up, but it NEVER worked, and I always felt like I had cheated a little bit when I got past.

 

[StashAugustine]

Deus Ex: The original had godawful voice acting and iffy shooting/stealth mechanics; the sequel (the good one) is a little unbalanced, has a weak ending and badly done boss fights.
Mass Effect: The main plot just kept getting worse, ME1 and 2 had weak gameplay.
Fallout: New Vegas: Buggy, combat got old, companion quests very hard to activate.
Metal Gear Solid 3: Unnecessary exposition, poor pacing, occasionally outright bad dialogue, shooting felt clunky.
Bastion: Not so much flaws as it could have done more- combat got a little old and the narrator could have been more nonlinear.

 

[CannibalCorpses]

1) Fallout 2: Amazing game and broken in lots of different ways. Quests don't work, infinite cash loops, auto-hostile enemies for no reason...still my favourite game though

2) Jagged Alliance 2: Cheating computer AI until you get uv goggles but still an amazing concept for a game. Bullshit character levelling and training...'biscuits!'

3) Rockman: Way too small, you can finish a lap in 15 minutes if you know what your doing but thats the Vic 20 gaming style

4) Final Fantasy 10: Unskippable cut scenes before boss fights arggghhhhh! Final boss is a joke if you battle all the dark dudes first.

5) Landstalker: The view makes some of the puzzles frustrating as hell and the music still haunts my nightmares to this day.

Wow, i actually managed to list my 5 favourite games of all time and none of them are on the current generation of platforms...

 

[lacktheknack]

Fable TLC: LET ME PLAY AFTER BEATING THE GAME DAMNIT

You can...

You have to wait through ALL the credits without pushing any buttons. Go make a sandwich and call your Mom, because it'll take fifteen to twenty minutes.

OT: Mirror's Edge: There's one room where you cannot avoid fighting. ONE room. GAH.

Uru: The loading screens are fairly rampant, and the pace is snail-like (which I think of as a feature, but whatever).

The Binding of Isaac: I nearly vomited.

Tropico 4: Each game is slow at the start. Also, construction on a low budget is too damn long.

Dwarf Fortress: Menus. Oh, the menus.

 

[White_Lama]

2: Skyrim - Haven't played it in about 3 months, but no beast race children, no beast race marriages. Kahjiit and Argonian make babies and want to be married too!.

I really agree with the babies and marriage part, but as far as I'm aware off there is at least a female Argonian you can marry, she works at the docks in Windhelm.

EDIT: And apparently there are actually two male Argonians up for marriage, which makes me wonder, why the hell didn't they just put in at least one of each sex for Khajiits :c

 

[Terrible Opinions]

5. Grim Fandango: Pain-in-the-ass inventory; awkward controls.
4. Starcraft Brood War: 'Dat pathfinding.
3. Wind Waker: Too easy.
2. Half-Life 2: Grenades still their own separate weapon? Daaaamn. Also, too many god damn antlions in Episode 2.
1. Planescape Torment: Damn, this one's getting mentioned a lot. Turrible pathfinding and AI, irritating 2nd edition D&D rulest, ugly 3D portraits, the Rubikon dungeon...

 

[Evil Alpaca]

A lot have already been said so I'll go with

Spore - the game tanks after the creature mode. The tribal and civilization parts are on par with flash games created by students. There is no challenge or strategy. The creature phase was a fun game to explore but after you evolve the game becomes terrible.

Mirror's Edge: The cut scenes. The in game scenes were decent yet the game insisted on using those cardboard cutouts.

League of Legends: More of a meta-game flaw but the penalty enforcement on players. I've had tons of games ruined by leavers. What makes it so frustrating is that there is a report function but it doesn't seem to influence a player's decision to quit.

Dawn of War: Soulstorm - The game wasn't bad but the campaign felt like a copy-paste version of Dark Crusade. Nothing about the game seemed new.

 

[Klumpfot]

Quite a fun twist on the old "Your 5 Favourite Games". I can dig it!

Suikoden II: They could've put more effort into the translation.
Tombi: Success or failure in the racing minigame seemed almost entirely random.
Beyond Good & Evil: Please don't make your game the first in an unconfirmed trilogy. Especially when doing so necessitates an ending that doesn't fit with the game as a whole.
Saints Row 2: I wish the city wasn't so lifeless. There are a lot of hidden details, but there's no real incentive to seek them out.
Psychonauts: There is something slightly off about the colours in the game, which makes it harder on my eyes than it should be. Also, I do think that the very uneven difficulty curve is to the game's detriment.

 

[Childe]

I donno, I have level 40+ gear and when I go into the level 20 area, I can't seem to fight off a group of like 3 vetren mobs.. the other day a non vetren killed me, like quick too..

LRN 2 PLAY NUB!

Seriously though, 3 veteran mobs is an ugly pull, that SHOULD be killing you.

I died to a normal worm the other day on my Thief. Just an ordinary level 14 Worm. Are you playing a Thief? Thieves are made of spun sugar and decorative glass.

I dunno so far thief has been a blast to play.... unlike necromancer which was SOOO boring.

On topic:
Dead Space One: level where you have to run thru the ship with the hull breach
Lol: more maps
Dota 2: more frequent updates
WoW/TOR: it better to make the game super easy so we get more people regardless of the fact that that we will lose everyone else

 

[Terrible Opinions]

It got in to an E-Rated SNES game because you're playing a fan-translated ROM?

 

[RedDeadFred]

1. Skyrim -bugs.
2. Mass Effect 2/3 -occasional weird textures.
3. Windwaker -Searching for the Tri-force shards in the ocean.
4. Fallout 3 -bugs.
5. Borderlands -not much variation in environments and main quest took itself to seriously.

 

[shrekfan246]

Halo: Repetitive levels, seriously, the last half of the game was virtually all just backtracking along grey corridors. Especially annoying on that part where the helpful arrows on the floor pointing you in the direction of the control room so you knew you were travelling in the right direction were now pointing in the wrong direction because you were travelling away from the control room

Fuck 'The Library'. It can go straight to hell and never return. I have no clue how such a terrible level made it into a game with otherwise such excellent level design.

OT: Okami: The opening is far too long and the story-line text scrolls too slowly. The character voices could get grating too, since they're little more than exaggerated grunts.

Batman: Arkham City: Two certain side-quests just ended with no actual resolution as sequel-bait, and a lot of them felt a bit aimless and unimportant in the grand scheme of the game. Also, Batman felt a bit out of character in a lot of the cut-scenes.

Mass Effect Series: 1 has terrible gameplay mechanics, 2 hit the sweet spot between gameplay and story but stumbled from the plot not feeling very urgent, 3 has fun gameplay but a very stripped down dialogue system.

Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (Subsistence version, truth be told): Same issues most MGS games have - extreme amounts of exposition and a highly unbalanced gameplay-to-cut-scene ratio. The Cobra Unit, except for The Boss, also felt a little less fleshed out than Kojima usually writes his enemies.

Sonic Generations: Extremely short, and the nature of the game (a 20-year Anniversary thing) means that the levels don't feel connected in any way. Also, unless you mod the game on PC, there's practically no reason to actually use Super Sonic once you've unlocked him, because the only way for him to move faster than Boosting-Normal-Sonic drains Rings extremely fast and makes him move on a predetermined path.

 

[DugMachine]

Skyrim - I love exploring but almost all the caves and dungeons scattered throughout are the same copy/paste cave trolls and bandits.

Team Fortress 2 - Too many people play snipers thinking they're good. You're shite and not getting any points or helping the team in any way.

Minecraft - Setting up in an area and totally tapping out all the resources and having to up and leave -.-.

Left 4 Dead 2 - MOAR CAMPAIGNS DAMMIT

Gears of War (1 2 and 3) - I am convinced there is no skill in the multiplayer whatsoever. I have a theory that cliffy B just sits in this office with a huge panel of player names fighting one another and he rolls a dice to see who should win. God. Damn. SHOTGUNS

 

[Woodsey]

Metro 2033 - Stealth doesn't work anywhere near as effectively as going on a rampage

Works out a lot better in my experience - although it can become slightly tricky when you're outside and lumbered with the possibly-a-bug-but-no-one-actually-fucking-knows gas mask bug. Hell, even if it were demonstrably less effective, there's nothing more satisfying then taking out a room with the throwing knives.

OT: Don't know if I have an actual top 5, so I'll just do the stuff I like that comes to mind:

Deus Ex: Human Revolution - they should have had a Liberty Island level at the start. I get why they didn't, but there are some missions in particular which are incredibly reminiscent of Deus Ex in their design, and they should have opened with something like that.

Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time - combat is crap.

Mafia - it wants to be a film and is pretty much diametrically the opposite of what I say other games should aim to be like (minus the great writing, obviously), but fuck me does give me a stiffy still.

Far Cry 2 - although I remain adamant that everything it does has the effect of pretty much driving you insane and that they totally intended to get that effect, I know that deep deep down, some of the stuff just added to it by pure luck (and it being a little bit poo).

Knights of the Old Republic - no widescreen support, so now when I try and play it again my character has an arse that you could drive a bus through.

 

[meowchef]

Kotor series: not quite enough exploration, and GIVE ME THE DAMN MANDALORIAN HELMETS/ARMOR WHEN I KILL THE BASTARDS. how dare you deny me one of the most awesome armor sets in history..

On the planet you crash land on before the Star Forge you can get that armor and helmet.

This may have been mentioned since you posted, but I didn't check.