Digikid said:
Your an arse, whats wrong with the orignal, you don't think its the best but because of you I now hate Ctrl+Alt+Del.
Zero Punctuation: Webcomics
- Thread starter Yahtzee Croshaw
- Start date
Your an arse, whats wrong with the orignal, you don't think its the best but because of you I now hate Ctrl+Alt+Del.
I agree entirely. There's nothing wrong with writing a serious comic; a comic is a form of media like any other, not one exclusively for humour (the preconception of the comic being exculsively for humour notwithstanding). However, I feel that TB is rather pushing his artistic license by writing a long-running, super-serious storyline that runs alongside the jokes in an established humorous comic.Plowking said:
From reading his News posts and explanations of the storyline it's obvious he has been planning this for some time, so I'm even more in the dark as to why he doesn't split the comic into "Ctrl+Alt+Del: XBox Jokes" and "Ctrl+Alt+Del: Lilah and Ethan Drama". Sorry, but the two really don't mix.
You know, I could say SO much, but all I can say is that its funny how some people bash these other comcis for 'not being funny' or have personal issues against the authers when they defend this one to the death. ZP has gone downhill fast, and no matter how many rambling blathering incoherant text walls people put up the bottom line is that he is simply bashing other people in the same field he is. What gets me though is not that this week bashes Webcomics I like per say, as I don't like all he noted, its that he seems to be going out of his way to find something bash-worthy in his eyes. I miss psychonaughts. There, I said it. I miss it when the man felt like he gave a damn and wasn't just putting up crap because it would tick people off. I miss when he would drag up the name of some amazing game or even one he found amazing and just say "You know what? This kicks ass" instead of just picking the most popular game of the week and ripping it a new in the most ass backwards way he can just because, well I'm not sure why anymore.
And to all of those Yatzee fanboys who defend him I hope you guys really love the direction it is going because you are going to be the majority of his fan base soon. For the past few weeks he seems to have just taken the easy way out,m aybe longer. To be frank it almost seems like he does not care anymore. I for one have no reason to sit here and watch a man just start ragging on things anymore. When he seemed to have some credability, some insight, some vision beyond the norm it was great but the more he opens his mouth lately the more it just seems like hes blurting out more nerd-hate and less actual insight. Oh he doesn't think Penny arcade is funny. Wow... Thats just so amazing. Even if he hates it so what? I really don't give a damn about his opinion on web comics. I could care less what Yatzee does in his free time in regards to what he reads/watches. Next hes going to do a ZP on why he hates hats other than the one he wears or something. WHO CARES?
The man is losing it, and I really hope he gets dropped so that he can go on to something that makes him happy again because its obvious he does not like this job anymore with the lack of work he puts into it.
And to all of those Yatzee fanboys who defend him I hope you guys really love the direction it is going because you are going to be the majority of his fan base soon. For the past few weeks he seems to have just taken the easy way out,m aybe longer. To be frank it almost seems like he does not care anymore. I for one have no reason to sit here and watch a man just start ragging on things anymore. When he seemed to have some credability, some insight, some vision beyond the norm it was great but the more he opens his mouth lately the more it just seems like hes blurting out more nerd-hate and less actual insight. Oh he doesn't think Penny arcade is funny. Wow... Thats just so amazing. Even if he hates it so what? I really don't give a damn about his opinion on web comics. I could care less what Yatzee does in his free time in regards to what he reads/watches. Next hes going to do a ZP on why he hates hats other than the one he wears or something. WHO CARES?
The man is losing it, and I really hope he gets dropped so that he can go on to something that makes him happy again because its obvious he does not like this job anymore with the lack of work he puts into it.
For as much as I hate CAD and his awful characters, themes, and posse/groupies, I think that those fucking dinosaur comics are worse and need litigation against them. They are so terrible it makes my eyes bleed whenever someone posts one ironically on something awful.
Wow, I didn't realise all that stuff he said about the miscarriage actually happened - I thought it was just Yahtzee's usual non-sensical ramblings. I never personally found CAD funny anyway but now I'm really glad I stopped reading it. Did the author actually make any of those comments Yahtzee said in his review?kittenbot said:
Damn, just read that. It was horrible. It had some potentially good jokes in it but something about a miscarriage is just not funny. I mean, the comic's title was changed to Ctrl+Alt+Miscarriage. It's just disturbing to me how someone thinks that's funny. Wow.LumpOfCole said:
Buckley's a pretty despicable piece of human filth to be honest. I read CAD sometimes and found some strips funny, but I never really gave a crap about who was writing it, or bothered reading the news things, but then someone on another forum pointed this exert out from the "So, then... let's chat" update:
Now that's pretty disugsting. He's in a "toxic" relationship, "doomed to fail", yet he'd still have sex with this girl without a rubber? Basically reading between the lines what he's saying is he wasn't happy in the relationship, but he was still going to screw this girl without protection or any form of birth control, and luckily her miscarrying provided him with a convenient way out. How fortunate.Tim Buckley said:
Ya that one's not an actual comic, someone photoshopped, check the actualy site if you want to see the real oneHamster at Dawn said:
Problem is, everything wrong with CAD and webcomics in general has already been said before and more verbosely, by John Soloman.
http://badwebcomics.blogspot.com/2007/06/ctrlaltdel.html
Considering how much he hated Dominic Deegan's orc rape story arc, Buckley's egotistical posturing over the miscarriage stroy would have him turning in his grave.
http://badwebcomics.blogspot.com/2007/06/ctrlaltdel.html
Considering how much he hated Dominic Deegan's orc rape story arc, Buckley's egotistical posturing over the miscarriage stroy would have him turning in his grave.
What makes you think he wasn't using a rubber, or any kind of birth control? Because she got pregnant? Well, not sure if you realize this, but no birth control is 100% effective. However, you want to believe that Tim Buckley is truly evil, willing to force a miscarriage to get out of a relationship, be my guest.Ragamuffin said:
You're assuming that the pregnancy of TB's then girlfriend was his fault. There are so many ways that the various contraceptive types can fail that unwanted pregnancy is still possible even if precautions are taken to prevent it. I'm not a huge fan of TB, but I think your accusation is unwarranted and unfair.Ragamuffin said:
for anyone who wants to see the original version of the comic: http://www.ctrlaltdel-online.com/comic.php
it's a comepletely different thing than that piece of excrement that someone photshopped out of their sick mind
and btw that John Soloman guy is worse than Yahtzee at making a point and having a believable and interesting opinion....the guy just goes on a little tantrum about very little other than the fact that he doesn't like CAD and he's going to be as much of a forum whoring douchebag as possible to get that point across, if that's even a point
it's a comepletely different thing than that piece of excrement that someone photshopped out of their sick mind
and btw that John Soloman guy is worse than Yahtzee at making a point and having a believable and interesting opinion....the guy just goes on a little tantrum about very little other than the fact that he doesn't like CAD and he's going to be as much of a forum whoring douchebag as possible to get that point across, if that's even a point
A condom has about 2% failure rate when used properly, if your girlfriend is on the pill too that chances of unwanted pregnancy are in the decimals. Still, it's nice to see you pick on the idea of birth control over what a little scum bag his is for still screwing a girl in a relationship he openly called "toxic" instead of doing them both a favour and ending it. Also, I never called him evil, there's a big difference between evil and a piece of human waste, which is what I'd call anyone who strings a girl along in a relationship he can't stand just for the sex, which it sounds like exactly what was going on.thebobmaster said:
I find it kind of sad that anyone would go after Buckly for an error most people make. I know several people who are in relationships and have sex when its doomed to fail. Hell from what I understand sex is usually the last thing a couple has when the relationship is When the love is gone most people seem to try and patch things up with sex as its one of the few things they have in common. As for contraceptives, well, as shocking as it is that I am the one to explain this to everyone they do not always work. Everyone makes mistakes, and just because its unplanned and would have been bad for the two of them does not mean that he was not saddened by the miscarrage in some way. Sometimes people do diffrent things to deal with such issues. I just find it sad that people are jumping to conclusions about an issue that is very personal and the way an artist chose to deal with his emotions. Its not your life, you don't know what youd do in the same situation or how you would feel.
What I really find disturbing is that you people can judge him, but I don't hear anyone here praising Jerry Holkins or Mike Krahulik for Childs Play. That was a wonderful thing and I can honestly say the only sad thing is that it is not spreading as far or as fast as it should. But no, you take an expression of someones mixed and confused feelings and use it to say they are a bad person. You don't find it funny thats fine but you all have just as much wrong with you, and I do too.
And Ragamuffin, it can still happen. As I said sex is usually the last resort of a failing relationship and he may not have wanted to admit to himself that it was toxic at the time. He may have been fighting to get himself to see the good in a person he thought he wanted to be with. Again I find it disturbing that you are trying to judge a situation that is personal and that you know NOTHING about.
What I really find disturbing is that you people can judge him, but I don't hear anyone here praising Jerry Holkins or Mike Krahulik for Childs Play. That was a wonderful thing and I can honestly say the only sad thing is that it is not spreading as far or as fast as it should. But no, you take an expression of someones mixed and confused feelings and use it to say they are a bad person. You don't find it funny thats fine but you all have just as much wrong with you, and I do too.
And Ragamuffin, it can still happen. As I said sex is usually the last resort of a failing relationship and he may not have wanted to admit to himself that it was toxic at the time. He may have been fighting to get himself to see the good in a person he thought he wanted to be with. Again I find it disturbing that you are trying to judge a situation that is personal and that you know NOTHING about.