Ukraine

Seanchaidh

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 21, 2009
5,870
3,565
118
Country
United States of America
Already seeing the usual suspects on social media bending over backwards to explain how this isn't Imperialism on the part of Russia.
Why shouldn't they? All they need do is deploy precisely the same arguments as people 'defending Ukrainian sovereignty and democracy from Russia' but substituting Donetsk and Luhansk for Ukraine and Ukraine for Russia; those regions voted for Yanukovich, indeed they are where Yanukovich fled from the Euromaidan protests before he was impeached. And the new Ukrainian regime's idea was to reconquer them. The same logic applies in a rather tranquil symmetry. Just like the same logic applies to NATO expansionism and encirclement of Russia as it does to Russian encirclement of Ukraine (though the details differ a bit more in that case).

Hopefully the wishes of the people of Donetsk and Luhansk will be respected by all parties who end up having a say over their fate, though I don't particularly expect it in any case; given these developments it is good, at least, that civilians have been evacuated from the DPR/LPR-held areas of the Donbas, as interested parties seem determined to have a conflict there. The DPR/LPR are emboldened by Russian recognition, and the Ukraine by NATO supply and rhetoric. It is in fact difficult to tell who is more responsible for the escalation (though I'm certain people who are invested in believing the half of the story they heard first will blame solely one side or the other).
 

Hades

Elite Member
Mar 8, 2013
2,373
1,805
118
Country
The Netherlands
It is in fact difficult to tell who is more responsible for the escalation
Its actually quite easy. The one with the giant invasion force and a history of illegally seizing land is the one responsible for his escalation. The one who seeks to forbid Ukraine and Europe from forming ties is responsible for the escalation. The one who behaves as he Ukraine is his rightful vassal state is the one responsible for the escalation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thestor and Hawki

Seanchaidh

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 21, 2009
5,870
3,565
118
Country
United States of America
Its actually quite easy. The one with the giant invasion force and a history of illegally seizing land is the one responsible for his escalation. The one who seeks to forbid Ukraine and Europe from forming ties is responsible for the escalation. The one who behaves as he Ukraine is his rightful vassal state is the one responsible for the escalation.
As the prophecy foretold, there's that (speaking generously) half of the story...
 

crimson5pheonix

It took 6 months to read my title.
Legacy
Jun 6, 2008
36,527
3,731
118
Its actually quite easy. The one with the giant invasion force and a history of illegally seizing land is the one responsible for his escalation. The one who seeks to forbid Ukraine and Europe from forming ties is responsible for the escalation. The one who behaves as he Ukraine is his rightful vassal state is the one responsible for the escalation.
I know it's Russia sending troops into Donbas right now and they are wrong for it, but 2 out of those 3 apply to the west and the only reason the third doesn't apply is that you have to switch a name around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seanchaidh

Godzillarich(aka tf2godz)

Get the point
Legacy
Aug 1, 2011
2,946
523
118
Cretaceous
Country
USA
Gender
Dinosaur
I know it's Russia sending troops into Donbas right now and they are wrong for it, but 2 out of those 3 apply to the west and the only reason the third doesn't apply is that you have to switch a name around.
That's what superpowers do, bully their neighbors into submission. There's a reason why USA screwed over South America or China is trying to take sea area or forcing most of the world to not recognize Taiwan as a country.

But stuff like this should always be challenged, countries have the right to decide their own destiny and we must call out stuff like this whether it's the USA or russia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawki

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,377
6,496
118
Country
United Kingdom
Its actually quite easy. The one with the giant invasion force and a history of illegally seizing land is the one responsible for his escalation.
Hrm, that description actually applies to quite a few parties in this debacle.
 

The Rogue Wolf

Stealthy Carnivore
Legacy
Nov 25, 2007
17,003
9,698
118
Stalking the Digital Tundra
Gender
✅
They are not coming in Ukraine with promises, compromises, and solutions. This is going to happen with shelling, bullets, and the loss of life.

I probably agree with you a hundred different ways why this experiment of America is loss because of the unrestrained way corporate infrastructure is the only American Dream being lived. But this is not a feel good moment. People. Are. Going. To. Die.
But surely they would rather be liberated by Russian bullets than continue to suffer under the heel of American imperialism?!
 

Trunkage

Nascent Orca
Legacy
Jun 21, 2012
9,129
3,077
118
Brisbane
Gender
Cyborg
Why shouldn't they? All they need do is deploy precisely the same arguments as people 'defending Ukrainian sovereignty and democracy from Russia' but substituting Donetsk and Luhansk for Ukraine and Ukraine for Russia; those regions voted for Yanukovich, indeed they are where Yanukovich fled from the Euromaidan protests before he was impeached. And the new Ukrainian regime's idea was to reconquer them. The same logic applies in a rather tranquil symmetry. Just like the same logic applies to NATO expansionism and encirclement of Russia as it does to Russian encirclement of Ukraine (though the details differ a bit more in that case).

Hopefully the wishes of the people of Donetsk and Luhansk will be respected by all parties who end up having a say over their fate, though I don't particularly expect it in any case; given these developments it is good, at least, that civilians have been evacuated from the DPR/LPR-held areas of the Donbas, as interested parties seem determined to have a conflict there. The DPR/LPR are emboldened by Russian recognition, and the Ukraine by NATO supply and rhetoric. It is in fact difficult to tell who is more responsible for the escalation (though I'm certain people who are invested in believing the half of the story they heard first will blame solely one side or the other).
Look, I give this about a 5% chance of happening long term. I really hope they get the freedom they want.

I also think that everyone is going to try to take a piece of the pie
 

Seanchaidh

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 21, 2009
5,870
3,565
118
Country
United States of America
Alarming if true (repeating for the dullards: I don't know if this is true)
 

meiam

Elite Member
Dec 9, 2010
3,640
1,852
118
Well fuck...


Putin said Ukraine was a country with no tradition of independent statehood and an artificial creation of Soviet state founder Vladimir Lenin - a restatement of views he has expounded previously and which Kyiv has rejected as a false and self-serving view of history.
So it does appear that the pull out was fake, or maybe Putin is indecisive...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gergar12

Lykosia

Senior Member
May 26, 2020
65
33
23
Country
Finland
Well fuck...




So it does appear that the pull out was fake, or maybe Putin is indecisive...
It was more of a trick. Putin can say now that "See, I was trying to prevent war, but Ukraine/West kept attacking these sovereign states (Donets, Luhansk)." And now he can claim that they're actually peacekeepers and defending these "states."
 
  • Like
Reactions: thestor

Kwak

Elite Member
Sep 11, 2014
2,357
1,892
118
Country
4
Seriously, fuck Putin, and fuck Russia. The world doesn't need this shit. Why now?
And the constant gaslighting - 'what troops, we're not doing aaaaanything, you saying that we're up to something makes it more likely we will do something so it's YOUR fault."
Fucking goddamn evil sumfabitches.
 

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,538
5,796
118
Australia
Why shouldn't they? All they need do is deploy precisely the same arguments as people 'defending Ukrainian sovereignty and democracy from Russia' but substituting Donetsk and Luhansk for Ukraine and Ukraine for Russia; those regions voted for Yanukovich, indeed they are where Yanukovich fled from the Euromaidan protests before he was impeached. And the new Ukrainian regime's idea was to reconquer them. The same logic applies in a rather tranquil symmetry. Just like the same logic applies to NATO expansionism and encirclement of Russia as it does to Russian encirclement of Ukraine (though the details differ a bit more in that case).

Hopefully the wishes of the people of Donetsk and Luhansk will be respected by all parties who end up having a say over their fate, though I don't particularly expect it in any case; given these developments it is good, at least, that civilians have been evacuated from the DPR/LPR-held areas of the Donbas, as interested parties seem determined to have a conflict there. The DPR/LPR are emboldened by Russian recognition, and the Ukraine by NATO supply and rhetoric. It is in fact difficult to tell who is more responsible for the escalation (though I'm certain people who are invested in believing the half of the story they heard first will blame solely one side or the other).
Is this an example of quod erat demonstrandum when married to the context of @CM156
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,377
6,496
118
Country
United Kingdom
Well, we now have Russian troops marching into Ukraine.

Specifically into the Donetsk and Luhansk "people's republics", which Putin recognised as part of Ukraine's sovereign territory in 2015, and then instead recognised as independent states he must help defend against Ukraine literally hours before his troops entered.

It's pretty obvious that the status of Donetsk and Luhansk doesn't actually matter a single iota to Putin, considering his government's official stance was that they were Ukrainian until... uhrm a few hours before he needed them not to be. Calls into question whether he signed the Minsk Accords in the first place as a ruse.

NB. That polling in Donbas consistently show majority opposition to Russian intervention and/or integration into Russia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thestor

Agema

Do everything and feel nothing
Legacy
Mar 3, 2009
9,312
6,591
118
Why shouldn't they? All they need do is deploy precisely the same arguments as people 'defending Ukrainian sovereignty and democracy from Russia' but substituting Donetsk and Luhansk for Ukraine and Ukraine for Russia; those regions voted for Yanukovich, indeed they are where Yanukovich fled from the Euromaidan protests before he was impeached. And the new Ukrainian regime's idea was to reconquer them.
Let's please remember that the military revolt in Donbas was built on the back of Russia arming separatists and slipping thousands of "volunteers" over the border. Thus when you say Ukraine wanted to reconquer them, this is because Russia had already de facto invaded them.

The Donetsk and Luhansk separatists are not representatives of the people: they are military juntas backed by a foreign power, who have never won or run a free and fair election. These areas were around 60% Ukrainian in ethnicity, so I'm very doubtful they really wanted to be part of Russia. So please don't give us this appalling crap about what Donetsk and Luhansk people want regarding independence or unification with Russia, because they've never been allowed to voice an opinion - and nor will they in the near future given Russia's attitude to democracy. There's a large gap between protesting the toppling of their preferred president and being forcibly stripped from their country by a neighbour.

Although of course, I suspect with enough movement of people - Ukrainians fleeing and Russians moving in - Russia can readily manufacture a Russian majority population anyway. In essence, little different from what Israel is doing in the West Bank.
 

Trunkage

Nascent Orca
Legacy
Jun 21, 2012
9,129
3,077
118
Brisbane
Gender
Cyborg
Seriously, fuck Putin, and fuck Russia. The world doesn't need this shit. Why now?
And the constant gaslighting - 'what troops, we're not doing aaaaanything, you saying that we're up to something makes it more likely we will do something so it's YOUR fault."
Fucking goddamn evil sumfabitches.
Why now? IMO Biden is much better at making alliances than Trump, thus being a greater threat.