It can work fine, but it will always be hated for at least the first outing of that new character.
Like I said before, depends and YMMV. Most didn't.
When does it work? Cause at most an old character will get a moment of badass then fade into the background.
Minus the whole killing off character thing, it worked for
Devil May Cry 4 & 5, but as we all know with Nero, everyone didn't start accepting him until after the "reboot" was announced. Then all of the sudden, the haters began loving him, because they don't wanna deal with DINO's bullshit. I never hated Nero to begin with, so I always appreciated him.
I am not going to come up with every single example as nearly everything is different. It didn't work for
Soul Calibur V, and the reception towards (big spoiler here for a Nintendo Switch Exclusive here)
when Bayo died in Bayonetta 3 many fans didn't enjoy. Viola is still love it or hate it. Not so much for her personality, as it's too soon for many fans to be the new protag this early, and nearly every returning character bit dust. While I do like Bayo3 and Viola, Platinum was just copying Capcom's DMC5, but all the worse for it.
Though as I've seen most media, it doesn't work out. It depends how attached the audience is, how loveable the characters are, and often they show up in said game, TV show, or movie.
Jojo and
Castlevania can get away with this, because nearly each installment or game is different with a different or new protag, and takes place in a new timeline/era. As we are seeing with the upcoming
Castlevania Nocturne TV series, it's going to work out fine.
I have very little trust for GGmanLives since he thought the trapped vases in Powerslave were good design.
Ha! Even Civvie11 said those were bad designs. This isn't the first time GGMan has said a controversial or inherently wrong opinion. I lost lot of trust with him when it came to
Evil West. He was so wrong or missed the point on so mant design elements, it was not funny. I can never watch his review on that game ever again.
He would also just be wrong, BL3 plays so much better then 2 and 2 plays so much better then 1.
I can agree with
2 > 1. Like said before, as for
3 or
2 being better than each other, it boils down YMMV and other fans. I never touching games, so I have no stake in this opinion.