Are Man-crushes normal?

Recommended Videos

Riku'sTwilight

New member
Dec 21, 2009
301
0
0
Man crushes are fine. I've got man crushes on Tom Welling, Ian Somerhalder and a few other male actors I consider 'good'. Girls have girl crushes all the time so it's fine
 

KeyMaster45

Gone Gonzo
Jun 16, 2008
2,846
0
0
thiosk said:
I didn't think man-crush was sexual, by definition.
Same here, my definition for man-crush was that it goes beyond just looking up to another guy as a role-model or hero, but to the point where you just want to hang around them in the hopes some of their awesome rubs off on you.
 

Wadders

New member
Aug 16, 2008
3,796
0
0
I think so...

I kinda have a man-crush on Adam Johnson, a footballer who plays for Manchester City. Mainly because he's a good player really, hes not what I'd call good looking, I just admire him. And feel sad whenever he doesn't play.

But he also looks similar to Ian Curtis, so maybe that has something to do with it as well...

A couple of my mates have admitted "man crushes" as well, I think its less of a crush and more of an admiration to be honest.
 

Robert Ewing

New member
Mar 2, 2011
1,977
0
0
disregard all this religious bullshit and this strange modern age homophobia. There's around a 75% chance a male will fancy another male. same with a female.

people have been gay, or had feelings for someone of the same sex since the freaking human race began, it's not non-normal at all, it's something that can't be helped. So it should be encouraged a little more.

Trust me, homosexuals are totally chill, and natural. Just try to forget all this religious bull and cultural stuff that seems to resent this. Homosexuality is natural, and normal. Even if you think you're straight, you are still susceptible.
 

funguy2121

New member
Oct 20, 2009
3,407
0
0
theninjagecko said:
Now, to clarify, this is not synonymous with 'Are gays/homophobes all evil?' This is about a straight man (or even woman) having one or more romantic crush/es on members of the same sex.

I mentioned once to my girlfriend that I had little crushes on a friend I have, (the young) John Lennon, and John Barrowman's coat. I also once... Experimented with a bloke I know. I am neither ashamed nor proud of that moment, and we are still friends, so as far as I can say, it was just 'an experience.' One that changed my 'interested in' on Facebook for precisely three months.
Anyway, my girlfriend brought this up (with a small amount of disgust, and sparing no details) in a conversation with my parents. Not to ramble about my own life, but I wish she'd take a hint sometimes.

Anyway, I publicly announced all that just to ask a very broad question; was I really all that weird? Or was my girlfriend blowing it all out of proportion?
Thank you for providing this opportunity. This particular phenomenon has been getting on my nerves for quite some time. It's clear that you have had, as you say, romantic or sexual feelings for people of the same gender - and male bisexuality is the one sexual orientation whose numbers will always be understated. You can call it what you like; it's not my intention to "label" you. It's just a definition that provides clarity. You sometimes like dudes. Is that normal? First answer: who fucking cares? Embrace who you are and enjoy being you. Second answer: it's more "normal" than touching kids or molesting cats, it's more normal than most of the BDSM things that quite a few "straight" (hur hur) people do, all of the incest role play and mock rape scenarios out there. Beyond that, as much as I hate to be a sideline deconstructionist, just what in the Hell is normal? Five minutes fucking a woman and leaving her unsatisfied before falling asleep dreaming of a sandwich and a better life? Vanilla sex?

That's not the part that really annoys me. Since we can accept anyone as long as we can pigeonhole them, we have to mock everything by calling it gay (because, you know, that's an insult and all). I have a joke that I like to tell:

"Everything's homoerotic now, huh? Sam and Frodo marching up the path to Mount Doom, that's homoerotic. Look, here's two professional wrestlers piledriving each other in their underwear - that's homoerotic. Look, two gay guys sucking each other off, that's homoerotic! I'm sick of it!"

When you hear someone say man-crush in the course of normal, colloquial conversation, they aren't talking about a romantic or sexual crush but a fascination with or admiration for another man. The reason why they make damned sure it has those homoerotic overtones is because they want to say it without saying it. Man, woman, transgendered persons, there is a dark force that exists somewhere in the collective consciousness that wants us all to be passive agressive, cynical, hateful sissies who can't stand up and insult someone like an adult. So we have to call someone queer without calling them queer (again, because that is of course a huge insult). I admire Danny Carey because he plays the drums probably better than I ever will. I admire Christopher Nolan because his films transcend my expectations. Penis has nothing to do with the equation. All of these idiots who think I have a man crush on Jason Segal need to just say it: "I think you're a little gay, and as worthless sissy and deplorable homophobe I don't know how to express that in a sincere way."

...and that's why washed-up beauty queens are running for President.
 

hooksashands

New member
Apr 11, 2010
550
0
0
I would have gone into detail with her, if only to unsettle your parents AND make her look like a fool for trying to force shame on you.

My man-crush is Cillian Murphy, for obvious reasons.
 

Luke3184

New member
Jun 4, 2011
273
0
0
Dr Snakeman said:
Oh, please. Of course they're normal. I firmly believe that everyone at least has a crush on Neil Patrick Harris.
He is a sexy, sexy man

Him and Justin Timberlake....

Considering I'm a bit of a rock man myself it's a little odd, but I'm comfortable enough to be able to see a guy as sexy, which has been viewed with some degree of oddness by female friends.

But yeah, completely normal :)
 

Gralian

Me, I'm Counting
Sep 24, 2008
1,789
0
0
I think the answer is an unequivocal yes. Just look at Bridget. LOOK AT HIM.


However. I don't think i personally can say i've had a "man-crush". Actually, i don't really understand how man can be seen as sexual full stop - i'm male but i'm actually a little bit misandryist. I don't like men, i don't find anything about the male physique or even general male culture to be remotely attractive or enticing.

Though like others have said, it depends on what you mean by "man crush". Do you mean in finding someone of the same sex to be sexually attractive? (See TvTropes: BiTheWay) Or do you mean being able to find someone of the same sex romantically appealing even if you are not sexually compatible?

I tend to have the theory that anyone can fall in love with anyone else, regardless of genders / orientations. Or at least have very strong feelings for. Love is a difficult notion to define since it can be used in so many different contexts. I'm guessing though by your original post that you mean the former. I guess appreciation of the same sex for one or two specific individuals may be classified as "normal" (some psychologists and whatnot believe we're all bisexual to some degree) but you sound outright bi to me since you've gone and experimented. Most hetero guys would likely find the idea repulsive, no matter how burly they thought Russel Crowe or whoever looked. However if the "man-crush" in question was very feminine looking / behaviour, they might not be so disgusted. But then i would question whether it would really be considered a "man crush" if the guy is basically a girl with no tits and a tackle.

I would say your girlfriend is somewhat homophobic OP. Actually it's something i've seen before to a worrying degree. Women seem to think homosexuals are "inferior", or they feel insecure if they think their boyfriend / husband / lover has homosexual tendencies because they feel it is some failure on their part. I think that might be why your girlfriend lashed out in such a passive-aggressive manner. Though to be fair i think men probably have that problem as well if their girlfriend leaves them for another woman or they announce they're bi; the boyfriend might get insecure in his ability to please her and might think he will "turn her gay", just as a woman may think she is so sexually inadequate that the man can only seek pleasure from another man.

DISCLAIMER: Please don't gather the angry mob, these are just my thoughts and theories! I am in NO WAY an expert on sexuality and sociology, nor do i claim to speak for everyone or be able to read their minds!
 

HotFezz8

New member
Nov 1, 2009
1,139
0
0
theninjagecko said:
Now, to clarify, this is not synonymous with 'Are gays/homophobes all evil?' This is about a straight man (or even woman) having one or more romantic crush/es on members of the same sex.

I mentioned once to my girlfriend that I had little crushes on a friend I have, (the young) John Lennon, and John Barrowman's coat. I also once... Experimented with a bloke I know. I am neither ashamed nor proud of that moment, and we are still friends, so as far as I can say, it was just 'an experience.' One that changed my 'interested in' on Facebook for precisely three months.
Anyway, my girlfriend brought this up (with a small amount of disgust, and sparing no details) in a conversation with my parents. Not to ramble about my own life, but I wish she'd take a hint sometimes.

Anyway, I publicly announced all that just to ask a very broad question; was I really all that weird? Or was my girlfriend blowing it all out of proportion?
err, you ask a intriguing question. i think its ok, although i've never experienced that. how do you mean "experiment"? i've drunkenly kissed my mate (a bloke) but thats it. i think more than a kiss is probably gay.

that said if you don't feel any need to do it again, or any inclination to stop doing things with girls, i wouldn't say its gay.
 

funguy2121

New member
Oct 20, 2009
3,407
0
0
Catchy Slogan said:
It's completely normal. And honestly? Your girlfriend sounds like a bit of a *****. You admit something to her, and she completely disrespects your privacy and trust, to your parents no less. The disgust part is what annoyed me the most.

But meh. That wasn't what you asked for. And maybe I'm just being overly sensitive.

It was a crime to do that without the do do dedededo do do dedede.
 

Boba Frag

New member
Dec 11, 2009
1,288
0
0
Catchy Slogan said:
It's completely normal. And honestly? Your girlfriend sounds like a bit of a *****. You admit something to her, and she completely disrespects your privacy and trust, to your parents no less. The disgust part is what annoyed me the most.

But meh. That wasn't what you asked for. And maybe I'm just being overly sensitive.

You know, I was basically going to say everything this fine gent just did.

The lack of respect and the horrifically narrow minded trait that displays isn't something you should accept in a partner. And in front of your parents?!?

I'd tear that ***** a new asshole. Good. Grief.

But hey, you know your own business best, man. In any case, I suggest you enjoy Adam Jensen's crazy dancing.
 

funguy2121

New member
Oct 20, 2009
3,407
0
0
hooksashands said:
I would have gone into detail with her, if only to unsettle your parents AND make her look like a fool for trying to force shame on you.

My man-crush is Cillian Murphy, for obvious reasons.
Everyone thinks that the person they're attracted to is attractive to everyone else.

"I think Karen O is a sex goddess, for obvious reasons."

No, not really, though I do worship at the alter of Karen O.

I mean, I guess I get it. Cillian Murphy is a Helluvah character actor, and he did play Scarecrow, so that's kind of cool. At the height of his career and popularity women really dug Nicolas Cage, and he's certifiably ugly.

Then again, I shouldn't claim to have taste in male beauty. I still think all of the guys from Twilight look like douchebags, so what do I know?
 

drisky

New member
Mar 16, 2009
1,605
0
0
"I happen to think a man looks nice with good hair in a ponytail, but no, I'm not gay" -Robert Freeman

Thinking someone looks good or having experimented to in the past and ended up not liking it does not necessarily make you bisexual. It is incidental so you can keep calling your self straight. In the end you just do what feels natural and not worry about what is right.
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,506
5,319
118
Not only are they normal... they're essential!!!

I got man-crush on Ted Price - head honcho at Insomniac.
 

Zaverexus

New member
Jul 5, 2010
934
0
0
Catchy Slogan said:
It's completely normal. And honestly? Your girlfriend sounds like a bit of a *****. You admit something to her, and she completely disrespects your privacy and trust, to your parents no less. The disgust part is what annoyed me the most.

But meh. That wasn't what you asked for. And maybe I'm just being overly sensitive.

JoJoDeathunter said:
Yep, I'm pretty much as straight as you get and even I've found several men attractive before... though I wouldn't actually make out with one as that would be kinda gross for me.
Thedek said:
It's probably more like hero worship and not really sexual in nature at all, people anymore seem to have forgotten that admiration doesn't have to mean "I want to fuck this person."
I've collected three very sensible answers from my reading of this thread...
There ya go.

Everybody has some thoughts sometimes, but few people would act on them.
I honestly think its a bit odd to discuss it, especially with your girlfriend, but that may just be my personal experience.
 

Kae

That which exists in the absence of space.
Legacy
Nov 27, 2009
5,792
712
118
Country
The Dreamlands
Gender
Lose 1d20 sanity points.
I think it's normal, I've had a man crush with myself for a long time now, but it's been ruined by this stupid scar I have from yesterday, I accidentally burned my eye and it left a scar that makes it look like I have makeup on my eye, how horrible my beautiful face is ruined D:
 

Syzygy23

New member
Sep 20, 2010
824
0
0
Kekkles said:
None of my man crushes are fictional "Sephiroth. Yep."

I guess it's just context, I live in one of the gay capitals of the world so I'm bound to know about homosexuality, which is why I don't understand other people's spite and hate for homosexuals. If she's being "homophobic" (wrong word but everyone uses it like this) then she's in the wrong, if it was done during the relationship and could be considered cheating then she's right. If the girl did this to me I'd have chucked her out of my house and told her to go fuck herself.
Butt sex. It's as simple as that.
Robert Ewing said:
disregard all this religious bullshit and this strange modern age homophobia. There's around a 75% chance a male will fancy another male. same with a female.

people have been gay, or had feelings for someone of the same sex since the freaking human race began, it's not non-normal at all, it's something that can't be helped. So it should be encouraged a little more.

Trust me, homosexuals are totally chill, and natural. Just try to forget all this religious bull and cultural stuff that seems to resent this. Homosexuality is natural, and normal. Even if you think you're straight, you are still susceptible.
There's also a 75% chance that your neighbor fancies horses, but you don't condone that do you?