Battlefield 4's a "New Form of Cultural Aggression", Says Chinese State Media

Adam Jensen_v1legacy

I never asked for this
Sep 8, 2011
6,651
0
0
Mindless said:
Adam Jensen said:
I can't really blame them. Especially since the entire world knows that America is actually the bad guy that keeps invading other countries for oil and other riches under the guise of "protecting the democracy". It's ridiculous. That military and gun culture has got to stop. It's not healthy.
If the U.S did invade countries for oil why is oil so expensive and why haven`t they invaded Venezuela,Canada or Mexico?
Seriously? You obviously don't know jack shit about international politics if you can expect someone to give you an explanation in a forum post. The bottom line is, war is profitable for a lot of people.
 

Korolev

No Time Like the Present
Jul 4, 2008
1,853
0
0
The Chinese government cannot and does not consider this to be "just" a video game. They control all media very tightly in China, and they assume that the US does the same. Therefore, they assume that the US government specifically gave approval to this project and that it is part of a ploy to "turn the world against China".

When you're paranoid, you inevitably see everything has being a plot against you. Not that China doesn't have reason to be paranoid, but come on, Battlefield 4 isn't a US-government produced propaganda piece. It's an EA produced propaganda piece.

Besides, in China you have games where you go on rampages against the Japanese, killing them by the dozens. This is somewhat understandable, if not excusable, by looking at their history, but it's a bit rich for China to call the West "jingoistic" when a good portion of its state-run newspapers called for out-and-out war against Japan just last year (of course the Chinese government were not considering attacking Japan, but they told their newspapers to drive up the Anti-Japan sentiment).
 

Korolev

No Time Like the Present
Jul 4, 2008
1,853
0
0
Adam Jensen said:
I can't really blame them. Especially since the entire world knows that America is actually the bad guy that keeps invading other countries for oil and other riches under the guise of "protecting the democracy". It's ridiculous. That military and gun culture has got to stop. It's not healthy.
China invaded Tibet....

But you are right in that China rarely invades countries in modern times. In the past it was a different story - they invaded Vietnam countless times (the Vietnamese always managed to fight them off eventually) as well as Korea. China isn't a nice place and while I don't think they are into invasion, that may be due to the fact that their navy is incapable of invading at the moment (that will change in the next 20 or so years).

America is not a nice country, but I think you are being a bit naive if you think they are the only bad guy. All nations are selfish. Russia used to invade heaps of countries when it had the military power and the will to do so. France, Germany, the UK and even little old Belgium used to have colonies less than 100 years ago. Invasion and conquest are not an exclusively American thing by any means and I am not too optimistic that China, once it fully achieves superpower status (and it will) and gains a Blue-Sea Capable Fleet, will not invade as well under the guise of "national" security. They're already behaving aggressively towards some of their neighbors like Vietnam and the Philippines, claiming vast, vast, VAST swarths of ocean right up to the Philippines as its exclusive territority merely because a few islands it claims to own are near the Philippines. That would be like the US claiming all the pacific ocean up to Hawaii as being "it's waters".

Be wary of China. They have jingoists and xenophobes too. During the tensions with Japan last year, you had a Chinese university openly exhort its students to come up with a weapon more powerful than a nuclear bomb to "finish off" Japan for good.

Sure, the US has jingoists. Don't for one minute think China does not. Be wary of the US. But be wary of China. Be wary of any large, powerful country.
 

Tusalu

New member
Sep 6, 2010
8
0
0
They're right. Our triple A games should get more creative in choosing the enemy. How about Canada? Or Norway? Or New Zealand?
 

Adam Jensen_v1legacy

I never asked for this
Sep 8, 2011
6,651
0
0
Mindless said:
Okay I dont know jack okay. I know that transporting an army across the globe in hopes to claim oil is really stupid
when you southern and northern neighbor have a lot more oil and if you are going to invade a country why not invade the country that produces more oil such as Iran which produced almost 2 times as much oil as Iraq did in 2002.
OK. Not knowing anything about international politics is one thing. But you should at least be familiar with current events. The warmongers are trying as hard as they can to light the fuse that would lead to the war in Iran. It's actually happening as we speak. But you can't just wake up one day and decide to invade. It's a long con.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/12/19/iran-sanctions-bill_n_4472439.html
Right wing warmongers (when I say right wing, I don't necessarily mean Republicans. There are right wing politicians disguised as Democrats as well) want that war to happen. They don't want negotiations. And not just for oil either. A lot of people would benefit from it. Private contractors, weapon manufacturers, corporate shills and all kinds of other psychos.
 

The White Hunter

Basment Abomination
Oct 19, 2011
3,888
0
0
martyrdrebel27 said:
All hail The Glorious People's Republic Of China! Rise up against your Western Oppressors! Tell General Tso to rally his men!

OT: Let's just have Nazis be the bad guy from now on, an enemy everyone can agree on. Space Nazis, Shark Nazis, Tall Nazis, Robot Nazis, Nazi Nazis, Core-of-the-earth Nazis, exploding Nazis, Jetski Nazis, Nazis that are the rich well trained team in a 90's kid's sports movie that still somehow lose to the barely functioning American team, chocolate Nazis... I could do this forever. But instead, I say this to you China, make a decent game we wanna play, and you can be as good guy ad you want. You could even save Earth from Moon-Hitler.
That 1960's Wolfenstein with giant nazi robots sure does look agreeable after all.[footnote]I'm actually looking forward to it quite a lot[/footnote]

I agree though, we need more nazis of various sorts in gaems these days. Who doesn't like shooting nazis? I mean they're nazis.
 

Hero in a half shell

It's not easy being green
Dec 30, 2009
4,286
0
0
martyrdrebel27 said:
omega 616 said:
martyrdrebel27 said:
Nazi Nazis
How does that work? Is it like Nazi's that are Nazi's to Nazi's or is it more of a super ubermensch Nazi?
Nazi Nazis are two separate types, one is what we would call Orthodox Nazi, that are ubernazis, but they are constantly battling the Nazi Nazis who Nazi(v.) the Nazis. Ubernazis think they are the most Nazi Nazis, so they don't like to be pushed around, but its in the Nature of Nazi Nazis to Nazi the Nazis. Its a complex political landscape in Nazylvania.
Nazi Nazis from Nazylvania?

Good lord, They're the worst kind!
 

Diddy_Mao

New member
Jan 14, 2009
1,189
0
0
JazzJack2 said:
Li Mu said:
You can raise 'student suicides' and I could mention 'US school shootings'.
I could also bring up the mass execution and imprisonment of political opponents/dissidents, the occupation of Tibet, treatment of workers etc
Guantanamo Bay, "enhanced interrogation", pretty much the entire Iraq war...Walmart.

You really don't have to look very far to see a whole bunch of human rights violations in our own record books.
 

Alex Monroe

New member
Apr 18, 2013
1
0
0
As long as the Chinese Government thinks its a very good idea to shoot people that are of a different opinion they can - and excuse me - go and fuck themselfs, and furthermore have no right to complain for being "demonized" which is not even true. China is doing pretty much what can be considered a very solid turn towards what Video-Games in the recent years were making up, and i would worry more about my country doing a marathon-run to the ethics of WW2-Era-Germany than what Electronic Arts makes out of it. No offense to the chinese people themselfs in the slightest, trust me, but i think those people who feel insulted by this should worry about more serious things than "Duh vidyagarmz" there. And if they think they don't need to, there is a whole different set of problems to be taken care of anyway.

edit: Of course there are other countries this greatly applies to... And i admit im kind of curious also what american people would say to a game focusing about Country-X as "The good guys" fighting against America as a conquering, self-righteous world-police, which is the image that came up quite a bit over the last 20 years (i dont say it is like this but... let's be serious; It's not as far off either to depict them as that with a less diplomatic agenda, going for current allies in a game with military force).
 

tmande2nd

New member
Oct 20, 2010
602
0
0
Shooters should just stick to Nazis, Robots, Zombies, and Aliens.

Or have a Nazi who went into space and spliced alien DNA into himself, then made himself a cyborg who died and rose as a zombie!

That way we can shoot him with zero remorse.
 

Daaaah Whoosh

New member
Jun 23, 2010
1,041
0
0
If it helps, I'm really looking frward to playing as the Chinese when I finally get Battlefield 4. I'll have no problem shooting Americans; after all, it's just a game, and I'm playing as a soldier who just wants to get home to his family. But if China wants to get angry about it, I guess that's their right.
 

Grach

New member
Aug 31, 2012
339
0
0
You know what we need? A modern military COMEDY shooter. Just have it be like Team America: The Game. Have the main bad guy be a the son of Nazi and a member of Squad 731, who was trained in North Korea (where (s)he lost an eye) and rose through the ranks of the KGB until (s)he betrayed them to turn to the CIA (which resulted in the loss of his/her other eye, now uses a black visor), only to work assasinating civil rights activists. (S)He's also a distant cousin of Jeff Dunham or something. Also has a skin made of asbestos.
 

Aeonknight

New member
Apr 8, 2011
751
0
0
Li Mu said:
US as the hero always? Go back and play MW2, the main villain was General Carter, the US general.

In the context of Battlefield, the whole point of choosing a country like Russia or China is because of their military strength. US has F-18's, Russia has Flankers to be their equivalent. The context of the multiplayer wouldn't make sense if it was oh say.... US vs Al Qaeda, for the obvious technological gap between the two.

As for China being butt hurt about being "the bad guy", that's only in the campaign. Which no one gave a shit about. And even then, it was some rogue general just like MW2. In the Multiplayer there is no "good or bad guy".
 

Cecilo

New member
Nov 18, 2011
330
0
0
Meh, to all those that say we need an "America is the bad guys" Game. We really don't. The internet does that every single day.

Based on what the internet thinks of America, we are quite literally hell on earth, the worst country to ever exist, possibly the belated reincarnation of Hitler.
 

SnakeoilSage

New member
Sep 20, 2011
1,211
0
0
Fuck it, have the next Battlefield be a second American Civil War.

I've been waiting for aliens since Battlefield 2.
 

Not G. Ivingname

New member
Nov 18, 2009
6,368
0
0
Oskuro said:
Rainboq said:
This is inevitable when you're making games framed in a modern conflict.
It is not inevitable. You can make a game where you face a real-world country and still not come across as jingoistic.

The problem with these sorts of media (not just games) is not that they pit one nation against other nation, but rather that they demonize one of the contenders.


Want a US vs China game? Sure thing, have a US campaign where China are the bad guys, and a China campaign where the US are the bad guys.

But no, apparently our culture is so in need of validation that "our" side needs to be portrayed as the unjustly attacked underdog that fights the Global Threat of Doom.

And note that I'm not criticising the US specifically. Everyone is somewhat guilty of this, even when the enemies are aliens, the undead, Orcs, or killer turkeys, it is always about agrandazing ourselves via demonization of the "others".
China didn't ban Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising even though it had the Chinese as the enemy. It actually isn't banned in China, because the developers did their research and depicted the PLA accurately.