Biggest plot holes

[Gizmo1990]

Snip

I will just concede the point. It has been a long time since I read any Harry Potter and stopped enjoying them after Chamber of Secrets I just kept reading them to find out what happened. So as I do not remember enough to debate this you win

 

[Calibanbutcher]

snip

Yeah I was going by the movies, in the books everything around Gandalf is sunshine and happy rainbows.
Still wouldn't have protected them from having Sauron look at them, which apparently is so unpleasant that even Aragon could not withstand it and also doesn't do a lot of good against the Nazguls just being formidable foes.
Also, having Gandalf on one of those eagles flying into mordor, a guy Sauron counts amongst his most powerful enemies, is a bit like bringing a neon sign reading "We are going to try and wreck your shit, so come at us".
And even if you are the greatest wizard in the world, having all of Mordor's orcs against you seems like a bit of a tough challenge to me.

 

[TheLastTatlFan]

One of many from Final Fantasy IV: The After Years...
In FFIV, Rydia aged up from let's say an eight year old to a twenty year old in what couldn't have been more than a few days by living in the Feymarch. At the end of the game, she decides to live there permanently.

The After Years takes place ninteen years later. She barely looks a year older. Unless Asura and Leviathan put some anti-aging charm on her new, draftier outfit, she should be either dead of old age or rocking the robed ancient sorceress look.

 

[Rawne1980]

Jurrasic Park.

The little blonde lass, computer genius. Able to sort out the security systems while being yelled at and having Raptors trying to get in and eat the,

Yet she can't turn off a fucking flash light.

 

[In Search of Username]

The entire plot of Heavy Rain.

 

[Loop Stricken]

I was always of the opinion that Princess Celestia has the biggest plot hol- oh right movies!

Probably the Twilight books/films. Everyhting in them is just so poorly plotted that it could be called one big plot singularity.

We can't confuse plot holes with piss-poor plots.

Also I'm very surprised you didn't use this:

 

[Casual Shinji]

LOTR:
They kinda needed to stay hidden.
From a giant eye in a very high tower.
A giant eye which also commanded a group of incredibly powerful Nazgul, who, incidentally, also had flying mounts who could incapacitate almost anyone within hearing range by simply screeching at them.
Now, the eagles were shown to be capable of downing said flying-screech-beasts, but not whilst also carrying someone.
Plus, let's not forget that the eyes power is so strong, that simply being looked at is dangerous.

So why in Galadriel's name would you choose to ride a flying beast over the enemies territory?
You would be spotted almost immediately upon crossing the border and assaulted by a group of immortal spirits whose only wish is to see you broken and destroyed.
It seems safer to me to simply walk into mordor.

Thank you!

I always get a bit annoyed when people bring up that supposed plothole. They don't ride the Eagles to Mordor for the same reason they don't bring a giant fucking army of soldiers to accompany Frodo.

OT: How is it that in Terminator 2 the T-1000 is able to travel back in time, when Kyle Reese specifically stated that only living tissue, or something surrounded by living tissue, can go through the portal? Seeing as the T-1000 is pure metal.

Jurrasic Park.

The little blonde lass, computer genius. Able to sort out the security systems while being yelled at and having Raptors trying to get in and eat the,

Yet she can't turn off a fucking flash light.

You think that's strange?

How is it that the T-Rex paddock suddenly sank like 300 feet after the Rex stood right infront of the fence at the exact same spot before it escaped?

 

[Rawne1980]

You think that's strange?

How is it that the T-Rex paddock suddenly sank like 300 feet after the Rex stood right infront of the fence at the exact same spot before it escaped?

Or how the T-Rex managed to sneak in at the end without anyone hearing, or feeling, it coming.

One minute they are all stood there ... in silence ... being surrounded by Raptors then...

BOO

Ninja T-Rex suddenly appears.

 

[Nekron_X]

well since most of the ones i can think of have already been mentioned,and i don't really watch a lot of movies, there's not much for me to say, except for maybe the one in the shining. Yes jack went crazy and all that, but it doesn't explain how he just froze to death in the maze, he didn't even go that far from the entrance, 2, maybe 3 turns in and away,while his son runs deep into the maze and yet easily finds his way back out, while somehow gets stuck out there for the night and freezes to death, like he didn't only go insane, but lost his intelligence as well apparently...still love the movie though.

The biggest plot hole ever is Bruce Banner's pants. Seriously, what the F are those pants made of??

The biggest plot hole in the Harry Potter series is the goddamn Time Turner. Where the hell did that thing go and why wasn't every character (good and evil) seeking to find it and use it? It seemed to be the single-most powerful artifact in the entire story.

Also regarding the Fusion Reactor in Dark Knight Rises, I totally agree that you can't turn a fusion reactor into a bomb in ~15 seconds. You just can't, it's not how reactors work. When a fusion reactor destabilizes it melts down and releases a whole bunch of radiation into the surrounding area. It does NOT explode and vaporize everything in a 6 mile radius, because it's not a goddamn nuclear bomb...it's a reactor. They are built completely differently.

While i can't say anything about Bruce' pants(maybe magic since it's the marvel universe...meh,let's go with that), and you've already explained how fusion reactors work. the time-turners weren't gone after for 2 reasons.
1)due to the use of one, when a person goes back in time, they have a chance to run into said past self. since the past one wouldn't yet know about the use of a time-turner, they're like to shoot first and ask questions later at seeing a double, since it would be assumed polyjuice potion over time travel.

2) I don't know if it's shown in the 5th movie since i stopped watching after the 4th one, but in the book at the fight in the ministry, one of the spells used by a death eater destroys the place where the time-turners are stored when not in use, while i'm sure there's some still around, that's where the majority of them were so they assumed they were gone.

 

[Agow95]

For me, it's when Elrond says, "I was there when the strength of men failed", as clearly the strength of elves also failed that day, because Elrond had a sword, and didn't do anything, if he had at least lost to Isildur in a short fight, I'd understand, but he kinda just stood there shouting while Isildur walked past him with the ring of power.

 

[Proverbial Jon]

If he only lernt after Chamber of Secrets then fair enough. I did not know that. However he did know about the prophesy. He knew what Voldermort was capable of and he knew that Harry would have to face him. You would think he would actually teach him some magic that would actually help him. Plus that raises more issues.

Dumbledore did not know about the Horcruxes, ok, but in the years he spent fighting him did he never try to kill Voldermort? If he did not then he was willing to let countless people die for his principals, making him a selfish person. If he did and found that Voldermort could not be killed, Dumbledore is a smart guy. There can only be a few ways to make yourself immortal. Surly he could have worked it out. Also how the hell did I forget about the DKR. That thing is riddled with plot holes.

Dumbledore knew about the prophesy, yes, he knew that neither Harry nor Voldemort could die while the other still lived. He knew that Harry had to kill Voldemort because Harry himself was a horcrux, meaning that Harry had to effectively sacrifice himself in order for Voldemort to die. But Harry's death would have been in vain had the other horcruxes still existed so he had to play the long game.

Besides, it was probably near impossible to find all the horcruxes while Voldemort and his supporters were all in hiding. Once Voldemort had lost a few horcruxes he became paranoid and put more protection around the others, making them, paradoxically, easier to locate. Voldemort himself contained a horcrux, the last twisted remains of his soul, something that would have been impossible to find before he had a physical form. Between the time of Voldemort's original downfall and Book 4 he was just a weak and floaty spirit thing with no true body.

At least that's how I see it.

 

[Casual Shinji]

You think that's strange?

How is it that the T-Rex paddock suddenly sank like 300 feet after the Rex stood right infront of the fence at the exact same spot before it escaped?

Or how the T-Rex managed to sneak in at the end without anyone hearing, or feeling, it coming.

One minute they are all stood there ... in silence ... being surrounded by Raptors then...

BOO

Ninja T-Rex suddenly appears.

Yeah, but then that was just really fucking awesome! Dramatic effect before logic... to a degree.

Also, how in hell did Samual Jackson's severed arm get propped behind the electrical cables in the maintenance shack? Did the Raptor just store it there for later like a squirrel?

Don't even get me started on that scene in The Lost World with the T-Rex killing all the people on the ship, even the ones in the control room where the T-Rex never should've been able to get without tearing the structure apart, and then getting itself locked in the ship's cargo hold by, yet again, a severed arm.

 

[Azurian]

Oh yeah I have one and it's been bugging the hell out of me when Loki touch Tony's chest with his staff in Avengers why didn't it work? Did his chest piece protect him somehow?

 

[CrazyCapnMorgan]

BOO

Ninja T-Rex suddenly appears.

That's kinda like a shiny Haxorus, amirite?

Anyways, I saw Mass Effect mentioned, but not the issue I was hoping to see addressed:

Spoiler: Go, X to the Z!

Captcha: Ghost Squirrel. Would probably have been better.

 

[TheLastTatlFan]

Oh yeah I have one and it's been bugging the hell out of me when Loki touch Tony's chest with his staff in Avengers why didn't it work? Did his chest piece protect him somehow?

That was what I got out of it, yeah. Mini arc reactors don't conduct mind-controlly waves.

 

[Terminate421]

Sonic '06. How was the city NOT on fire after it was clearly shown to be on fire in the opening sequence after Robotnik attacked?

Even more, how does a little girl NOT CRY her entire life until Sonic, a hedgehog she barely knows, is killed.

 

[FoolKiller]

There is a movie called Hanna.

The story is not the point. There is a part where the family she is travelling with is kidnapped to be interrogated. You never actually find out what happens to them. Not a plot hole exactly but the biggest loose string left dangling that I've ever seen.

As for plot holes, every supernatural story has them because it would take eons to come up with truly consistent universes with alternate rules that must be adhered to. Inconsistencies tend to occur because rules aren't necessarily created before the story begins.

As for the giant eagles... maybe they couldn't fly in to drop the ring off because Sauron would see it and have them shot down before they got close. Once the bad guys fell, the eagles could come in and give transportation out.... just a thought.

 

[CrazyCapnMorgan]

Oh yeah I have one and it's been bugging the hell out of me when Loki touch Tony's chest with his staff in Avengers why didn't it work? Did his chest piece protect him somehow?

That was what I got out of it, yeah. Mini arc reactors don't conduct mind-controlly waves.

Or, as I like to put it:

"You are mine to command!" - Loki

"BEEP BOOP BA-DEEP BOOP ************." - Tony's chestpiece

Which could be considered surprisingly canonical given Marvel's histories and characters.

 

[The Artificially Prolonged]

In Heavy Rain where where they never explain why Ethan keeps blacking out and waking up with an origami crane in his hand. It just a giant red herring to keep us from guessing the real killer's identity that they never bother to even give an explain.

Also why would any sane woman hop into bed with Ethan in the context of the plot? The guy turns up every night at a motel, clearly in some distress and showing more and more severe injuries which he never adequately explains, and yet Madison just jumps right on in there.

And why did no one suspect Shelby? Especially when he kills that shop keeper with someone just standing in the next room [footnote]which the game conveniently doesn't show actually happening until afterwards in a contrived way to hide the twist[/footnote]. I mean it wasn't like he did it quietly, he bashed the guy's head in with a wooden clock and the connecting door was wide open, how did the other person not hear anything or furthermore just believe Shelby that someone must have sneaked in and done in the brief moment between them speaking to the shopkeeper and him finding the body? It gets even worse if you get the scene where you didn't clean up your prints and get taken in for questioning by the police. They just let him go! The police just let go two people who where the last people to see a murdered man alive and where the only two who where around at the time, neither of which could really give each other an alibi as they briefly separated during the actual crime. Furthermore they didn't immediately report the crime to the police but instead tried to leave the scene erasing any evidence that they where there. What police would just let them go?

The entire plot of Heavy Rain.

Damn it! Ninja'd.

 

[Baron von Blitztank]

Sonic '06. How was the city NOT on fire after it was clearly shown to be on fire in the opening sequence after Robotnik attacked?

Even more, how does a little girl NOT CRY her entire life until Sonic, a hedgehog she barely knows, is killed.

Also, why did Mephiles have to kill Sonic to make her cry? Surely it would be simpler to just cut up some onions in front of her!