Brütal Legend Dev Counter-Sues Activision

Ima Lemming

New member
Jan 16, 2009
220
0
0
Fumbles said:
Touche. But saying you are a nonconformist makes you the ultimate conformist. So what, Tim should've gone multiplatform with it, but he chose to stay on the Xbox... He deserved it not making money. It was a good game but according to your logic Beyond Good and Evil was better.
Except he did go multiplatform with Psychonauts, unless you mean the PS2 and PC versions should have been released at the same time as the Xbox version.
 

romitelli

New member
Jan 2, 2008
108
0
0
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
 

timmytom1

New member
Feb 26, 2009
2,136
0
0
Oh hell yeah,sue activision for every penny they`ve got ,they deservew it for being such pricks
 

Sewblon

New member
Nov 5, 2008
3,107
0
0
EA has been backing Brutal Legend for long enough that you would think they would have jumped in to protect their cut by now.
 

Triforceformer

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,286
0
0
romitelli said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
Please tell me you're kidding, romitelli.
 

romitelli

New member
Jan 2, 2008
108
0
0
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
Please tell me you're kidding, romitelli.
Ok, maybe I'm being too hard on the guy, it's just that, when I heard a new Tim Schafer title was coming out, months ago, I expected... so much more.
 

jaoblia

New member
Jul 21, 2009
172
0
0
activision, brutal legend wont stop guitar heros sales it will be the craptastic songs

Edit:
AlexTheBucket2112 said:
Guitar hero will die soon (IMO). YOU'RE JUST DELAYING THE INEVITABLE!!! (RE5 albert wesker FTW)
i liked it when general Grievous said it lolzzz :p
 

scotth266

Wait when did I get a sub
Jan 10, 2009
5,202
0
0
How exactly does this game compete with the Guitar Hero franchise? That part of the lawsuit seems a bit off somehow.

Other than that, GO DOUBLE FINE!
 

Triforceformer

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,286
0
0
romitelli said:
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
Please tell me you're kidding, romitelli.
Ok, maybe I'm being too hard on the guy, it's just that, when I heard a new Tim Schafer title was coming out, months ago, I expected... so much more.
Better fighting, witty jokes, metal from all ages from Glam to Thrash, Ozzy, Creative level design, Ozzy, a sacred beer tree, Ozzy, a customizable Hot Rod, and Ozzy. Did I mention Ozzy? What more would you want? The game to be a diamond farting masterpiece from the gates Heaven after Zeus and God had Holy Sodomy???
 

Triforceformer

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,286
0
0
scotth266 said:
How exactly does this game compete with the Guitar Hero franchise? That part of the lawsuit seems a bit off somehow.

Other than that, GO DOUBLE FINE!
The game has a feature where you have to press certain buttons as they come up to play a solo to change something in the terrain or whatever that solo is meant to do...So Activision is whining about their Quick Time Events=Music concept they've based an entire series around, that many games on the internet have ripped off and don't see them complaining about that. Of course this is all in theory.
 

Lord Krunk

New member
Mar 3, 2008
4,809
0
0
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
Thats why everyone bought it?
We owe it to them, they're one of the most awesome (and under-appreciated) Devs of all time.

I don't know whether Double Fine's going to win this one. Justice demands that they succeed, but a crappy technicality is preventing that and I hope that their lawyers find a way... if it means selling their souls to the devil for one.

That is, if they have souls.

I hate you Activision.
 

romitelli

New member
Jan 2, 2008
108
0
0
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
Please tell me you're kidding, romitelli.
Ok, maybe I'm being too hard on the guy, it's just that, when I heard a new Tim Schafer title was coming out, months ago, I expected... so much more.
Better fighting, witty jokes, metal from all ages from Glam to Thrash, Ozzy, Creative level design, Ozzy, a sacred beer tree, Ozzy, a customizable Hot Rod, and Ozzy. Did I mention Ozzy? What more would you want? The game to be a diamond farting masterpiece from the gates Heaven after Zeus and God had Holy Sodomy???
I have to say that your take on the game is much better than the crap I've seen on the internet.

And Ozzy does rule.

(I'm gonna go listen to some Sabbath now)
 

Triforceformer

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,286
0
0
romitelli said:
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
Triforceformer said:
romitelli said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
HardRockSamurai said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCKIt is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
To be honest, I never gave a rats ass about Jack Black being in the game. The game is going to

[HEADING=2]ROCK[/HEADING]

Because it's

[HEADING=2]TIM SCHAFER[/HEADING]

The guy who made

[HEADING=2]PSYCHONAUTS[/HEADING]

Which is one of the

[HEADING=2]BEST GAMES EVER MADE[/HEADING]
That's why everyone bought it?
Dude, Jack Black is not making Brutal Legend. Anyone who goes out and buys a video game just because their favorite celebrity is stamped on the cover is an idiot. That, we can agree on.

However, don't go bashing a game just because you hate Jack Black. That's like bashing a Final Fantasy game because you hate Japan. Whether you like it or not, he's part of the game, but he's not going to be deciding factor of the game's quality.

Tim Schafer. Double Fine. Heavy Metal.

That's why people are going to buy Brutal Legend.
I'm a HUGE fan of Tim Schafer (hence the avatar); he is a genius, and simply can turn shit into gold.

Buuut,

from what I've seen from BL, the game is going to fail miserably. I mean, come on, a game about a roadie of a metal band who slays demons with an axe in one hand and a guitar in the other? Sounds nothing like the guy responsible for all of his adventure titles.

I guess everyone flops from time to time.
Please tell me you're kidding, romitelli.
Ok, maybe I'm being too hard on the guy, it's just that, when I heard a new Tim Schafer title was coming out, months ago, I expected... so much more.
Better fighting, witty jokes, metal from all ages from Glam to Thrash, Ozzy, Creative level design, Ozzy, a sacred beer tree, Ozzy, a customizable Hot Rod, and Ozzy. Did I mention Ozzy? What more would you want? The game to be a diamond farting masterpiece from the gates Heaven after Zeus and God had Holy Sodomy???
I have to say that your take on the game is much better than the crap I've seen on the internet.

And Ozzy does rule.

(I'm gonna go listen to some Sabbath now)
Well I'm one of those "Games are art" Hippies that Yahtzee will act like in his review of the game. Those who actually wants some true creativity in games, not just Halo but on mars with a hammer or some shit like that.
(Cue Red Faction Fanboys to the Tune of Seek and Destroy by Metallica.)
 

Gerazzi

New member
Feb 18, 2009
1,734
0
0
SomeBritishDude said:
Ranooth said:
It me or is Activision acting extremely evil lately?
It's most deffinitly not you.

EA are the heroes for once, giving a new and original franchise a chance.
I know, it's like the creative freedom brainslugs have attached to them for once.
We're better off.
Double Fine all the way and if anything happens to them I say we boycott Activision.
Forever.
 

Andy Chalk

One Flag, One Fleet, One Cat
Nov 12, 2002
45,698
1
0
You guys talk like you know metal, but you don't know metal.

This is metal.


F'n metal.
 

plastic_window

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,218
0
0
AlexTheBucket2112 said:
Guitar hero will die soon (IMO). YOU'RE JUST DELAYING THE INEVITABLE!!! (RE5 albert wesker FTW)
What's really strange is how EA are changing into a much better company. They still release all their Fifa, Madden and NFL games but they're trying to expand their list of new IPs like Brutal Legend and last year's efforts with Dead Space and Mirror's Edge. At least, I hope that's what they're trying to do...

As for the article, I want to voice my support for Double Fine. This is basically Activision breaking a toy they didn't want so no-one else can have it, but unfortunately, there will be intense legal work required to work around all these accusations. I hope Double Fine pull through and I hope Activision get seriously scalded for trying this petty little trick.
 

Credge

New member
Apr 12, 2008
1,042
0
0
Triforceformer said:
Well I'm one of those "Games are art" Hippies that Yahtzee will act like in his review of the game. Those who actually wants some true creativity in games, not just Halo but on mars with a hammer or some shit like that.
(Cue Red Faction Fanboys to the Tune of Seek and Destroy by Metallica.)
Yeah, that's a pretty ignorant statement.

Want some creativity? Red Faction, not the one from this generation, was one of, if not the first game to allow for non-scripted terrain deformation. Including buildings. So, to request something different from an IP that is built around that thing is a bit... silly. That would be like asking Rock Band to turn in to an action rpg that is controlled with your guitar, drum, or mic.

Not every game that is released has to be a unique and different experience. There's only so much you can do with video games that is actually fun. The point of IP's and genres is so you can stick to one you enjoy and play it. It's almost always been like this.

And no, I haven't played the new Red Faction. It's not on my 'to do list'.

Edit: Further, seeing as how very, very few games have terrain deformation, and even fewer (none other than Red Faction as far as I'm aware) have the entire game focus around that point... how can you even say that Red Faction is Halo on Mars? That would be like saying that Doom is Halo on Mars. Absurd.
 

BakaSmurf

Elite Member
Dec 25, 2008
1,323
0
41
Dear Sweet Jesus, Activision has become a typical tyrannical conformitist company and EA is valiantly backing up the little guy full of original and unique ideas the big evil conformatist company is trying to destroy....

Casualty has been shattered, Existance is a nightmare without beginning or end.
 

Triforceformer

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,286
0
0
Credge said:
Triforceformer said:
Well I'm one of those "Games are art" Hippies that Yahtzee will act like in his review of the game. Those who actually wants some true creativity in games, not just Halo but on mars with a hammer or some shit like that.
(Cue Red Faction Fanboys to the Tune of Seek and Destroy by Metallica.)
Yeah, that's a pretty ignorant statement.

Want some creativity? Red Faction, not the one from this generation, was one of, if not the first game to allow for non-scripted terrain deformation. Including buildings. So, to request something different from an IP that is built around that thing is a bit... silly. That would be like asking Rock Band to turn in to an action rpg that is controlled with your guitar, drum, or mic.

Not every game that is released has to be a unique and different experience. There's only so much you can do with video games that is actually fun. The point of IP's and genres is so you can stick to one you enjoy and play it. It's almost always been like this.

And no, I haven't played the new Red Faction. It's not on my 'to do list'.

Edit: Further, seeing as how very, very few games have terrain deformation, and even fewer (none other than Red Faction as far as I'm aware) have the entire game focus around that point... how can you even say that Red Faction is Halo on Mars? That would be like saying that Doom is Halo on Mars. Absurd.
Sorry I was only vaugely kidding just to get one of those *Insert metal song here* jokes through, and even if I wasn't, I saw a guy say Brutal Legend is a Halo ripoff, no kidding. All I know about the red faction series is the latest one has a 1 mission demo, it takes place on mars, and yahtzee doesn't like it.
 

theultimateend

New member
Nov 1, 2007
3,621
0
0
Random argument man said:
Fumbles said:
I dont see why everyone is all butt hurt about this. The game is going to SUCK. It is JACK BLACK Jack Douchebagnotfunny Black.
So the game will suck because the voice actor for the main character is Jack Black....What about a story, the gameplay, the setting and the rest of the awesome stuff?
Don't try to reason with people who say "butt hurt". That's like trying to explain astrophysics to an infant. They just bubble up their spit and shit during the conversation.