Okay but the entirely of the Gaza strip was displaced, by force. This historically happened. It happened for 15 months. Most of this thread is an extensive documentation of literally all of that happening. And the people involved with the negotiation directly said there was no right to return promised, which is part of why they turned him down. At this point you're just denying reality.
Sure, because "right of return" was not something the US or Biden can guarantee, only Israel and Netanyahu. And the latter certainly wanted to expell as many people as he could geht away with.
Yes, no disputing that here. This mass internal displacement occurred over many hundreds of routes, without borders or bottlenecks, and without a single starting or end point.
Well, one side of the negotiation said that, and the other side said they would have that right.
Indeed, that's why I said this happened.
Well the end point was the southern tip of Gaza, specifically Rafah. They were all rounded up and put at this camp. Concentrated, if you will. All they needed at that point was for the Rafah border to be opened.
Biden proved himself thoroughly untrustworthy during this whole affair, if he ever said he was securing a right to return, and other people in the negotiation said he was lying, it's best to assume he was lying. As Satinavian points out, the real arbiters over whether they'd be able to return or not is Israel, and these 15 months are proof that the US would never contradict Israel.
These internal evacuations were essentially orders. They issued orders, gave (tiny) timeframes, and then proceeded to bomb the areas. The movement was largely left to those leaving, rather than rounding them up or organising it themselves. The result was chaos, which I suspect was partly what the IDF intended.
Like I said, I'm not taking him at his word-- I'm making this point because you appeared to be arguing that Biden's /stated intent/ was the same as Trump's in denying right of return.
He didn't come with a hand drill. He came with the wrecking ball. Biden provided the weapons. Biden provided the support. Biden even supplied troops. All he had to do was open the border to 2000 people a day and Gaza would have been drained if nobody else (this is key, someone else) stopped him. These are the actions that happened. You can justify this in your mind all you want, but you have to deny reality to do so. Your entire argument hinged on 2000 people a day taking too long, and it would take less than 1 presidential term. That should be you reevaluating your position. Instead you've doubled down to minimize what Biden did. And before you get to "I've said Biden did horrible things", you've also just stated that him helping commit a genocide is the hand drill to some else's wrecking ball. You are very actively minimizing what he's done right now.
What has this got to do with you laundering Trump crimes?
These are the guys that said that Obama killing 1500 people with drones and Trump killing 3000 in half the time are the exact same amount of evil
What am I laundering? Or is this another one of those circumstances where you guys don't understand that when I shit on Democrats, that's not me taking the sides of Republicans? Do I need to spell it out again?
There are still 1.8 million to kill. There's a lot more escalation to be had
The bombs etc are not the hand-drill, because right now we are specifically discussing the role of the evacuation route. The minuscule size of that evacuation route, and the immediate dropping of that request, are the hand-drill. They indicate the scope of what was expected from that route.
No, I categorically did not state that. We are talking about the intended role of the evacuation route specifically. Whether it was intended to accommodate 2.2m people or not.
3 years. 2.2 million in 3 years ignoring all other attrition. That's not miniscule. That's you not understanding timeframes. That is you downplaying what he tried to do. You are in fact making genocide apologia.
Everyone likes words, apparently. Trump never said he'd kill them all, he said he'd relocate them.
That's very slightly better. What happens when they don't want to go?
Yep. Does Trump sound like he going to stop?
