No... one of the people 'interviewed' in the movie theorized that those were workmen (er, workaliens) and because of that were subservient and didn't even know exactly how their own technology worked. Imagine that instead a cargo ship full of illegal immigrants were transported through THE TWILIGHT ZONE and into a dimension of highly advanced aliens, and they might have the same view of humans as you have of the Prawns. (Plus, if the concept of free will was entirely foreign[footnote]Man, I really struggled not to use the word 'alien' here.[/footnote] to them then Christopher Johnson wouldn't have tried to put a stop to the 'invasion'. (If you say that he maybe 'learned' that trait from humans, you didn't pay attention. He says he took 20 years to collect the amount of fuel he needs. 20 years is how long the ship's been stranded on Earth, so he was doing that from day one. Back to my magical cargo ship analogy, even though most of the people inside are ignorant and can't even explain how the cargo ship they are on works, there might be a few who, despite being poor and uneducated, are intelligent and can figure out more than their simpler travelmates.)CJ1145 said:I'm not following. We are very, VERY different from the Prawns. As far as we can tell, the entire concept of free will is new to them. They just do what they are told by people they believe to be in charge.Ryokai said:I loved the original movie. By showing us how humanity treats the aliens, we learn about ourselves and the lowest levels we can sink to. Also, the movie successfully portrayed aliens that were very much like humans, but different looking (and with a crippling addiction to cat food), and how in the end we were not so different.
I see your point, but Christopher Johnson was well-documented in the movie as being the "exception" among the Prawns. If you will notice, excluding himself and his son the aliens are very complacent, to the point of simplicity. Those that aren't are simply feral. What you describe as coincidental gaps in intelligence, I describe as evidence of a caste system amongst the Prawns. The leader caste, represented by Christopher Johnson, would not be used for menial labor, and thus would be in far smaller numbers aboard the ship, the rest being relatively mindless workers. This is given further evidence by the only other truly intelligent creature being Christopher J's son. This would imply their castes are genetic, passing on their characteristics that are best suited to their task.The Random One said:No... one of the people 'interviewed' in the movie theorized that those were workmen (er, workaliens) and because of that were subservient and didn't even know exactly how their own technology worked. Imagine that instead a cargo ship full of illegal immigrants were transported through THE TWILIGHT ZONE and into a dimension of highly advanced aliens, and they might have the same view of humans as you have of the Prawns. (Plus, if the concept of free will was entirely foreign[footnote]Man, I really struggled not to use the word 'alien' here.[/footnote] to them then Christopher Johnson wouldn't have tried to put a stop to the 'invasion'. (If you say that he maybe 'learned' that trait from humans, you didn't pay attention. He says he took 20 years to collect the amount of fuel he needs. 20 years is how long the ship's been stranded on Earth, so he was doing that from day one. Back to my magical cargo ship analogy, even though most of the people inside are ignorant and can't even explain how the cargo ship they are on works, there might be a few who, despite being poor and uneducated, are intelligent and can figure out more than their simpler travelmates.)
Exactly. The aliens did cringe before a lot of humans, but then wouldn't you if you had a gun pointed to your face? The fact is, I found the alien behavior to be very human.The Random One said:No... one of the people 'interviewed' in the movie theorized that those were workmen (er, workaliens) and because of that were subservient and didn't even know exactly how their own technology worked. Imagine that instead a cargo ship full of illegal immigrants were transported through THE TWILIGHT ZONE and into a dimension of highly advanced aliens, and they might have the same view of humans as you have of the Prawns. (Plus, if the concept of free will was entirely foreign[footnote]Man, I really struggled not to use the word 'alien' here.[/footnote] to them then Christopher Johnson wouldn't have tried to put a stop to the 'invasion'. (If you say that he maybe 'learned' that trait from humans, you didn't pay attention. He says he took 20 years to collect the amount of fuel he needs. 20 years is how long the ship's been stranded on Earth, so he was doing that from day one. Back to my magical cargo ship analogy, even though most of the people inside are ignorant and can't even explain how the cargo ship they are on works, there might be a few who, despite being poor and uneducated, are intelligent and can figure out more than their simpler travelmates.)CJ1145 said:I'm not following. We are very, VERY different from the Prawns. As far as we can tell, the entire concept of free will is new to them. They just do what they are told by people they believe to be in charge.Ryokai said:I loved the original movie. By showing us how humanity treats the aliens, we learn about ourselves and the lowest levels we can sink to. Also, the movie successfully portrayed aliens that were very much like humans, but different looking (and with a crippling addiction to cat food), and how in the end we were not so different.
OT: I do not believe putting the words 'sequel' and 'unique' in the same sentence will ever constitute a truth, unless the words 'never' or 'impossible' are between them. A sequel by definition is more of the same. That said, if there's a movie out there that I would be hopeful for the sequel it's this one.
"christopher johansen"T-Bone24 said:How did noone see this coming? The first one ended on an obvious sequel hook or two. Hang on.
Christopher Johnson said that he would return in three years, a reasonable time for a sequel to be produced and lo and behold it has, and with reinforcements. Boom, you have your setup.
The new alien residence is called "District 10", so boom, you have your title.
There's a man in red standing just behind you.McNinja said:Unexpected? Now I'll be expecting the unexpected. They can't tell us to not expect something then expect us to not expect it.
In short, District 9 was a fantastic movie, and I have high hopes for the sequel.