This comes to no surprise. Ever since i heard they were ACTUALLY going to make one, I knew it wasn't going to exceed expectations.
However, do note that most expectations basically reach the moon and have cracked its inner core (or whatever the moon has inside).
If the game was made maybe 4-6 years ago, an average game would have been tolerable. The fans would say, "Ok, it's not bad, but they can improve" and if they were given even 4-6 years to make another game, they could fix the flaws this one would have.
Unfortunately, what I'm going to see is the companies that made it (Sorry, i don't study this) going under, and we'll never see a true Duke Nukem EVER again. Like the Sonic franchise, it will live on... but only as a mask for mediocre games so they can produce more revenue.
Of course, if the World goes loopy and awesomely good for everyone, and money is no longer an issue and we can eat all the Nutella we want without getting fat, then a faithful Duke Nukem will be released.
I personally love the way Zhukov put it. I was almost fooled to think it actually was Yahtzee.