Am I really the only person who thinks the 3D Sonic games were fun?
I enjoyed some of them too and was a bit baffled by how some people were badmouthing 2006 or the Black Knight one without even seeing them played. Word of mouth of the single kiss from a person, or simply the TITLE for the latter was enough for it to be entirely condemned. And the others, the true fans that bought them anyway? True fans are never happy. =P
Personally, the original games were good for the time, but even back then I thought it was kinda samey after 3 games. It was a mascot for a system that has since died and is only going on longer than the other dead mascots because of the fans that are at the same time, eviscerating it on a constant basis. Even if there was a pure return to the roots, ala the New Super Mario Bros/Wii thing that mario did...would that really be all that great? A step back MIGHT satisfy SOME nostalgic fans, but I don't see it doing all that well on the whole.