Final Fantasy 13, I have never enjoyed the story so much in a game. I was seriously emotionally attached to the characters. And I also enjoyed the combat, anyone who says all you have to do is mash the autoattack button never got to any fight harder than the very basic ones. If you didn't set up your characters and time your heals and buff you cannot beat some of the enemies.
Mirror's Edge, I didn't know people hated until reading this thread. One of my favourites games, just absolutely breathtaking and rather moving in story and gameplay.
Too Human was such fun, I put a ton of time in there to grind up to the best gear and almost 100% it, loved the aesthetics and I ACTUALLY LOVED THE GAMEPLAY. Couldn't go back to it though, after coming back to it I couldn't enjoy it again unfortunately.
Also, LoZ Wind Waker is by far and away my favourite 3D Zelda despite the hate it seemed to gather.