Dragon Age 2, which is easily my GOTY. No, it's not perfect. No game is. Everyone creaming themselves over Skyrim have to admit that the dialogue is hilariously basic and the bugs are astoundingly high. However, to them, those things don't matter as much as the freedom and flow of gameplay. Same for me and DA2. One man's deal breaker is another's whatever. DA2's flaws are mostly all things that don't bug me much, and its strengths are all things that are top of the list in importance for me.
Also, I loved most of the series to varying degrees, but Final Fantasy XII is easily and without contest my favourite of the entire bunch.
It used to really bug me that nobody else likes the games I do, and all the really big name popular games seem to whoosh over my head audibly. But truth be told, I've mostly stopped giving a shit. So long as the stuff I like keeps getting made, I don't really care what everybody else thinks about it, and I wish everyone the best with the stuff I don't give a crap about that they love.