No game is above reproach, and I tend to be pretty tolerant towards contrarian views on games that I've liked. There are a few that I belive don't recieve the recognition they deserve, but that is balanced by the games that I've played that don't deserve the acclaim they receive. I legitimately enjoyed both mirror's edge and deadspace for example and both of those games are regularly talked about in disparaging terms (usually for being short).
One thing I absolutely don't like to see however, is when a game the silly elitist bashing of popular titles. WoW might not be the game for everyone, but when someone tells me it's a bad game I have to wonder what sort of reality they live in - afterall, millions upon millions of people have paid to play the game, and it seems consumers are pretty savy when it comes to purchasing entertainment items. In spite of major hype and a huge budget, Battlefield Earth was an absolutely horrid film. After the first crowds cleared out the movie nosedived its way into the pages of history as one of the biggest flops ever. Were WoW a legitimately bad game, I would think that it wouldn't have enjoyed it's years of success.
So, for the most part I'm not going to defend any game to the death. I'll correct factual errors when I see them, I'll tell people what I think about a game and I'll most certainly make a comment when some elitist jerk-bag tries to gain some e-respect by trashing a popular game with bland and baseless arguments.
DrDeath3191 said:
The Conduit. Too many of Yahtzee's yes-men have taken his review of the game seriously, and a great game suffers for it.
I don't excactly think his review is lying, nor would I consider the Conduit a "great game". It's a solid game for the platform, yes, but I'm fairly tired of the apologetic boilerplate of "for a wii game". The game allows for immense customization in the controls, but straight out of the box the game can charitably be described as "clumsy". The design and pacing of the game are nothing special, seeing as the mechanics have already been done (and done pretty well) in Metroid Prime. The story exists, but I never found it terribly compelling. In short, the only thing the game does to set itself apart from any of my many options for FPS games is that it exists on the Wii.
This leaves me in an unfortunate position. If I compare it to other games of the current era, the game seems at best slipshod and fairly dull. It is only when I tack on the boilerplate of "for a wii game" that I can be charitable. There simply aren't many games like the Conduit on the Wii, and for this reason alone the game has it's merits. I would recommend it if someone was looking for a shooter for the Wii, otherwise I'd likely never mention the game to anybody.