IamGamer41 said:
arc1991 said:
IamGamer41 said:
So they do intend to retcon previously straight characters into bisexuals.Lame Bioware.very lame.
And what's so bad about that? That means there are romance options for all players...
I honestly do not see how that is bad thing...
In the first Mass Effect Kaiden turns down the male shepard if you try and romance him.Also The same is said for Ashley.So now they all of a sudden swing both way? No I don't think so.
Those are both established characters.Its going to screw with the story as well as peoples immersion,especially the ones who have ported the same Shepard from ME1 to ME2 and into ME3.
This is my only objection to games making all romance options available to all player characters. Some people are straight, some are gay, some are bi; that's reality. A gay man won't suddenly fall for a straight woman just because they see the "I AM THE PROTAGONIST" sign on their shoulder. Similarly, even if you approach someone of a compatible preference, there's always the chance of being rebuffed. So even if the entire supporting cast of Mass Effect turn out bi - implausible and unimmersive in itself, quite aside from being out of character for about three quarters of the love interests - I'd want to see at least one of them say "Sorry, Shepard, I see you more as a brother or something... it'd be weird."
Bottom line: character is key. Just as you can't suddenly decide Ashley had a Turian best friend at school or a Quarian girlfriend in college, you can't say "oh, and Ash is bi now, have fun".
(EDIT: Also, as a lifelong RPG player, I find the roleplaying possibilities quite interesting. Imagine playing a frustrated Shepard - he's fallen for one of his crew, but that crew member either doesn't like guys or does and doesn't like
him. No romance option - but a romance-related roleplaying option. It could affect the outcome just as much, maybe even more.)
I mean, I get the idea. There are gamers of all stripes, playing characters of all stripes, and everyone should be able to have a romance option that suits them. But I can't help but think that it diminishes the characters
and cheapens the very option they're trying to introduce.
"Hmm... someone gay might play this. But hey, sexuality is basically just wallpaper, right? We'll just redecorate Kaidan so he now likes guys too."
Okay, maybe Kaidan's a bad example, particularly given the porny lighting and setup of the "I shall now go and talk to Kaidan" scene when talking to him on board the Normandy in the first game. But the point stands - most people's sexuality is utterly integral to who they are; not the main thing that defines them or something to be worn on one's sleeve, but vital nonetheless. Retconning characters like that just makes it look like Bioware think it's something that doesn't really matter, something that can be changed to appeal to a bigger market share.
The characters are established. Ashley is straight. Kaidan is (theoretically, but dubiously) straight. Liara is... well, the blue lot (I can't believe I've forgotten what that species is called) are a special case. Jack's definitely bi, and so on. There are so many options available to a player already - they don't need to change existing characters to make them fit.