Jimquisition: Too Cool To Be Cool

Balobo

New member
Nov 30, 2009
476
0
0
ShadowKatt said:
Drake666 said:
ShadowKatt said:
Espsychologist said:
Jim fails at funny again.
I agree whole heartedly. I believe there was even a poll that asked the escapist if they wanted to keep this feature, and the highest vote was "NO".

And here we are, so poll = petition, and no one takes internet petitions seriously.
You know, if you watch his show, you're saying to the Escapist that you want to see more... it's the same thing if you watch shitty movie, play shitty video games or go to a bad restaurant...

A petition means nothing if there's no intention behind it :)
So, just ignore it and it'll go away? I don't know why I didn't think of that, it works every time, right? Try ignoring me, see if I go away. The point here being that if youwant change, you have to take an active part, so I will continue to speak out against it.
So you're basically an annoying protestor that won't shut up until they get their way?

Are these videos really hurting you? Why do you want this to be taken off so badly, it's not like you are being forced to watch it every time it comes out. It's not like it's restricting your abilities to enjoy this website or anything. You personally disliking it doesn't mean that it's ruining the whole site. Please just jump off your high horse for a second.
 

kikon9

New member
Aug 11, 2010
935
0
0
I don't see why everyone hates Jimquisition so much. If you don't like it then don't watch it. Seems simple.
 

Sharalon

New member
Jan 19, 2011
321
0
0
I don't think that duke is supposed to be taken seriously, but you when you say it... Randy pitchford always seemed a little too... Into it when is was talking about duke.

I really like the show, and it's good that you made it clear for all the stupid people that you are a little bit sarcastic.
 

Inkidu

New member
Mar 25, 2011
966
0
0
Jim has got a fair point. I'm not big on the whole "ironic" thing. However, I won't say it wouldn't work. Maybe this is why I don't like Duke Nukem... it takes itself seriously.
 

Servantes

New member
Jul 12, 2010
54
0
0
I have to thank you for putting some thought into Sonic, because I personally just gave up on him after Sonic Adventures 2, I thought about it once for a good 2 hours " how can they fix sonic..." and came up with nothing.

As for Dante he came off as a great character who evolved into what I think he was meant to be, I mean think about his character for a moment, his mother was a priestess and his father was a demon general, he killed his own brother who went crazy for power and only thing he has for "friends" is a hot demon chick who looks like his mother and another hot chick who often wants to kill him, I always waited for the moment he would just snap and go demon on people.

Its no surprise he comes off as insane or ridicules at times.

I am a fan of The Duke, but you have a great view point of his persona kind of out of date.

I think way too many people are acting like they never seen a self-centered wisecracking womanizing asshole.....maybe they haven't.... probably why so many people are pulling their hair out asking WHYISTHISGAMECOMINGOUTOMG?! is because they just cant comprehend his attitude.
 

ProjectTrinity

New member
Apr 29, 2010
311
0
0
This is actually my favorite episode so far. It has the Sonic mention, the Dante mentioning, someone mentioning that Duke isn't as grand as others make him out to be (Who cares: If you're buying the game, you think he's good enough), and a complete knockout on those who take your persona/attire seriously. I thought that was the best part.

Though I still get the feeling that a "games as art" argument may very well be the place where we disagree the most.
 

Keava

New member
Mar 1, 2010
2,010
0
0
Hristo Tzonkov said:
I think it's kinda sad the way he's portrayed in DNF.I actually agree with Jim in that aspect because DN is much akin to Johnie Bravo.Except nobody takes Johnie seriously whereas Duke is taken seriously in his own world.That made Johnie so likable because he was some super satire,Duke is supposed to be the same.Getting sucked off by 2 schoolgirls is wrong in a lot of countries as well.

Unless the game is there to fulfill everyone's self desires of being a douchebag who's not only awesome but gets everything he wants.
Err. Wait, which countries exactly, except of course the ones ruled by religious doctrines, in which majority of games would actually be illegal? If i recall correctly "school girl porn"makes up big part of porn overall. Dressed like schoolgirl is not the same as underaged....

Now as for the Duke part, why wouldn't he take himself seriously in his won world? It's not like you relaly interact with many non strippers/monster sin that game. You don't have the reference point of "world treating Duke".
It's a game where over the top action hero goes to blow aliens up, throwing around cheesy one liners and acting extremely sexist towards women. If you don't see the satire on manliness, action flicks and American Way of Life there, then i'm not sure if we played the same games.

Satire, as a genre, doesn't have to be funny in "straight-forward" way at all, it often isn't even meant to be, it's all about throwing random food for thought in a very exaggerated and ludicrous form. One of most known satirical works is "Gargantua and Pantagruel" and i doubt many of people here would find it tasteful or overly 'funny'.
 

Harry Mason

New member
Mar 7, 2011
617
0
0
So... A character has to be actively screaming "WHURR DURR, I'M A MACHO COOL MAN BUT NOT REALLY 'CUZ I'M REALLY LAME! MY LEGS ARE MADE OF PURE LIQUID IRONY!" or have some snarky character cutting their jokes down constantly in order for Jim to think that they're funny? The very fact that Duke is played so unrelentingly straight is what makes him funny!

A minority of people not understanding and taking things too far contributes to the comedy. Steven Cobert is funnier BECAUSE there are people who actually think he's a Republican. Having an outside voice reminding the audience of the central joke constantly MURDERS any merits something has in the first place.

It like telling any joke...

(Comedy begins)
"How many surrealists does it take to screw in a light bulb?"
"I don't know! How many?"
"FISH."
(Comedy ends)

At this point, the comedy as ended for 90% of your audience. If someone didn't get it, they get left behind. It's too bad, but you have still gotten a laugh out of most of your consumers.

If you stand there after you finish the joke and go "Well, you see, 'surrealism' is an artistic movement where things not making sense and being out of place is kind of the point. You were expecting a number of people to be the punchline, but instead it was something random that made no sense!" People will lose interest and you've LOST 90% of your audience at that point. It's why laugh tracks have fallen so far out of style. If you need to be REMINDED why something is funny, it wasn't funny in the first place.

Once again, awful show, awful argument and central point, awful and forgettable personality, awful presentation, awful, ham-fisted attempts at irony... Just BAD.

Boo.

I do like the glasses better this week, though.
 

camazotz

New member
Jul 23, 2009
480
0
0
Damnit Jim, here I was hearing about your name from sites like GJAIF and coming to the conclusion you must be all that's wrong with gaming journalism today....and then you have to go and do something so freakin' brilliant like this that I have to officially say I am a fan now. Great stuff! And right on the money too with Duke Nukem....helps to explain why I don't now, nor have I ever cared for this character.
 

ShadowKatt

New member
Mar 19, 2009
1,410
0
0
Balobo said:
ShadowKatt said:
Drake666 said:
ShadowKatt said:
Espsychologist said:
Jim fails at funny again.
I agree whole heartedly. I believe there was even a poll that asked the escapist if they wanted to keep this feature, and the highest vote was "NO".

And here we are, so poll = petition, and no one takes internet petitions seriously.
You know, if you watch his show, you're saying to the Escapist that you want to see more... it's the same thing if you watch shitty movie, play shitty video games or go to a bad restaurant...

A petition means nothing if there's no intention behind it :)
So, just ignore it and it'll go away? I don't know why I didn't think of that, it works every time, right? Try ignoring me, see if I go away. The point here being that if youwant change, you have to take an active part, so I will continue to speak out against it.
So you're basically an annoying protestor that won't shut up until they get their way?

Are these videos really hurting you? Why do you want this to be taken off so badly, it's not like you are being forced to watch it every time it comes out. It's not like it's restricting your abilities to enjoy this website or anything. You personally disliking it doesn't mean that it's ruining the whole site. Please just jump off your high horse for a second.
Ah, so now having a poor opinion of something is simply having a superiority complex(the "high horse") you refered to. I dislike the Jimquisition, but you offend me with your accusations.

No, I'm not being forced to watch it, but whether you like it or not(which I'm sure is heavily the 'not') I'm just as much a part of this community as you are and I have just as much a vested interest in this site maintaining a certain standard of excellence that I feel the Jimquisition does NOT stand up to. That's why I speak out against it, because when you compare it to other columns like Extra Credits and The Big Picture, it falls very short in terms of contant and presentation.

And I'm not alone. It's not one person that isn't satisfied with this kind of content on the site.

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.287959-Poll-do-you-like-jimquisition
 

camazotz

New member
Jul 23, 2009
480
0
0
Harry Mason said:
So... A character has to be actively screaming "WHURR DURR, I'M A MACHO COOL MAN BUT NOT REALLY 'CUZ I'M REALLY LAME! MY LEGS ARE MADE OF PURE LIQUID IRONY!" or have some snarky character cutting their jokes down constantly in order for Jim to think that they're funny? The very fact that Duke is played so unrelentingly straight is what makes him funny!

A minority of people not understanding and taking things too far contributes to the comedy. Steven Cobert is funnier BECAUSE there are people who actually think he's a Republican. Having an outside voice reminding the audience of the central joke constantly MURDERS any merits something has in the first place.

It like telling any joke...

(Comedy begins)
"How many surrealists does it take to screw in a light bulb?"
"I don't know! How many?"
"FISH."
(Comedy ends)

At this point, the comedy as ended for 90% of your audience. If someone didn't get it, they get left behind. It's too bad, but you have still gotten a laugh out of most of your consumers.

If you stand there after you finish the joke and go "Well, you see, 'surrealism' is an artistic movement where things not making sense and being out of place is kind of the point. You were expecting a number of people to be the punchline, but instead it was something random that made no sense!" People will lose interest and you've LOST 90% of your audience at that point. It's why laugh tracks have fallen so far out of style. If you need to be REMINDED why something is funny, it wasn't funny in the first place.

Once again, awful show, awful argument and central point, awful and forgettable personality, awful presentation, awful, ham-fisted attempts at irony... Just BAD.

Boo.

I do like the glasses better this week, though.
Well if it helps any, that's what I got out of his show: that the Duke is now having to remind us of why he's funny, essentially, and it shouldn't have to do that; it's telling us the same joke that's already been done to death a thousand times since, essentially...it needs comedic irony, something....anything!....to make it notable in some way today, outside of the fact that its a vaporware game finally coming to life.
 

Penguin_Factory

New member
Sep 13, 2010
197
0
0
I think you've got a point here with Duke Nukem, although I'm not entirely sure I agree with the specifics. Whether he's supposed to be an over the top parody or played straight, I just never found the whole concept funny. It's actually one of those situations where not only is it not funny, I'm not even sure what's SUPPOSED to be funny about it.

You'd totally right about Sonic though. Jesus, I can't believe there was ever a time when people thought Sonic really was cool. The 90's were a strange time.
 

camazotz

New member
Jul 23, 2009
480
0
0
kikon9 said:
I don't see why everyone hates Jimquisition so much. If you don't like it then don't watch it. Seems simple.
There's a pretty loud minority online that doesn't seem to understand that the best way to protest someone is to stop talking about them, stop listening to/watching them, and stop making them relevant by virtue of ignoring the subject of their ire.

Luckily, they go right on bitching about Jim and that makes him more relevant than he ever would have been if they had simply disregarded him entirely!

Honestly, the first time I ever heard of the guy it was on some web sites that regularly held him up as the poster child for all that is evil about the internet. Now that I've seen a few of his shows, I think its pretty safe to say that those people need to chill out and maybe focus on real problems in the Real World that deserve more attention than trying to smear Jim's own ironically besmirched name. The guy is a developing talent, he's not nearly as vile as his online persona makes him out to be, and he's got some decent observations....and I fully expect him to continue to get better and more polished at the webcast thing over time.
 

Hristo Tzonkov

New member
Apr 5, 2010
422
0
0
Keava said:
Hristo Tzonkov said:
I think it's kinda sad the way he's portrayed in DNF.I actually agree with Jim in that aspect because DN is much akin to Johnie Bravo.Except nobody takes Johnie seriously whereas Duke is taken seriously in his own world.That made Johnie so likable because he was some super satire,Duke is supposed to be the same.Getting sucked off by 2 schoolgirls is wrong in a lot of countries as well.

Unless the game is there to fulfill everyone's self desires of being a douchebag who's not only awesome but gets everything he wants.
Err. Wait, which countries exactly, except of course the ones ruled by religious doctrines, in which majority of games would actually be illegal? If i recall correctly "school girl porn"makes up big part of porn overall. Dressed like schoolgirl is not the same as underaged....

Now as for the Duke part, why wouldn't he take himself seriously in his won world? It's not like you relaly interact with many non strippers/monster sin that game. You don't have the reference point of "world treating Duke".
It's a game where over the top action hero goes to blow aliens up, throwing around cheesy one liners and acting extremely sexist towards women. If you don't see the satire on manliness, action flicks and American Way of Life there, then i'm not sure if we played the same games.

Satire, as a genre, doesn't have to be funny in "straight-forward" way at all, it often isn't even meant to be, it's all about throwing random food for thought in a very exaggerated and ludicrous form. One of most known satirical works is "Gargantua and Pantagruel" and i doubt many of people here would find it tasteful or overly 'funny'.
Well there's a difference between schoolgirl and women dressed as schoolgirls which was something I might've missed :p.

The point of Jims video was that.The world treating the character.Which is most important for an over the top character.I personally don't find the intrigue in Duke being himself and people being glad about him being himself.It's a really warped reality and you lose the satire and interesting likability about the character being flawed despite perfect.It slowly turns into a wank fantasy.
 

EchetusXe

New member
Jun 19, 2008
1,046
0
0
Jim seems to have confused cool with comic. It is the essence of comedy to have a man think he is cool/smart/charismatic when is actually uncool/dumb/uncharismatic. The tragic clown. We love them because they are tragic, we find them funny because everyone likes to laugh at the pomposity of an arrogant fool. The best example of this is Rigsby in Rising Damp.

Anyway, where was I? O yeah, Jim has a point that it is very difficult and foolhardy to say 'let us make a story about a cool character who goes around doing cool things and everyone thinks hes cool'. It is much easier to have a supporting character as the cool guy, because we see less of him. You follow someone round long enough and the lose their mystery and 'coolness'. Hobbes said every man must sleep and so therefore no man is invincible (I'm paraphrasing). It much the same way, nobody looks cool on the john (toilet).

I guess James Bond is the inspiration, forever cool and forever a murdering wiseass womanizer. But Bond has class, Nukkem has no class whatsoever. No class, no humour, no style - how can he still be cool? Actually Schwarzenegger is probably the inspiration. But at least he had a funny accent.

So make Nukkem Austrian and keep the same script? Yep.

^ I just typed a complete pile of shite but oh well.
 
Apr 24, 2008
3,912
0
0
The humour in Duke Nukem is too dry?

It's pastiche more than it is parody anyway, so it makes sense for the delivery to be fairly straight.

Duke is fine, I definitly don't want him to be just another idiot-savant character, that's seriously been done to death in recent years.