DrunkOnEstus said:
You'll hear no dissent from me. I knew in my heart that Fallout 4 would simply take the advancements from Skyrim and dump the Fallout art and weapon kit all over it, but I still hoped that it would show Bethesda's next technology for creating the open worlds that made them famous, not a continued refinement of the very technology that did the same. The animations are so robotic, the "God Rays" were one of only a few advancements that made one pretend that it could trade blows graphically with a Witcher 3, Far Cry, or even an Assassin's Creed, and the level of jank that permeates everything really should be unacceptable.
I've often said the same but have been told I just don't understand that, "The jank is what makes Fallout great!" I'm not sure I agree with that sentiment, but to each her/his own. Who am I to dictate what people should like?
With the massive reduction in RPG elements, F4 really does end up competing with something like Far Cry, and it's unbelievably obvious that the technology limits every possible thing the game attempts. Granted, it's probably the reason that modding is so simple in these games (as well as their modular file structure and code design, but I'm not a modder), but at this point it isn't enough to keep the old dog around. I imagine that if any game released with Gambryo not named ES/Fallout and not released by Bethesda, it wouldn't receive the excuses and "slides" that FO4 got, it wouldn't be enough that "the community will come together and make it great, even on Xbox one", and it would only be considered a notch above such fare as Two Worlds 2 or Bound By Flame.
Thing is, there are engines just as 'mod friendly' as Gamebryo. Some even more so. There's no meaningful, technical, or creative advantages to Gamebryo. I suspect its continued use is a combination of familiarity and a fear of change, both from Bethesda and within the modding community.
I could be far off the mark, of course. I can't really say for sure. What I
can say, though, is that Bethesda could achieve so much more with
Fallout and
Elder Scrolls if they'd just drop that needlessly antiquated engine.
I don't know why I have an extended diatribe for every offhand comment here, but I'm enjoying it.
Passion for the topic, maybe?
I don't know, but the reason doesn't really matter as long as you're enjoying yourself.