Er...who said the gameplay of STALK--er...Metro 2033 was bad?
Names. Give me names! I must break their windows with bricks. :|
Seriously, Metro 2033 was a (admittedly linear) masterpiece, simply because it was atmospheric, the graphics were amazing on high-end machines, the guns handled like they probably should in the real world, and the combat was just plain fun.
Admittedly, there were a lot of problems plaguing it...like the fact it was terribly linear and there were some interesting game mechanics that weren't actually implemented much in-game: for example, the Ghosts and the Anomalies. Sure, they're in certain sequences...but largely non-existent throughout the rest of the game.
But...seriously, this game was gold, and worth every penny I spent on it. If Metro 2034 is going to be even better, then Duke Nukem Forever can kiss my ass for all I care, it'll be my vote for GOTY.