GrandmaFunk said:
it's beyond you? you don't get why some ppl would prefer fresh game play over unending rehashes of the same formulas and IPs?
it has nothing to do with being cool or edgy, I just wish there was more variety and creativity within the industry and the press that covers it.
Such a sentiment is beyond me because your logic is flawed at a very basic level, since you seem to imply that a sequel cannot be fresh or innovative, and that all sequels are rehashes of the same formulae. I fail to see how this is a valid statement, as there are tons of sequels that build upon their original to create something wholly new and creative that could not be achieved with a stand alone entry in a new IP. This argument does not imply that ALL sequels fall under this category, mind you, but it is outright foolish and simply wrong to somehow believe that sequels cannot present someone with a fresh experience, or that they cannot be creative in themselves. The exact reasons that you posited as to why new IP is important can be garnered from a sequel just as effectively.
Thus is why I cannot help but to cast serious doubt upon your overall assessment that it is "unhealthy" to have a large number of sequels. I fail to understand this belief that a fresh experience cannot be delivered via sequel for the exact reasons I outlined above. Even further, sequels have been a "proven" business model, in which a publisher and developer can assuredly make a solid return on their product. I fail to see how publishers and developers engaging in techniques that will assure that they can continue to make games, and perhaps even make "new IPs," is considered unhealthy. If anything, that is the signs of a very healthy industry, speaking from a purely business perspective.
Ultimately, video games aren't really movies... they're different media. Video games are significantly sequel dependent: the industry always have to be quite forward. It's simple blind nostalgia to somehow deny that this industry has always had a significantly greater affinity towards sequels than other comparable media. The conclusion I cannot help but to reach is your disdain towards sequels is unjustified. Despite the fact that you deny it, I cannot help but to feel that your hatred of sequels is done out of the pure motivation to be "edgy" or "cool," as I previously cited.