I stuck this in the Facebook comments a while back when the video went up, but I realized I should probably start sticking my comments here more often. So yeah...
----
You know.. I love the Jimquisition and I'm always using it as an example of someone saying things I've been wanting to say but in a better, more intelligent way, cause you have such a way with words and it is certainly nice to see someone summing up things I want to say so easily....but I don't agree with this at all.
I -liked- the happy end for Newt, Hicks and Ripey in Aliens. Considering all the hell she'd been through I wanted to see her finally get away and move on with her life, let someone else carry the torch, as it were. Perhaps because most horror films have horrible or stupid endings, I felt Aliens was superior for not only ending on a positive note but making it look like the survivors had something to look forwards to: a new life together.
Alien 3 pisses all over that, but that isn't the only reason I didn't care for it. The alien had none of the presence or fear that the previous ones had - probably because of the crappy CGI - and when the movie came out the editing made sure that a number of scenes made absolutely no sense. No, you can't defend it by saying, "Oh, but the Director's Cut/Special Edition shows how it was supposed to be!" because by then it's too late. That's like in Star Trek: Generations where the writers explain away some of the plot holes in their commentary - it doesn't help the movie cause it wasn't IN it.
I thought the cult angle felt like a weak B Plot, tacked on to give maybe one person a little more development which ultimately came down to "I'm a murderer and rapist, and damn proud of how things work around here, so don't rock the boat, *****." It probably didn't help that it was playing onto stereotypes by having it be the only black man with a significant role.
As for the guy pouring his backstory out to Ripley? Kinda felt like padding, especially since he's up and killed off making me wonder why we bothered getting to know him, anyways. I know that's probably pretty shallow and I admit that until he is killed you don't have any reason to think he's not important. I think it might've been better if he'd died in a different way besides, "Whelp, told you about myself, time to die and set up another scare scene."
I do want to say that I loved the Alien figures and how they had different animal types and the Flying Alien Queen and so forth. It's just a shame that all those things never made it into an actual movie where they might've been awesome to see on screen - not that they would've done it without CGI, making the whole effect look crap, sadly. Really, the scene at the end where Ripley accepts her "fate" and casts herself into the fire felt a lot like Alien as a franchise casting itself into the abyss. Probably why it took so damned long for us to get another film; they had to wait until the bad memory faded from enough peoples minds and the series got popular again.
As an aside, I'd really like to see your Freddy vs Jason review. Although I thought the movie was ridiculously laughable and impossible to take seriously, I didn't actually think it was bad.. just that it failed at being scary and more than once I found myself shouting at the characters for being utterly stupid.
----
You know.. I love the Jimquisition and I'm always using it as an example of someone saying things I've been wanting to say but in a better, more intelligent way, cause you have such a way with words and it is certainly nice to see someone summing up things I want to say so easily....but I don't agree with this at all.
I -liked- the happy end for Newt, Hicks and Ripey in Aliens. Considering all the hell she'd been through I wanted to see her finally get away and move on with her life, let someone else carry the torch, as it were. Perhaps because most horror films have horrible or stupid endings, I felt Aliens was superior for not only ending on a positive note but making it look like the survivors had something to look forwards to: a new life together.
Alien 3 pisses all over that, but that isn't the only reason I didn't care for it. The alien had none of the presence or fear that the previous ones had - probably because of the crappy CGI - and when the movie came out the editing made sure that a number of scenes made absolutely no sense. No, you can't defend it by saying, "Oh, but the Director's Cut/Special Edition shows how it was supposed to be!" because by then it's too late. That's like in Star Trek: Generations where the writers explain away some of the plot holes in their commentary - it doesn't help the movie cause it wasn't IN it.
I thought the cult angle felt like a weak B Plot, tacked on to give maybe one person a little more development which ultimately came down to "I'm a murderer and rapist, and damn proud of how things work around here, so don't rock the boat, *****." It probably didn't help that it was playing onto stereotypes by having it be the only black man with a significant role.
As for the guy pouring his backstory out to Ripley? Kinda felt like padding, especially since he's up and killed off making me wonder why we bothered getting to know him, anyways. I know that's probably pretty shallow and I admit that until he is killed you don't have any reason to think he's not important. I think it might've been better if he'd died in a different way besides, "Whelp, told you about myself, time to die and set up another scare scene."
I do want to say that I loved the Alien figures and how they had different animal types and the Flying Alien Queen and so forth. It's just a shame that all those things never made it into an actual movie where they might've been awesome to see on screen - not that they would've done it without CGI, making the whole effect look crap, sadly. Really, the scene at the end where Ripley accepts her "fate" and casts herself into the fire felt a lot like Alien as a franchise casting itself into the abyss. Probably why it took so damned long for us to get another film; they had to wait until the bad memory faded from enough peoples minds and the series got popular again.
As an aside, I'd really like to see your Freddy vs Jason review. Although I thought the movie was ridiculously laughable and impossible to take seriously, I didn't actually think it was bad.. just that it failed at being scary and more than once I found myself shouting at the characters for being utterly stupid.