Ehh, not amazing or scary, but it honestly made me pause the game and think about what had just happened.
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood. I was walking alongside Machiavelli, holding the button down to keep myself incognito, when I accidentally brushed a woman who would not get out of the way-- stupid me, forgot that if you brush past someone while incognito, you rob them --and Ezio's arm shot out and hit her right in the fun zone. The gained-money sound hadn't happened, so she must not have had any Florins. Continued walking, listening to Machia--
.... wait, what?
I stared at the screen for a few seconds, paused the game, and asked myself what the fuck had just happened between bursts of horrified laughter. My sister asked what was wrong when she entered the room, and what else could I say?
"I... think Ezio just punched that lady in the crotch."