The problem is that you're reading pro oppression and human rights abuses propaganda from Seanchaidh, you may as well trust Houseman on the US elections.Looks like they agree with the lunatic fringe who think pandemic control measures are communism.
Here's the full article for context: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/12/business/china-zero-covid-policy-xian.html
Here are some examples from the article as to why they condemn the China way:
"In the northwestern city of Xi’an, hospital employees refused to admit a man suffering from chest pains because he lived in a medium-risk district. He died of a heart attack.
They informed a woman who was eight months pregnant and bleeding that her Covid test wasn’t valid. She lost her baby.
Two community security guards told a young man they didn’t care that he’d had nothing to eat after catching him out during the lockdown. They beat him up."
Do you agree with letting a woman lose her baby because her test wasn't valid?
Do you agree with someone dying needlessly from a heart attack because he lived in the wrong place?
And do you agree with beatings?
If not you agree with the article from NYT. If yes, you agree with Seanchaidh.