Poll: Top 5 games of all time, no mean comments
- Thread starter Dutchy115
- Start date
I've got to admit, I found the sequel much more enjoyable, the bulked out the experience with muscle rather than fat (understand my metaphor) And overall, the puzzles were much more elaborate and well thought out.Sirron Kcuch said:
The story was exceptional to boot
I very much doubt any of those would make my list.
I'd probably have gone crysis, LoZ OoT, company of heroes, warcraft 3/dota and morrowind (in no specifc order)...Mirrors edge just missed the cut, it was a fantastic concept but the top 5 are pretty much limited to the perfectly executed games I've played.
I'd probably have gone crysis, LoZ OoT, company of heroes, warcraft 3/dota and morrowind (in no specifc order)...Mirrors edge just missed the cut, it was a fantastic concept but the top 5 are pretty much limited to the perfectly executed games I've played.
I have too many games which I love, but these are my top five:
5 - Deus Ex + Human Revolution (amazing amazing games indeed)
4 - Diablo 2 (so many hours of my life spent on this, hours well spent indeed)
3 - Portal + Portal 2 (no explanation needed)
2 - Age of Mythology (great when I was 12, still great, best RTS ever)
1 - Half Life 2 + Episodes (dude.... of course)
Minecraft would come close, as well as Team Fortress 2, Left 4 Dead, Star Wars Battlefront 2 and Crash Bandicoot 1, 2 and 3.
5 - Deus Ex + Human Revolution (amazing amazing games indeed)
4 - Diablo 2 (so many hours of my life spent on this, hours well spent indeed)
3 - Portal + Portal 2 (no explanation needed)
2 - Age of Mythology (great when I was 12, still great, best RTS ever)
1 - Half Life 2 + Episodes (dude.... of course)
Minecraft would come close, as well as Team Fortress 2, Left 4 Dead, Star Wars Battlefront 2 and Crash Bandicoot 1, 2 and 3.
Uff, it's hard to choose just five games from my quite big collection. Those that spring to mind first are;
God of War 2
The Saboteur
Assassins Creed II
Ratchet & Clank
Final Fantasy X(apart from Tidus and Yuna it blew me away)
God of War 2
The Saboteur
Assassins Creed II
Ratchet & Clank
Final Fantasy X(apart from Tidus and Yuna it blew me away)
Woah! Kill the motor dude...I don't recall criticising the taste of anybody's choices, that's because games that people deem good enough to place in their Top 5 tend to be great regardless. The mention of COD in the Original Post was just a playful example for my whole "Don't be a douche" thing that I wanted to put in place here.Yosharian said:
I find the Mass Effect trilogy, the Pokemon games (up to Gen 3, before they started all looking like Clowns) and Assassin's Creed II and Brotherhood to be really good, as such, I placed them in my Top 5. It's weird that you jumped to the assumption that I was bagging on everyone else's choices before you read anything in the thread, and even if it was true, for you to then go on to bag on my choices is just disgustingly hypocritical.
I've got to admit, you're list is substantially good (i'm only drawing from my experience, i.e. the ones i've played)
In no particular order
Tekken 3 - My god the fun
Burnout 3 - Yes, I know, a racing game. But give it a go, you wont regret it. The amount of time I spent on this game was unbelievable, and all of it was utterly joyous.
Oblivion - This game consumed me. Always have a special place in my heart.
Crash Bandicoot - Fantasticgasm.
Portal 1 & 2 - Need I say more?
Tekken 3 - My god the fun
Burnout 3 - Yes, I know, a racing game. But give it a go, you wont regret it. The amount of time I spent on this game was unbelievable, and all of it was utterly joyous.
Oblivion - This game consumed me. Always have a special place in my heart.
Crash Bandicoot - Fantasticgasm.
Portal 1 & 2 - Need I say more?
post="9.348281.13867408"]
It seems to me that you've played very few really good games, and hence are just picking a bunch of mainstream stuff that you happen to have played.
But ok, I was exaggering a bit perhaps. All I'm saying is that AC2 is really not that hot.[/quote]
Oh my God, do you hear yourself? This is not WHAT ARE THE TOP FIVE GAMES EVER MADE AND SHERPADURP?
This is:
I was making a joke to make my request for peace in this thread more acceptable by the masses, I personally love CoD, and if someone had it in their top 5, as indeed someone did, I wasn't going to say "Idiot, CoD is crap, etc. etc.", I said that in my original post as a warning for no one to be abusive in any way
Don't reply, you're wrong, it's best that you accept that now before you embarrass yourself further trying to prove otherwise
But if you do, do yourself a favour:
READ.
THE.
FREAKING.
POST.
PROPERLY.
Dutchy115 said:
Mass Effect 1 is an ok game, not even close to top 5 games of all time. I can't really comment on Pokemon in all fairness. Assassin's Creed II is similar to Mass Effect - fairly good, but not anywhere near top 5.
It seems to me that you've played very few really good games, and hence are just picking a bunch of mainstream stuff that you happen to have played.
Um.. actually, I have =pDutchy115 said:
But ok, I was exaggering a bit perhaps. All I'm saying is that AC2 is really not that hot.[/quote]
Oh my God, do you hear yourself? This is not WHAT ARE THE TOP FIVE GAMES EVER MADE AND SHERPADURP?
This is:
Dutchy115 said:
You read that right? Once more, reread it "BUT LET'S NOT ABUSE THEM"Yosharian said:
I was making a joke to make my request for peace in this thread more acceptable by the masses, I personally love CoD, and if someone had it in their top 5, as indeed someone did, I wasn't going to say "Idiot, CoD is crap, etc. etc.", I said that in my original post as a warning for no one to be abusive in any way
Don't reply, you're wrong, it's best that you accept that now before you embarrass yourself further trying to prove otherwise
But if you do, do yourself a favour:
READ.
THE.
FREAKING.
POST.
PROPERLY.
Baldur's Gate 2
Final Fantasy X
Fallout 3
Bioshock
Deus Ex:Human Revolution
I feel like Mass Effect 3 will soon be fighting for one of those spots.
Final Fantasy X
Fallout 3
Bioshock
Deus Ex:Human Revolution
I feel like Mass Effect 3 will soon be fighting for one of those spots.
Well I had to pick Jak 3 in the poll because it is quite possibly one of the best platforming games of all time.
My list would be something like this:
-GTA San Andreas
-Red Dead Redemption
-Baldur's Gate II
-inFamous
-Jak 3
-Fallout 3
I know thats six but fuck you if you don't like it, I can't pick any less. I could easily pick more if I really thought about it.
EDIT: I forgot Metal Gear solid, there needs to be a MGS game in my list. Either MGS 3, MGS 4, or MGS Peace Walker. I can't decide which, but one of them most go in the list.
My list would be something like this:
-GTA San Andreas
-Red Dead Redemption
-Baldur's Gate II
-inFamous
-Jak 3
-Fallout 3
I know thats six but fuck you if you don't like it, I can't pick any less. I could easily pick more if I really thought about it.
EDIT: I forgot Metal Gear solid, there needs to be a MGS game in my list. Either MGS 3, MGS 4, or MGS Peace Walker. I can't decide which, but one of them most go in the list.