I'd say the Xbox 360, because I prefer it as an all rounder. Fine, it may die on you at some point (I had the RRoD after Christmas, but MS gave me a free replacement, so I don't see why there's a Hate Microsoft bandwagon...), but the chances aren't exactly high and if it does survive then you get a better gaming experience. The PS3 is only for people serious about having the best graphics and most powerful system, while the 360 is better for those who value gameplay more. Both have good and bad points, so don't let the fanboys tell you what to get (note, any fanboys who are going to/have already flamed, leave now). Overall I'd say Xbox 360, but if you want a more powerful platform then by all means go for the PS3, even if it will cost a bit more.