Scientists Work on Force Fields for Tanks

A Pious Cultist

New member
Jul 4, 2009
1,103
0
0
darkknight9 said:
I'm extremely skeptical. An applied current can generate a magnetic field strong enough to deflect a warhead before the shaped charge has properly impacted and had a chance to form yes, but it would take a hell of a large capacitor to produce the kind of voltages needed to deflect any projectile that is coming in at rocket speeds. The timing I'm certain could be perfected... but one rocket followed immediately by another would be a very bad time to find out that you don't have enough juice to get the job done.
Surely the energy needed to deflect a fast-moving projectile would be more then enough to cause substantial damage to the rest of the tank, unless we're going to start making them out of plastic.
 

dalek sec

Leader of the Cult of Skaro
Jul 20, 2008
10,237
0
0
GrinningManiac said:
I would pay top dollar to see the look on the first Islamic fundamentalist insurgent who fires an RPG at that thing

It would be the perfect mix of "Buh?" "That's not supposed to happen" "WTF" and "Holy Crap, our entire army's tactics just went out the window"
This so much, I would love to see their shock/horror at the fact that the tank is still rolling towards them. Now we just need to replace guns with laser based weapons and we have a pretty bad ass weapons platform, either that or can we make those titans from Warhammer 40K?

All jokes aside I wonder how much something like this would cost in terms of building it, mounting it on a tank and seeing if it would drain too much power from the tank as it does it's job or how many rounds could it take before the shields would give out.
 

Calatar

New member
May 13, 2009
379
0
0
Syon said:
Twad said:
Well, time will tell if its cost-efficient to implement those "shields" or add an extra layer of armor plating.
Or whether it's physically possible. Seriously, how does one manipulate electrical energy to create a solid shell?
You can't. It's impossible. The idea is that a sudden pulse of charge to the hull would create an EM wave that would slightly alter the trajectory of the RPG, hopefully enough to prevent damage to the crew.

I am extremely skeptical that this actually makes sense. I'd wait for a demonstration before I believe it. Can an EM pulse really alter the trajectory of a large, partly-metallic, mostly non-ferromagnetic projectile?
 

Teddy Roosevelt

New member
Nov 11, 2009
650
0
0
sravankb said:
Whose idea was this?

"Hmmm, those middle-eastern countries, they have some really fancy weapons and we need to be a 100 steps ahead of them so we can conquer them before lunch."
You don't understand warfare, do you? All war, no matter who are fighting, is all about being 100 steps ahead, all the time.

Anyway, this idea seems far to inefficient, Slat armor is already being deployed, which is simply sturdy metal cage which crushes the RPG as it comes in, preventing it from detonating effectively, if at all. Of course, it isn't 100%, but where do you get batteries to power electromagnetic pulses like that, and you'd also need to make your tanks with radiation hardening to stop the pulses from screwing up our oh-so important computers. Otherwise, you can't aim well, or navigate, or anything that we want to be able to do.
 

razerdoh

New member
Nov 10, 2009
248
0
0
Aby_Z said:
Please tell me they plan on calling this an AT field...
Absolute Terror Field ... would love that lol


Personally when i read it i was thinking "Phase shift armor"
 

Aphroditty

New member
Nov 25, 2009
133
0
0
Pillypill said:
formless777 said:
That doesn't sound like it will work. I hope it isn't tax dollars wasted.
Well it won't be, it's a British arms company.
Most of which are private, so maybe BAE systems are doing this.
So it would be tax pounds being wasted then, right?

You guys should go over to euros just so us Americans can talk about tax dollars, since saying tax pounds sounds awfully silly to my ears. :p In any event, the scientists discussing this work for your Ministry of Defence, which means your government would be funding any development.
 

Davrel

New member
Jan 31, 2010
504
0
0
Captain Pancake said:
And It's British! this almost salvages my national pride!
Ditto - but don't worry, something embarrassing will happen when/if we ever get around to using them, it has to.

MurderousToaster said:
I remember earlier that these guys were also developing invisible tanks. Maybe they could combine the two, but just make invisible "shield generator" vehicles that could ride ahead of the rest of the personnel/vehicles and protect them from incoming warheads.
You have been playing too much Supreme Commander!

OT: Tanks just got more awesome - this is a good day.
 

Prometherion

New member
Jan 7, 2009
533
0
0
All well and good, but someone will invent a RPG made of wood and where will we be then?

Cant help feeling this is an invention to minimize friendly fire incidents.
 

Asehujiko

New member
Feb 25, 2008
2,119
0
0
Logan Westbrook said:
The system involves covering vehicles with a thin cloth-like supercapacitor material which would use a stored electrical charge to generate pulses capable of pushing back dangerous projectiles like RPG rounds, which require a huge amount of traditional armor to properly protect against.
So it's going to be hideously expensive and break beyond the possibility of field/forward base repairs after somebody as much as scratches it with a bayonet/regular bullet/shrapnel from the rpg you just bounced into the ground in front of you? Sure, let's revive the Landkreuzer project while we are at it.
 

Latinidiot

New member
Feb 19, 2009
2,215
0
0
Twad said:
Well, time will tell if its cost-efficient to implement those "shields" or add an extra layer of armor plating.
ah, but if you take weight and gasoline in consideration, I think it just might be.
 

MurderousToaster

New member
Aug 9, 2008
3,074
0
0
Davrel said:
Captain Pancake said:
And It's British! this almost salvages my national pride!
Ditto - but don't worry, something embarrassing will happen when/if we ever get around to using them, it has to.

MurderousToaster said:
I remember earlier that these guys were also developing invisible tanks. Maybe they could combine the two, but just make invisible "shield generator" vehicles that could ride ahead of the rest of the personnel/vehicles and protect them from incoming warheads.
You have been playing too much Supreme Commander!

OT: Tanks just got more awesome - this is a good day.
Wait what?

That's in Supreme Commander?

I don't even own a SupCom game.
 

Sallix

New member
Apr 9, 2008
291
0
0
High tech electromagnetic fields?

Philadelphia Experiment all over again?