@Aero:
Yeah, the "You've" was my attempt to keep the finger not pointed at me. Not thinking at all that I screwed up in the next sentence by revealing that Beer was who I saved. Like I said, this is the first time we've had the medic save someone so I wasn't quite sure how it was going to work, and the fact that we announce it was cool. That combined with a busy work day got me slipping up.
After last round, I'm must less willing to trust random spy lists, it would be nice if the other person came out and revealed their 'message' from the spy too. then Caramel and whomever could be safe. Then I
might trust Caramel's list.
Realistically your list is suspect too because no one else would have thought to do that so we just have to take your word for it.
I'm not outright accusing either of you, I've just learnt my lesson to question free information...
As for me, yeah I've kinda screwed us because now we're stuck in a situation were do we trust me as the medic, or do we kill me off to prove I'm the medic get me rezzed next round (I assume I can still save people next round right? or do I have to wait until round 3 if I get brought back up?) the risk being that then we lose the priest, and if the spy gets nabbed we can't bring him back (not a huge risk but it is there). If what Caramel says is true then that's okay as the spy being dead with a list of 6 (since king is dead) people is easy enough to work through. If we rely on you being right too we're down to 4
But if Caramel is lying then we have 14 people based off your list, or 18 if we don't trust either of you. (I mean you two could technically be in on it together, but I don't think that's the case, I'm sure at least one of you is being truthful. if not both, I'm just not willing to blindly devote myself to it like I did last time.)
gritch said:
While not conclusive we can at least assume Demagogue was logged in and active at the time the Killer assigned his second target. The time spacing seems to be consistent with Demagogue being the Killer.
If he's the Medic I'm sorry but I'm going to have to vote for you too.
Dammit gritch I was typing! lol
Anyone who looks at my posting history in these threads can see I am quite active during the day (EST) at least on work days, heh. And yeah I posted shortly after the save, because again, we got to save someone for the first time in 4 rounds, I was excited.
If it is the group consensus to kill me to prove my innocence then so be, I'll vote for me too. I just didn't want to waste the priest until we knew some of this 'information' we've got is legit.