Caved in and picked it up tonight. I was a bit concerned about whether I could 'git gud' enough without flinging my controller in frustration at the nearest wall, as I had never played a Souls game before, but I have to say, only two bosses in and this is rapidly turning into one of my favorite titles. The combat, I find, has this great mix of pre-battle strategy where you try as best you can to ascertain the situation- how many enemies, their types, best angle of approach and/or opportunities to draw some of them away- as well as 'Oh crap crap crap crap' quick dodging when, inevitable, some brilliant plan of yours fails and you find yourself trying quite vigorously not to die. The elation I feel for conquering opposition that I was CERTAIN was going to obliterate me is almost addicting. @_@ Interestingly, even though I am technically far more dangerous a fighter in Shadows of Mordor, as Talion is a wraithly demi-god of a warrior, playing my Hunter in Bloodborne makes me feel infinitely more badass, because it feels like I'm clawing my way past insurmountable odds.
Also little touches. Naturally, your clothes get soaked in crimson blood after a vigorous slaying, but not all of the enemies bleed red, and that will be reflected in the stains on your laundry. After cleaving my way through half of the Central region, then slaughtering my way through the sewers, then back up top to chop my way across the bridge towards the second boss, I was a veritable mess of red and green blood.