The Cool Kid said:
Section 103.4 states that you need to provide evidence that the site is "dedicated to theft". Which part of the Bill suggests that any post on a forum could be accused of causing a site to be dedicated to theft?
As you claim to have read the bill, you should know that (103.a.1) "An internet site is dedicated to theft of US property if it... is marketed by its operator for use in, offering goods or services in a manner that engages in, enables, or facilitates" copyright infringement. It took me five minutes to find this.
IANAL and neither are you, but my high school English comprehension skills tell me that this paragraph means that any site that in any way allows the even possibility of copyright infringement can be called a site dedicated to theft under SOPA. Is it possible to make a forum post that infringes copyright? Yes, of course it is. Therefore, all forums are dedicated to theft according to the SOPA definition.
And actually Section 103.5 states that the site can counter any actions taken if it, under penalty of perjury, has good faith in that it is not a site dedicated to theft.
Which is fairly pointless when you acknowledge that the definition of a site dedicated to theft covers pretty much the entire web.
Also, 103.4 and 103.5 are not even parts of the bill. Paragraph designators take the form "number.letter.number", not "number.number".
Paragon Fury said:
If was being accurate and honest, he would say "Chinese thieves" since they are the biggest problem in piracy and IP protection. But because he can't do that without pissing the Chinese off, so he says the ambiguous "foreign" instead.
But SOPA only applies to sites that can be accessed from the US. So it'd be fairly trivial for a Chinese site whose users are mostly Chinese to circumvent SOPA simply by blocking access to IP addresses in the US.
He's using the "foreign thieves" codephrase obviously to mean the Chinese, to play on voters' fear of an expanding China, but that's not what SOPA is really about.
Exile714 said:
I wish I could properly explain how the US Congress works to The Escapist community. How many of you actually know what markup is?
I'd look it up on Wikipedia, but...
Robert Fuller said:
from http://www.google.com/landing/takeaction/community/
Thank God that I Can Has Cheezburger? is taking a stand for freedom.
Also, Torrentfreak. What's a torrent site doing on that list?
Aeshi said:
Does anyone else find it funny that all these websites, in their haste to protest SOPA, are essentially doing its job for it by getting rid of their own content?
I think that's kind of the point. They're saying "this is what the web will look like if SOPA passes".