SL33TBL1ND said:
You're kidding right? Seriously people, there's no such thing as an illegitimate tactic, and anyone who claims that there is, including Treyarch, are complete idiots. The only tactic worth having in a game is "Win." If it's possible to do this in the game you should do it. If it's possible to do anything, within the games inherent rules, that means you win you should do it.
If the rules of the game inhibit alternative strategies to the point where only one or two strategies can win at all, it defeats the point of the gameplay therein.
This is called a "Degenerate Metagame", and it saps the depth from the game by limiting the viable strategies.
A game with no depth is a very shallow experience, no matter how much you "Win".
The only reason people would enjoy such an experience is if they derived pleasure from griefing others, which is more akin to bully-logic, not one of competition (thus eliminating the "legitimacy" of such wins).
Of course, this particular example from Black Ops isn't a case of a degenerate metagame (though it demonstrates how it could turn into one); the match was rigged, there was no competition.