Closet Superhero said:
[
'We' didn't do anything. 'We' weren't victimised by 'them' before 'we' enslaved 'them'. The issue is that, RIGHT HERE AND NOW we live in an unequal society, with the determinants of that inequality being strongly associated with race. And the question is, why is that the case? Is it because some races are better than others? Or is it because of historical circumstances? If you're not racist, it is obviously that latter, and the issue becomes: how do we redress the problem. That is 'OUR' problem and our responsibility, and the abolishment of slavery does not diminish that responsibility. The Abolishment was just words anyway; it didn't magically make black and white people socially or economically equal.
Words are the easy part. So let's not congratulate ourselves too much. Besides, don't the glorious principles of freedom and equality get plenty of celebration as is? So what exactly are you complaining about, again?
Actually, yes we were victimized by "them" beforehand, everyone victimized everyone else. It was western, white, civilization that wound up putting an end to this kind of thing. Your basic arguement is that the thousands of years of slavery before the US shouldn't count because it's inconveinent to your arguement, and the simple fact that it was white civilization that ended slavery runs counter to what you want to believe... and there are a lot of people just like you, there is a whole political power block based around exactly that kind of ignorance which makes it difficult to unravel.
As far as the rest goes, equal oppertunities were made availible. There was never any pretension that black america was going to be suddenly uplifted into the upper 1% of society and be given all of the same things white folks had, merely that they would no longer be held back specifically because they are black. Being a minority group, they are not likely to ever have the same level of prescence or prominance in a country within the US due to simple numbers. Representation in general accordance with the population does not mean a 50-50 split with the majority, not to mention that it's a capitalist society where things are earned, not simply given by the goverment through a form of communism or socialism. Nobody walks in, takes your stuff, and gives it to someone else to be fair (well, not usually, but we won't get into exceptions like Enimant Domain and the like).
What problems we see right now are not so much racial, as cultural. Like it or not racism is dead as a mainstream phenomena. People can have their lives and careers ruined by the mere hint of associated racism, that kind of prssure doesn't happen without majority support.
The problem is when your looking at a situation where Black America feels it's entitled to things it is not. It's formed a series of counter cultures based around the idea of entitlement and forcing society to adapt to it, rather than adapting to fit in with society. People literally line up to give Blacks oppertunities, with books, computers, money, etc... all being funneled into inner city schools and such. The problem is that those things are intentionally targeted and destroyed. Becoming educated and joining others in the 9-5 job grind as a normal person is considered to be selling out and "beneath" blacks. You see an attitude where it's either being a thug, or being super rich, and nothing in between. The
so called "git rich or die trying" attitude, that has kids all reaching for basketballs in the vain hope of getting into the NBA despite all odds, as opposed to reaching for a
textbook and say aiming for more reasonable goals like say one day making middle management at a hotel or whatever after years of effort... you know, like where most people wind up.
Guys like Bill Cosby (who has a PHD In Children's Education, which is why I take him seriously) have talked about this at length, even if it hasn't gone over well with everyone. The usual excuse is that he's over simplifying very complicated issus, when in reality they aren't complicated issues, they are VERY simple issues with clear problems behind them. In the end it all comes down to Black America deciding that becoming educated is not "selling out" and to work towards assimilating into society. Nobody can force this, ultimatly it's
up to them to either take the oppertunities that have been presented, or continue to deal with the problems they bring upon themselves.
At any rate, I *DO* think there are things that can be done. Truthfully I think one of those things is to stop encouraging a black/white cultural divide. I feel the idea of things like "Black History Month" are counter produtive because by it's very nature it draws a dividing line, and businesses that harp on this and use it for advertisement when it's going on and such don't seem to help.
My suggestion about there being a "be thankful for white people" week, albiet not under that name, is actually well considered, as it blurs that division, and also tends to mitigate some of the messages of more extreme black leaders and icons that come up during this celebration, where "Black History Month" could be seen more as "Black Empowerment" or "Bash Whitey" month in some of the associated media that makes problems worse.
Overall where everyone is learning about iconic black contributors in school and through speeches, ads, and the media, blacks can also themselves be reminded that whites, rather than being the enemy, were insturmental in the end of slavery, this was not, and could not have been accomplished by the black people alone.
In school for example do a week where kids are expected to create and read a report on a white person, or heck even just a person who wasn't black, that was insturmental to civil liberties or had a positive influance on black culture. This *IS* a part of black history, and a part that doesn't involve direct enimity... you know like "here is my umpteeth report on Malcolm X".
As Martin Luthor King Jr. himself kind of pointed out, winning the battles was not the hard part, adapting into society is.