Yomandude said:
Going slightly off topic, I read a comment where someone mentioned notpron.org. So, being as inquisitive as I am, I moseyed on over to that site... and I'm already stuck. That crap makes these riddles look like "why'd the chicken cross the road?"
I've gotten approximately 30ish pages into this one. There is also: thisisnottom.org
Both are quite good, but very abstract and cryptic. We considered going that route (and perhaps we'll get there on day 5), but we decided that people who really like and are really good at puzzles will still enjoy ours - and people who are discovering puzzles/riddles like this for the first time wouldn't get discouraged by the necessity of making a half-dozen intuitive leaps to find part of a clue that might lead to an answer.
That's not to say we didn't come up with some of those though
Picking which puzzles to present, and in which order to present them, was almost as hard as designing them in the first place.
This had gone well so far, so I can't see why we wouldn't do it again at some point.
-LS