mm2publish said:
Yeah. I certainly hope not because we would all look like crap if he did! Did you hears what he just said about "Monsters"? I can only imagine what he would say about some of our stuff!
He criticized the writing and acting, though - he wasn't all that critical of the cinematography. Not to mention that, even though it was an indie director, he was still a "professional". Most (if not all) of the entries will be from amateurs; the same standards don't necessarily apply, if but for the fact that "Monsters" benefited from a studio presence, something most (if not all) amateurs don't have access to. With getting into too much more detail (how many of the videos had even 15 grand to throw around? That's a lot of money for a lot of people), even an indie film like "Monsters" is thusly in a much larger playing field than most Escapist entrants.
Keep in mind I don't mean to impugn anyone's efforts in the video contest. I used "amateur" and "professional" in their dictionary senses.