coldfrog said:
Casimir_Effect said:
Oh man, it's so hard to pick a favorite, but I think Deadhouse might be it - the cohesiveness of Coltaine's story and the way the whole tale played out was amazing, and this is also the book that pretty much sets up the rest of the future events in the series. It puts so many of the major players in place for what is coming. I need to finish that series... or at least what's available. And then read Esselmont's books.
Nevertheless, probably the best book I own would either be Catch-22 or Pratchett's Small Gods. Both have been read so much I've gotten second copies.
Everything with Deadhouse just clicks. And while Gardens of the Moon comes first that book is so damn confusing because Erikson just drops you into the world. There is no explanation of
anything. After Gardens though, Deadhouse is able to expand more and things start to become clearer. And like you said, it introduced so many of the main characters and plot arcs which will influence the later books.
The only book which can clearly compete with DG is Memories of Ice. It has the same great pacing and tragic bent to it. And it can also be thought of as book 2 of the series in a sense because both it and DG follow on directly from GotM, taking place simultaneously. Saying that, while books 2 & 3 are my favourites I also love the later ones. Bonehunters and Reapers Gale are great because so much happens in them (which unfortunately means they get a bit lost sometimes), House of Chains and Midnight Tides are excellent for following on from DG in a well written and mature way, and introducing a whole new continent. And the two latest ones showcase a very different writing style from Erikson which grew on me really fast. That's also when a LOT of stuff starts to come together in his convergences.
The Esslemont books are pretty good. Return of the Crimson Gaurd is better than Night of Knives in my opinion, because it feels more like a Malazan book - epic. NoK all takes place i nthe space of one night. An important night in the history of the Empire, but it still feels a bit confined and confusing. But I'm looking forward to his future ones. And the final one from Erikson. You have no idea how much I'm looking forward to that one - book 10.